Search Smart Spending:

Big spenders attract tightwad mates

Posted Aug 04 2009, 12:30 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

Opposites attract, even when it comes to spending money, new research has shown. Tightwads gravitate to spenders when selecting mates, and vice versa -- for better or worse (and richer or poorer).

Researchers at the Wharton School and Northwestern University "found that people who generally spend less than they would ideally like to spend, and those who spend more than they would like to tend to marry each other," a Reuters story said. (The research paper is cleverly titled "Fatal (Fiscal) Attraction" (.pdf file).) And that happens even though people tell themselves they'd prefer to be with someone just like them.

This information has all sorts of real-life applications, "The Weakonomist" observed at Weakonomics:

"Tired of saving every penny you can find only to have your spouse go out and blow it?  Well, it's time to point the finger away from them and back onto yourself. You were the fool that married them."

There's some heavy psychology going on here. We've found, for instance, that we tend to dislike characteristics in others that are the same ones we dislike about ourself. Thus, this line from the Reuters story makes sense: "Those who find it painful to spend, for example, may dislike that characteristic in themselves, and so are attracted to people who are more liberal in their approach to money."

The Weakonomist said he's avoiding that trap. "In just a short while my fiancé will be walking down the aisle to say her vows with me .... Though we won't promise to honor, cherish, and save 15% toward retirement, it will be implied," he wrote.

If you're not so fortunate as to pick your perfect money mate, Annie Scott at Luxist recommended, "Basically, next time your husband or wife asks, ‘Why are you spending so much?' in exasperation, you can truthfully answer: ‘That's why you love me, baby.'" Or, if you really want to improve communication, read "7 tips for money and marriage."

And if you're unsure where you stand on spending, you can take the Wharton School's quiz. They will send you the results.

Related reading:

How to talk openly about money in a marriage

He's paying off their debt, she's adding to it

The 12 biggest reasons we fight over finances

Your 5-minute guide to love and money

Comments

 

Aw thanks for including me in your post!

MY HUSBAND AND I ARE LIKE THIS. I LIKE TO BE THRIFTY AND HE LIKES TO SPEND. THIS WORKS  FOR US BECAUSE HE MAKES ME HAVE FUN AND I MAKE HIM SAVE AND CURB SPENDING...

Works for my wife and I as well, but one big caveat.  Both sides have to be moderate in their ways.  I don't think extreme spending with an extreme miser would ever work long term.  Misery seems likely.

But I'm disappointed.  I always thought my wife was attracted to my great body, not my great spending habits!  Rats!

Isn't it also true that when you combine two peoples checkbooks, one will always be a bigger spender and the other no so.  Then over time they gravitay more towards these extremes to compensate for the other??

This must be a question of degree.  My man and I both regard ourselves as savers who were *formerly* married to spenders.  We are on track to be debt-free by the end of next year, and that includes mortgage!  He'll be 42 and I'll be 35.

On a day to day basis I am more of a tightwad than the wife in terms of wanting to spend at all.  She spends frugally and uses coupons, discounts, and sales whenever possible.  Sometimes however the only "reason" for a purchase is that it is on sale, and to me there is no reason to buy anything unless you need it, or really want it and are going to use it.  

On things like vacations, or when it comes to buying a car, the wife is ready to spent freely, while still paying attention to getting the deal.  Overall we compliment each other in terms of spending habits.  Now if I could just get her to not buy pretty much whatever the kids want we'd be doing much better.

My husband is a total tightwad! I do like to spend, but in the end it was me who "put out" over 100,000 over ten years for camp, private school and day care for our son. When we got married  we both paid for the wedding , but only received enough money to reimburse my husband. My contribution is probably still reflected in a VISA bill somewhere! Thank heavens he is a good husband and father?

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):