The United States of France? - Top Stocks Blog - MSN Money
 
Search Top Stocks:

The United States of France?

Posted Sep 23 2008, 03:12 PM by Kim Peterson
Rating:
Filed under:

Wikimedia Commons licenseOur beloved nation has become the United States of France. At least, according to Time's Bill Saporito, who sees the signs. The U.S. government has nationalized the financial system, and is about to "quasi-nationalize" Detroit automakers. National health care is a hot discussion topic right now. You know where he's going:

"Put it all together, and the America that emerges is a cartoonish version of the country most despised by red-meat red-state patriots: France. Only with worse food."

It's a cutesy way of getting at a bigger question. What happened to the be-all-you-can-be capitalism that America was built on? Wall Street rode that horse for some time, enjoying the freedom of a largely deregulated environment and engineering all kinds of whiz-bang financial tricks. The system worked until it got worked over, by the bosses on Wall Street all the way to the homeowners on Main Street.

So the government has intervened with a very heavy hand, and Saporito says it might not be a bad idea if we adopted some of France's nationalistic tendencies. After all, the French aren't dealing with crushing personal debt, subprime mortgages or even college tuition payments (college is free). All they had to do was accept massive income tax rates and no job growth.

"So yes, while we're still willing to work ourselves to death for the privilege of paying off our usurious credit cards," Saporito writes, "we can no longer look contemptuously at the land of 246 cheeses."

Image credit: Beth Lieu Song, GNU Free Documentation License

Comments

 

Freedom, liberty, equality, and no credit cards.... Sign me up!

Isn't college wasted on some people?  Hypothetically, if someone has an IQ of 83 and their most likely job prospects are flipping burgers, should they get a free college education?

Socialism is for scared sheep.  Wait!  Isn't that what Americans have BECOME since 9/11, needing Big Brother to protect them from the evil terrorists lurking around every corner?

Just put Obama on top, add in national health care, and we are so there!

Thanks Bernake! I can't wait to get behind the line of sheep walking off the cliff...

What happened to being American and taking risks? Freedom is now dead. Capitalism is on life support and the secretary of the treasury is trying to pull the plug. And all of us "Americans" are letting these morons get away with killing principles our nation were founded on!!

Atlas is shrugging.

Well the POINT is that now we pay MORE taxes than France and we do NOT have a national health care. So we pay more taxes WITH OUT the benefits!!! And may I also add we don't get 6 weeks of vacation either.

@ alan in baltimore:

  College is free in France.  But people with 83 IQs aren't going.  There are still academic admission standards for who goes on to college and who doesn't  Simply because its free doesn't mean everyone gets to partake.  The smartest kids still go the the best colleges, the smart kids go to college, and the not-so-smart kids don't go at all.  Y'know, its called "meritocracy" its just that in France its based soley on your academic ability as the money issue is taken out of the equation vs. America where its based on how smart you are PLUS how much money you have (or can get) ... the more money you have in America, the higher up the college food chain you get to go. In America, lots of money can "buy" you a trip to a college that is a step or two above what your actual academic ability is.

I think that Steve (above) summed it up best: "we don't get 6 weeks of vacation either."  We are witnessing America becoming the home of the Nationalized, Timid and Lazy... lazy at least when it comes to paying for your own mistakes... that's what the government is for. While the government fixes our problems we should all go on a 6 week vacation!

Having lived in the US for most of my life and now have moved to France and been there for now 3 years and I can tell you France is 100 times better. Many Americans are brainwashed by the  propagnada media to hate France . I myself hated France but now my eyes are open and now I am free unlike my fellow brainwashed Americans who are living in a prison but don't know it.

My uncle moved to France after he got married and from what he tells me it's like night and day. He claims he will never set foot in the US ever again. He says he wasted 45 years of his life living in a corporate slave world in the US and now he lives life. Now I'm going to visit and he tells me that after one month in France that i'll never return to whaty he calls is a "prison" country of corporate slaves.

@ Nathaniel, glad I'm not the only one who sees the paralells, but who will be our John Gault?

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):