Search Smart Spending:

4 common money mistakes

Posted Sep 15 2009, 09:26 AM by Karen Datko
Rating:

This post comes from Jim Wang at partner blog Bargaineering.com.

One of the biggest challenges in almost anything you do is knowing where your blind spots are. In simpler terms, you don't know what you don't know.

So, today I'll point out four money mistakes you might be making that you don't even realize you're making. Hopefully, you're making none of them. If you are making one of these, don't beat yourself up over it. Now you know you're making it and you can take steps to fix it.

Paying too much tax too early. Would you give the government several hundred dollars a month, for no reason, just for the government to write you a check in April? Would you give the government a zero interest loan? Probably not (if you would, feel free to send me money). However, that's exactly what you're doing when you get a tax refund in April.

Optimize your withholding and adjust it so that you get a very little refund in April. I wouldn't be too aggressive about it -- owing taxes isn't fun -- but adjust it a little so that you keep the money for your needs. You can save it and earn interest, or you can put it toward projects, products or services you've had your eye on. Either way, it's your money. You should keep it.

I listed this mistake first because it's a minor mistake, if one at all. Considering how low high-yield savings account interest rates are, the interest you would have earned by reducing your withholding is minimal. Couple that with the strategy of forced savings -- you can't spend what you don't have -- your withholding can be used as an advantage. You can read more about these ideas in my devil's advocate post on why you shouldn't adjust your withholding.

Overanalyzing things. Analysis paralysis. Paradox of choice. This little demon has many names but the end result is the same: You don't make a decision and it's costing you.

This problem often happens with 401(k) plans where there are dozens of fund options. Do you want a balanced fund? An index fund? What about emerging markets? What about blue chip? Small cap? Bonds? Treasuries?

What happens? You don't pick anything. You don't invest because you don't know what you should have, what amounts, etc.

My advice is to set a deadline for any of the decisions you need to make and stick with it. The reality is that it's better to have made a decision, especially when it concerns investing or saving, than to put it off. Every single day you delay is a day of interest you could be earning. Need some ideas for investing? Consider a lazy portfolio. Not sure where to open a Roth IRA? Check out these discount brokers offering cheap stock trades. Just pick one.

Maintaining too high a checking account balance. This isn't a killer money mistake but one that many people make. If you know how much you're spending each month, you should try to maintain as low a checking account balance as you can and save the difference in a higher yield savings account.

How do you check this? One way is to budget so you know how much you spend. Another way is to look at your daily balance and see how low it gets. If your balance hasn't gone under $5,000 in the last few months, you might want to take at least half of that and put it in a savings account. Savings account rates aren't phenomenal but they're better than getting nothing.

Overpaying for index funds. An index fund is a simple creature -- match the benchmark index. An S&P 500 index fund matches the holdings of the S&P 500. Easy as pie. The mistake here is that you might be overpaying for an otherwise simple product.

Two of the cheapest index funds, and we'll use the S&P 500 index as an example, are the Fidelity Spartan 500 Index Investor Fund and the Vanguard 500 Index Investor Fund. The Fidelity Spartan 500 has an expense ratio of 0.10% and the Vanguard 500 has an expense ratio of 0.18%, which is 80% higher.

If you have your holdings in the Vanguard 500, I'm not advocating you move your funds to Fidelity. However, if you are paying more than 0.18%, which is already an 80% premium over Fidelity, then you're definitely overpaying.

Is there a money mistake you recently discovered that I might be committing but don't know about? Let me know in the comments. We all need help finding our blind spots.

Related reading at Bargaineering:

Are online savings accounts worth it?

2009 federal income tax brackets

Best online discount brokers

Comments

 

I do not believe in giving an interest free loan to the US Government.  I also believe that if everyone wrote a check to pay their income taxes, come April 15, they would be more interested in how those hard earned dollars are spent.

I'm self-employed.  I used to work six/seven days a week and now am working an average of 10 days per month.  Thank God I overpaid my taxes last year.  I'm able to save much less money, but at least I don't have to stress out about what happens next April.  The bank pays almost nothing when you hold the money in an account.  I'd rather have less stress personally.  

What people that are financially savy need to understand is... We are all not like you! Some of us really dont have that much self control! Like myself, I make 100,000 a year and I still go from paycheck to paycheck the same that I did when i was in graduate school and made 25,000 a year.  So, I pay the absolute MOST that I can to the govt, because they are doing me a SERVICE by holding my money and not letting me touch it.  I understand that I am giving them an interest-free loan, but what you are NOT calculating in your financial equation is.... Is the interest I would have earned from keeping the money and investing it, more or less, than I am saving by letting the govt hold money from a "spender". And furthermore, the way that the economy is going and the stock marker (my parents lost all most ALL their retirement from their 401K), I might as well take my April 15 check and go to the casino! I would have about the same luck! But as for me, and I think most Americans, Ill take the safe situation.  I wont make as much money, but I KNOW that I wont lose any!

Hey, if you are worried about the cost of an index fund why are you buying a fund. Buy the SPY ETF, there is NO fee each year and, whoa, get this, you actually receive the dividends that many of the companies in the S&P pay, when did you ever see your fund kick in $1.00+ per share each year??? So you own the fund and get 3%+ per year.  Tell me again why I should pay an annual fee to belong to an unmanaged fund in a bank that could go under??

This article's advice was great in the 1970's but doesn't hold true today.Bank savings rates are at est 1%.I am self employed and agree with Sheryl of overpaying to taxes to alliviate the stress.If you live in the state of California,as I do,your taxes are going up this year.One never knows when taxes are going up due to the greed of the Federal and state governments so it's best to overpay.

For all of my working life I have had extra taken out of my check for taxes.  My husband is also doing the same.  Yes it is an intrest free loan to the goverment but when I get 7k, yes seven thousand, back in February after I do our taxes, we are able to take a nice vacation, this year we are going to Hawaii for 7 nights, 8 days. To each there own, but I would rather have a large sum after taxes, then smaller sums thru the year that can get spent on things that are not needed.  

I love just getting a big refund check in April because then I can use it for a fun family vacation or event!  If I put it in the bank, then for me all it would do is go to more bills... how fun is that?  Everyone's situation is different I guess...

Karla:

Just think of what you'd do if you had that money to spend or save during the year? Do you like giving the federal government an interest free loan every year?

Y'know, you might want to pay off those bills.

Most community colleges have introductory courses on microeconomics.

Oops, sorry Karla... missed the sarcasm to the previous post.

Please pardon mine and direct them upward.

My most common money mistake is having kids out of wedlock. If you ask me, the state should take care of my kids, not me, i'm unemployed!

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):