That $350 billion sure didn't last very long - Top Stocks Blog - MSN Money
 
Search Top Stocks:

That $350 billion sure didn't last very long

Posted Dec 03 2008, 01:22 PM by Minyanville
Rating:

Just 60 days ago, Congress allocated $700 billion in TARP money to rescue the financial system, half of which was available immediately. Now, according to the Wall Steet Journal, Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson may ready to ask for the second half.

If he does, he's likely to face stiff opposition on Capitol Hill. A recent Government Accountability Office report rebuked the Treasury for insufficient oversight and staffing to ensure the money it has already poured into banks like Goldman Sachs, Bank of America, JP Morgan and Morgan Stanley is achieving the intended goals.

Meanwhile, Congress is eyeing the remaining bailout funds for other uses. First, and most immediately, lawmakers are likely to spring for an aid package for floundering automakers General Motors, Ford and Chrysler. The Big 3 said yesterday it would take $34 billion to save them from collapse.

Lawmakers are also pushing for more help for homeowners. The debate over loan modifications and how best to prevent foreclosures has intensified in recent weeks, as banks, loan servicers, investors, academics and regulators squabble over the best solution.

FDIC Chairman Sheila Bair has advanced an aggressive plan for the government to share potential losses with banks and streamline the modification process. Critics, however, argue Bair's program -- currently being stress-tested at failed California thrift IndyMac -- is falling short of lofty expectations and that claims of it's successes are overblown.

Compounding the complexity of deploying the bailout money is the transition to a new presidential administration. The Journal reports the Obama team is in close communication with the Bush administration, but is shying away from taking the lead in negotiations.

It's all but certain the $700 billion Congress allocated to prop up the financial system will simply be round one of a widescale capital infusion into American banks. Eroding economic conditions, falling consumer confidence and the ongoing credit contraction will continue to result in heavy losses for financial institutions across the country.

A broad-based stimulus package due to be announced on inaguration day is likely to include more help for troubled banks.

Still, short of outright nationalization, Washington is powerless to force banks to start lending again. Economic recoveries are typically spurred by an expansion of credit, making it cheaper for firms of all types to borrow, spend and start growing again. This time, however, banks won't part with their precious dollars for fear loans won't be repaid and losses will continue to spiral.

As well they should: Defaults across loan categories are rising as the economic malaise spreads up the credit spectrum. American consumers, strapped for cash and credit alike, are cutting back, reining in the rampant spending the propped up the domestic economy.

The road to recovery will be long, and not without potholes and hairpin turns, but it is a road nonetheless. As Toddo often says, "In order to get through this, we have to go through this.

Top Stocks blogging partner Todd Harrison is founder & CEO of Minyanville.com. This post was written by Minyanville Contributor Andrew Jeffery.

Related Articles:

Convertible Bonds: An Investor's Best Friend

Why Should I Care: Timothy Geithner, Your Next Treasury Secretary

Wish Lists Shrink, Happiness Expands

Comments

 

This whole thing was, and still is, an ongoing version of a "Ponzi" scheme played out on a National, if not Global Scale!

Think about it, a Ponzi Scheme is defined by wikipedia as:

An advertisement is placed promising extraordinary returns on an investment – for example 20% for a 30 day contract. The precise mechanism for this incredible return can be attributed to anything that sounds good but is not specific: "global currency arbitrage", "hedge futures trading", "high-yield investment programs", "offshore investment", or something similar.

With no proven track record for the investors, only a few investors are tempted, usually for smaller sums. Sure enough, 30 days later the investor receives the original capital plus the 20% return. At this point, the investor will have more incentive to put in additional money and, as word begins to spread, other investors grab the "opportunity" to participate. More and more people invest, and see their investments return the promised large returns.

So, the "bailout" has bought into "Morgage-backed Securities" (see: "sounds good but is not specific" above). These "Morgage-backed Securities" also fit the definition of "no proven track record for the investors" yet were "TRADED" (NOT 'bought and sold", there is a BIG difference) all over wall street with no REAL record of any value at all!

It looks to me like it works like this: Remember the old "Popeye" cartoons? "Wimpie" promises "I'll gladly pay you Tuesday for a Hamberger today" so you go out and find 10,000 Wimpies and give them all their hamburgers on the promise that they'll "pay you tuesday". Now, you are quite sure that a small number of these "Wimpies" will actually PAY you on Tuesday, Somewhat sure some of the rest will pay you an Tuesday, and have serious doubts that a LARGE number of these "Wimpies" will not be able to pay you at all!

Are you with me so far? Now, take these "Wimpie" notes, bundle them all together in one big lump and go borrow money against it. The person that loaned you the money on this bundle of "Wimpie Notes" puts your bundle together with 10 other bundles of "Wimpie Notes" he's loaned out money on and Borrows money against those 10 bundles of "Wimpie Notes" from yet another person... and so on down the line until there are hundreds of these huge bundles of "Wimpie Notes" everywhere that everyone is borrowing against. Not buying or selling, just "borrowing".

The day finally comes when SOMEONE needs their cash, and they need it NOW! So they think, "I'll just cash in (call) this bundle of "Wimpie Notes". Only problem is that no one has any idea of what the bundle of "Wimpie Notes" is really WORTH. So, the person you're trying to Sell the bundle of "Wimpie Notes" to takes a look inside the bundle and sees --SUPRIZE! -- MOST of these "Wimpies" are NEVER going to be able to pay for their Hamburgers AT ALL!!! He then offers you 10 Cents on the Dollar for this bundle of "Wimpie Notes" and NOW THE PRICE IS SET FOR THE FIRST TIME!!! Guess what? Every bundle of "Wimpie Notes" EVERYWHERE that everyone has money tied up into has just found out that the best they can do is get back 1/10 of the value. Got a $10,000 "Wimpie Note" bundle that you've loaned out $10,000 on? The best you can do RIGHT NOW is get $1,000 for it. Only problem is you can only find someone that'll give you $800. OMG! Says everyone holding these "Wimpie Note" bundles, "We gotta SELL NOW!!" Only to find that they can't sell these "Wimpie Notes" ANYWHERE.

