Are baby boomers the shallowest generation?
Posted
Nov 07 2008, 01:53 PM
by
Kim Peterson
Rating:
Baby Boomers are the shallowest generation, according to Seeking Alpha's James Quinn. Boomers have lived way beyond their means for three decades and have virtually bankrupted the capitalist system, he says.
"We have chosen to leave the heavy lifting to future generations in order to live the good life today," writes Quinn, himself a Baby Boomer.
Early in the first Reagan administration, Americans saved 12% of their income, and household debt as a percentage of the GDP was 63%, Quinn writes. But then the Boomers came of age and cast aside notions of saving, investing and living within one's means. This borrow-and-spend mentality was disastrous.
"The Boomer generation has freely made choices over the last quarter century that has brought us to the brink of a second Great Depression," he writes.
During the current Bush administration, he writes, the savings rate for households actually went below zero. Household debt as a percentage of the GDP hit 130%. Credit card debt has soared, as has the number of mortgage loans in default.
"We spend more eating out than we give to charity," he writes. "We spend as much on big screen TVs and stereos as we do on education."
Quinn goes on and on, and he got a lot of people riled up. In a rebuttal published today, Dennis Byron takes the author to task for failing to prove that it is specifically Baby Boomers (ages 47-62) living the high-and-wasteful life.
Baby boomers weren't saving in the 1980s because they were raising children, Byron says. And now, those children are raising their own children, causing savings rates to be depressed now. Byron questions some of Quinn's data, particularly the point that says Americans had a 12% savings rate in 1980. (I researched this and found that Quinn's data point is correct, as measured by the Federal Reserve).
I can see what Quinn is trying to do, but he doesn't tie it all together enough. If he wants to say that an entire generation has laid waste to the financial good sense that helped build this country, he'd better make a thorough case with proof of cause and effect. His research shows that something happened in this country when it somes to spending, saving and living within our means. And there are many, many reasons for that.
But laying it all at the feet of the Baby Boomers? That's a stretch.
Related reading:
Boomers mix business with passion
Retirement for the not-so-rich
Lessons from the Great Depression
Boomers' big inheritance: is it enough?
Should you bail out spendthrift parents?