Search Smart Spending:

Why I'm giving up my car

Posted Aug 18 2009, 05:55 PM by Donna Freedman
Rating:

I'm giving away my car at the end of August and making a conscious decision not to replace it. For now, anyway.

The decision isn't inspired by frugality or carbon-footprint concern so much as sheer curiosity: What would life without a car be like?

My daughter and her husband decided to speed up their planned move to Phoenix, Arizona. They have no wheels and limited funds and were discussing whether or not they could just use the city transit system.

Since my daughter has a chronic illness, waiting for a bus in 100-plus-degree heat sounds like a bad idea. So I'm giving them the Chevy with my best wishes plus the suggestion that they remember this when they're picking out my nursing home.

My neighborhood mechanic occasionally buys and fixes up cars for resale. Initially I thought I'd see if he had a beater I could buy once I gave up my vehicle. Then I decided just to use public transit and shank's mare for a while.

If I hate it, I can look for a used vehicle later on. And if I don't hate it? Then no more insurance/upkeep/gas costs.

I have other options, too. My sister says we can stop at the supermarket on the way home from church if I need something that's too heavy to carry home on the bus. There's always Zipcar, an auto-sharing service. I may also start taking mystery shopping assignments for rental car companies once more, so I can use the loaner for errands or appointments.

Since there's decent public transit here in Seattle and since I'm within a mile and a half of just about everything I need, it should be simpler for me than for some people. Simpler, not easier. As I noted in a previous Smart Spending essay, shopping on foot or even by bus limits your ability to take advantage of specials or visit multiple stores, and it takes a lot of time out of your day.

And yes, I fully expect to be cranky on days when I need to go somewhere and it's sleeting sideways. Life will go on, however, no matter how spoiled I turn out to be.

In the rural area where I grew up there was no public transit. There's still no public transit. Going carless wouldn't be an option there. It's an option here, though, and I'm going to give it a try.

As for being freed from gas/insurance/upkeep: A friend has already pointed out that any savings I realize will be offset by my trips to Phoenix. Could be.

Related reading:

What's afoot: Walking saves money, sanity, your waistline

Get a free car repair estimate

My embarrassing insurance confession

Comments

 

Donna, I use the buses here in Seattle too, and they're very nice, but when you want to go somewhere when the buses aren't running or the ol' "sleeting sideways" thing is going on, having a car seems like a necessity. I don't have one, but I could if I really needed it. Still, for two years I've survived, and yes, the kindness of a friend when you want to buy something too big or heavy for the bus helps. Good luck in your experiment!

I envy you! I hate supporting my car and wish I could give it away, but The Geriatric Wing is built onto the back of DD/DSIL's home, and they live in the burbs. There is NO transpo in the burbs. None. Zero. Nada. Zip. I'm looking for a job, but without a car, there's no way to get to one. At times like this, I wish I'd gone back to The Tundra after DH died so that I could walk wherever there was to go.

It'll be fun to follow your adventures sans auto so please don't leave us wondering!

good luck, I am sure you will do fine. Six years ago I was forced to quit driving for health reasons. I live in a city of around 200,000. So I have mastered taking a bus to my appointments. Only main problem is icy sidewalks occassionaly in the winter, that I have to cab cause I cannot risk falling. I bus to the Grocery store, buy two week supply of groceries and cab home. It's still much cheaper than maintaining a car. I will be watching your progress, Jan

I've lived without a car for years on end, riding bicycles everywhere...  It's better to have a car and not need it then to not have one and need it...  After all, you DON'T have to use it everyday,just when required or desired.

I'm pulling for you or I could be pushing a cart for you! I hope it works out for you either way. And I have to say that this will be one article that I will be waiting for. I think fear would set in if I had to give up my car but we are also 4 miles from a grocery store. And that wouldn't be a fun trek in the winter.  I'm just wondering what you will be feeling as you see your car drive away, not to mention your daughter.

i have no problem with mass trans. been doing it for 4 yrs. don't miss the assack with dealing in auto expenses and ins.

Donna...What a sweet selfless gesture...to give your daughter your car. But not surprising as you are a Mom. There just may be a good book out of this experiment. Heck if Judith Levine can write one about not spending money for a year this should be Pulitzer material. I have thought often what life would be like without a car...or the cost of tags...insurance...maintenance...gas, but never had the courage to give it a try. If nothing else this will provide plenty of material for your writing. Best of Luck and tell DD to drive careful!

Yay for Zipcar! You use it when you need it, and they pay for gas, insurance, and maintenance. The cars are clean and fun to drive, and they can be found in convenient areas. I've used it several times and done without my own car for a while now. It's reassuring to know there's a car available if you need it!

Donna, there's a book by Chris Balish called "How to Live Well Without a Car" that might interest you. I've gone w/o since last November and haven't really missed it. I live in Glens Falls, NY which has an adequate, but not superior mass transit. If one can choose where they live it helps (i.e. be a renter not a home owner).... Janet, there's a product called Yaktrax that slip on your shoes. They are incredible on ice. Just don't wear them on a tile floor.

Donna... I moved to Seattle from Southern California the "land of the car" and I gave away my car as well when I moved up here. I will tell you that it is very liberating. Sign up for Zip Car it is the best way to get around when you need to go to Fred Mayer.

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):