Apple's accounting makes GAAP numbers worthless - Top Stocks Blog - MSN Money
 
Search Top Stocks:

Apple's accounting makes GAAP numbers worthless

Posted Oct 23 2008, 01:33 PM by Kim Peterson
Rating:
Filed under:

Andy Zaky of Bullish Cross is practically begging everyone to ignore Apple's GAAP numbers from now on. That's because Apple doesn't recognize iPhone revenue immediately under its subscription method of accounting. Instead, it slowly recognizes the revenue over a two-year period.

With Apple's red-hot iPhone sales, that means a huge chunk of revenue is missing from the GAAP numbers.

"This should infuriate the informed investor because it means that Apple is quite literally trading on P/E ratios that do not reflect more than half of its business," Zaky writes.

If you look at the non-GAAP figures, he writes, Apple's share price is trading at around 11 times trailing earnings and seven times forward earnings. At these numbers, almost no analyst could justify downgrading the stock (as some have done recently).

Zaky is also incredulous that people aren't talking more about Apple's cash hoard, which grew to $25 billion in the most recent quarter from $21 billion the quarter before. That's a $5 increase in total cash per share. 

"At this pace, and assuming Apple makes no big acquisitions, Apple could very well have nearly $48 per share in cash and cash equivalents by the time we hit November 1, 2009," Zaky writes.

Comments

 

I don't get it either.  Apple sold the phones.  Period.  It is the carrier, AT&T, who recognizes the revenue stream over time.

It's dumb and misleading.  But I imagine the well-paid accountants at Apple have a reason for it.  The real issue of the above article should be the question "Why?  Why is Apple doing this?"

maybe we should get back to worldcom! about time some sanity in recording profits.

AAPL has made this accounting procedure CRYSTAL CLEAR since before the first Q they reported iPhone sales.  CRYSTAL CLEAR.  If investors are too foolish to figure this out, they shouldn't be investing in the company.  Me, I'll buy when the price is $45 and they have $45/share in cash in the bank.   Keep downgrading and selling, boys.  Come to papa.....

Apple does recognizes the income this so that they may provide updates of the iPhone OS free of charge. It also helps evens out their growth. Any other way would have shown explosive growth in an unreasonable manner for calculating future P/E growth. This conservative way makes the growth impressive but not crazy!

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):