Search Smart Spending:

Worst dollar-store purchases

Posted Sep 29 2009, 12:48 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

We're all for dollar stores. They can provide savings, many people agree. At last count, 55% of about 423,000 people who have participated in an MSN Money online poll said they sometimes shop at dollar stores, and 36% said they frequently do. (Another 3% chose "I'd never set foot in one.")

But there are some products "rutgerskevin" of The Red Stapler Chronicles recommends you avoid, via his post called "The 10 dumbest things to buy at a dollar store." First on his list are home pregnancy tests.

Find on Bing: Dollar stores thriving in recession

Pregnancy test from the dollar store? That's a product you'd want to spend more on for a result you can trust. "I almost bought this just to see what it looked like, but the girlfriend vetoed this idea in disgust," Kevin said.

That gets to a point about dollar-store shopping. Some items, like gift wrap and shampoo, are perfectly fine as well as a bargain. But others are not. Dollar store batteries are often the carbon-zinc kind and will wear out quicker. Electrical cords and similar products may not be adequately tested for safety. Also, the MSN Money slide show "Dollar-store deals and duds" says, "Jewelry and vinyl lunchboxes have been recalled from dollar stores as dangerous sources of lead."

Other samples from Kevin's recommendations of dollar-store products to avoid:

  • Pens. He bought co-workers 10-packs of dollar-store pens, which didn't work or quickly broke. One leaked on a co-worker's shirt. "I was mortified!!" Kevin wrote (in mock horror).  
  • Vitamins. They could be sugar pills, Kevin wrote. MSN Money said, "Several years ago, Consumer Reports found that half of the dollar-store brands it studied contained less of the vitamins than the labels indicated and didn't dissolve properly when ingested." Contrary to what you might expect, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration does not tightly control these products.
  • Any kind of paste, including toothpaste and treatments for rashes. MSN Money added: "In 2007, the Food and Drug Administration warned consumers that many brands of toothpaste found at dollar stores carried diethylene glycol, a poisonous chemical found in antifreeze."
  • Tampons. Considering the risk of toxic shock syndrome, we'd have to agree. You want to be absolutely confident about the materials they're made from.
  • Perishable food. Kevin found a box of fruit bars that was dated 2002. Maybe still safe to eat. "However, all signs pointed to this product being on various stores' shelves for seven years," Kevin observed. 

Kevin's bonus tip: "If they spell the name of the product incorrectly, I would not put it in your mouth. Just some words to live by."

See more dollar-store duds in the videos at the bottom of this post.

Related reading:

Dollar stores: Where the deals are

The dollar food pantry

5 retailers thriving in the recession

Comments

 

Very funny but good list

Last Time I Bought A Map From Dollar Store, I Follow The Direction And I End Up

In Disney World.

Brand name candy is a good deal. Candles are not.

Dollar stores can be a great place to find inexpensive party decorations that only need to last for one or two parties.  

I think it depends on which Dollar store your go to.  You can find some brand name stuff at the dollar stores and but yes always remember to check the expiration dates on any perishable items. Good list though.

I shop at the dollar stores and find some really great bargains.  But here's a good rule of thumb from my experiences---don't buy anything that goes into your body--e.g. tampons, aspirins, toothpaste, vitamins, ointments, most foods. Much of it is made overseas and you can't be sure of the quality. Anything else, like cleaning products, sponges, shampoos, soaps, floral stuff, wrapping paper, etc. you are OK.  And use common sense too--toilet tissue may be only 1.00 but if it is just 4 extra-tiny rolls, it is no bargain.  Through experience, you will decide on your best bargains and stick to getting only those products while in a dollar-store.

The pg tests from the Dollar Tree actually have the same sensitivity and are as good as the name brand or store brands from other stores. Pregnancy tests cost pennies to make, which make them ideal for sale at dollar stores. I have taken many of them myself.

the pregnancy tests are actually a good deal if you will be taking a lot of tests.  For example if you are trying to get pregnant and will be testing day after day, month after month.  They work (I used them and they accurately said I was pregnant) so why spend money on more expensive ones?

Or we could all buy from WalMart, JC Penny, Belks, Macy, Kmart.  Either way, nothing is made in America anymore.  

Some "bargain" stuff is so bad, you end up throwing it away, so it's no bargain.

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):