During times of great volatility in the stock market, a lot of people will turn to high-yielding money market funds to stash their funds. Yet late last month, I wrote a column – “Your safe money might not be so safe” -- observing that in some cases, money market funds might not be so worry-free themselves.
I highlighted one money market fund at brokerage Charles Schwab -- Schwab Value Advantage Money Fund -- as an example of the type of fund that has in the past obtained a significant amount of its yield from investments in commercial paper issued by troubled banks’ structured investment vehicles.
Schwab spokesperson Sarah Bulgatz disagreed with my assessment of the fund. Here is her response:
“It is a mistake to imply that all structured investment vehicles (SIVs) have subprime mortgage exposure. In Schwab's case, our money market funds have no direct investment in subprime mortgages or collateralized debt obligations. We do hold a small percentage of highly-rated SIVs, but these SIVs themselves have very limited exposure to subprime. As of January 2008, Schwab’s taxable, non-government money market funds have less than 3.7% of their funds invested in SIVs, and these SIVs themselves have on average less than 1% of their investments in subprime. That translates into less than 0.04% of Schwab’s money market portfolios indirectly exposed to subprime. Since our money market funds are all managed similarly, the percentage of SIV holdings within each fund are close to the average. To say, as the column does, that "If you … keep cash in the Schwab Value Advantage Money Fund you have had a sub-prime time bomb ticking away in your brokerage account," is simply not true.
Read More...