Now what, you ask? The Goverenment steps in with wads of OUR TAX DOLLARS! No matter WHAT, at it's most basic level, the US Taxpayer has just BOUGHT a CRAP LOAD of these "Wimpie Notes" on the promise that we will "Gladly" be "Paid on Tuesday"!!!

I guess if you can manage to pull off a BIG enough scam, it's not even Illegal! And this one is Freakin' GLOBAL!

I have yet heard of any one speak of the accountability issue of the downfall of the economy. All I have heard is we need to bailout the big three and all the failing banks. But on the other side I hear of luxury spa retreats after the bailout money arrived, 300 million dollars worth of bonuses handed out the upper management a week before filing for bankruptcy. Lehman brothers recieving bailout money and backing out on commitment. When will it end and all these CEO's and upper management get what they deserve ( ie.. Enron). The US goverment expects the blue collar, hard-working, barely making ends meet Americans foot the bill for the mistakes of greedy, self-centered, white collar workers and shut up about it. Assets need to be frozen and investigations need to begin, before they just hand out any more bail-out money. If not look out it will only get worse.

Note to Blue Collar Guy -- your right.  I am really tried of working and paying my way and now I have to help this crazys out when they are making Millions of Dollars per year.  Also, why is the United States giving Mexico $400 Millions to help them on their drug problem.  Seems to me that the US needs to help US Citizens.

IOWAGAL FOR PRESIDENT---------AND THE BIG JOB TO RULE CONGRESS!!!!! Could not of said it better myself!!!!!!!!!!!! Dont forget to fire Paulson!!

This is all bs. Im tired of everything. From big corps taking bailout money for bonuses to OPEC trying to cut production again to raise oil prices. Dont they remember just a few years ago when Oil was the same price it is now???? Why are they complaining. Someone needs to step in and tell Chavez and his crones to suck it up and change their budgeting.  Oh and the same with the big 3, they can all file chapter 11 for all im concerned. They need to kick UAW out of the house and put an end to the union. They are the reason our cars are so expensive. Take toyota and honda. They both have plants in the us and they are fine!!!  The big 3 needs to just go away.  Im 22 and me and my kids and their kids are going to have to deal with all the mistakes these big ceos have caused.

~1~

I think you're all correct and it was best stated by Justin From Tampa. This is all just bs. It was bs when they proposed the $700B bailout of the financial system. That was passed to buy up the toxic assets" of banks, not to buy equity positions in the banks. There is yet to be the 1st toxic asset bought or the 1st homeowner in trouble to get tossed a lifeline. It is bs that they should bailout the automakers. Amen to scraping the unions. The unions are like the fire department. Once upon a time there was a fire and labor needed representation to negotiate with management for better wages and better working conditions. The fire has been out for a long time now boys and you are just doing water damage. I'm not really certain how effective it is, but there are email contact links to every senator and congressman's office available on the internet. A massive email campaign to them directing them as to what "We the people" might like done for a change couldn't hurt and it may just do a wee bit of good. I also blame two other parties of significance for playing an active role in the financial dilemma that continues to unfold. The first is the media who harp on every morsel of bad news they can lay their hands on as often as possible. Is that the misery loves company theory at work? I find it most interesting that the media hammered the public with "cash is king" and "hoard your money" a couple of months ago. Hey, aren't they the same ones now reporting how soft Black Friday sales figures were? Hummm...any relationship here?  Nawww...probably not, huh? The second group is the consumers and homeowners. What does it take to teach some people how to live within their means? How about no groceries and no house? Still have the big screen TV though. Wonder if there are electric outlets under bridges? How about this pitch as a mortgage broker/councilor. "Yes, you have a full time job and asteady income. I understand that. You are a door greeter at Wal-Mart. No, you cannot afford a $450,000.00 house. Have you considered a mobile home? Single wide. Used. On a rented lot. That's what you can afford!

sad thing is that the so called Bush administration and Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson have already commited nearly $7 trillion toward the financial mess. Capitol Hills best bet would be to wait until next year with other $350 Billion, they have done enough for this yea.

The BIG 3 Car Companies need to face the truth.  We have already shelled out 25 billion dollars to them 3 months ago...they asked for 25 billion 2 weeks ago AND now they want 34 billion dollars????  C'mon if your ocmpany can't make it because of poor planning and a poor product then either face bankruptcy or get out of business.  Who's next to be bailed out???  Where does this all end???  It is the taxpayers money guys...let's use it wisely and not put a band-aid on companies whose CEO's earn millions each year!!!!   Hey there are thousands of businesses out there who are not as big but are trying to make it...why not help some of them or better than that ...what about US the taxpayer????

Oh, I almost forgot...can I deduct my portion of that $700B on my federal tax return for 2008?  Let's see now...$700 billion divided by...hummm...how many tax payers are there in the US?  Wonder if I'll have to use a schedule to amortize it over several years? Maybe I better get a pencil and some paper...

What good is it going to do to bail out the 3 car company's so they can stay running, when they get the bail out, what good is it going to do, when the price of everything else is so high, still no one will be able to buy a car because the prices are so high and the middle class is just barely making ends meet now, or not making ends meet. So where are the people going to get the money to buy the cars to keep them in business. Somebody needs to bail out the middle class.

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):