The financial industry: Yeah, it's that bad
Posted
Jan 18 2008, 07:12 PM
by
Matt Koppenheffer
Earnings have been pouring out of the financial sector all week and the picture hasn't been pretty. "Write-down" has commanded a starring role in this quarter's earnings reports dashing ahead of "earnings per share" as what investors seem to care about the most.
Citigroup, whose stock just can't seem to find a bottom, seems to have been the worst of the bunch. In an interesting twist, much of the pessimism over the company's quarter came because Citigroup only wrote down some $18 billion and didn't propose as many job cuts as the market was hoping.
CAPS still rates Citigroup just two stars out of five, but there has been some bullish sentiment after the company's earnings release. Michaelkoh1 rated Citi's stock an outperformer and noted that "2007 will be tough, and there will likely be more pain for equity investors as the financials muddle through this year, but this is a strong diversified franchise and will outperform the market over the next 2 to 4 years."
Meanwhile, Merrill Lynch got beaten up when it revealed its numbers -- complete with about $15 billion in write-downs -- but in my opinion showed some glimmers of hope. CAPS has slapped an even worse one-star rating on Merrill, though, and there's a lot of negative sentiment to go along with it. Some though, including CAPS All-Star Vavoom11, think that the worst may be over. He gave Merrill the thumbs up yesterday, noting: "[Merrill's CEO John] Thain wrote off as much as he could and risk/reward ratio is in our favor."
Have your own opinions on what's going on here? CAPS is absolutely free, so head on over and let the community know what you think.
(Full disclosure: I do not have a financial position in any of the companies mentioned.)