Search Smart Spending:

Chase raises minimum payments on credit cards

Posted Jun 25 2009, 11:45 AM by Karen Datko
Rating:

This post comes from Mark Huffman at partner site ConsumerAffairs.com.

Thousands of Chase credit card customers have gotten some bad news this month. The bank has informed them that the minimum monthly payment on their accounts is being raised from 2% of the balance to 5%.

That might not sound like a huge increase, but for many who are carrying large balances and are on a tight budget, it's a severe and unexpected blow.

Kay, of Pottsville, Pa., said she contacted Chase and was told the change in policy was related to the poor economy. "I was told I could possibly renegotiate a lesser monthly payment but my interest would go from 3.9% to 21.99%," she told ConsumerAffairs.com. "My monthly payment from my four accounts will go from $961 a month to $2,394 a month. Needless to say, I will not be able to make these payments and will end up defaulting on my accounts and probably claim bankruptcy."

The change in minimum payment has little to do with how long customers have been Chase cardholders or their credit ratings. An analysis of complaints to ConsumerAffairs.com in the last few days shows that many customers do seem to have one thing in common. They all mention that they took advantage of a previous promotion and signed up for a Chase credit card with the promise of a low fixed rate for an extended period of time.

"In the past year I took advantage of balance-transfer offers with their life-of-the-loan low interest rate offers of 5.99% and 6.99%," Wendy, of Cardiff-by-the-Sea, Calif., told ConsumerAffairs.com. "I basically used the card as debt consolidation this year ..., wanting to close some other accounts and just use the Chase card to pay this amount down. I am horrified at the new 5% minimum. This will increase my payment by about $475 a month."

Dana of Dacula, Ga., also took advantage of the promotion and transferred money to a Chase account at 4.9%. Her minimum monthly payment will go from 2% to 5% in August.

"This could put me in default since it would cause my payment to more than double each month," she said. "I do not want to use the card. I just want to pay it with the terms I agreed to when the card was issued."

With new credit card rules on the way, thanks to changes by regulators and Congress, lenders are preparing for a new consumer-lending environment. By increasing its minimum monthly payment for customers with low fixed interest rates, Chase recovers that low-interest money faster, and can loan it out again at much higher rates.

The new credit card rules will prevent lenders from arbitrarily raising interest rates, but do not address the issue of minimum monthly payments. In fact, regulators in the past have encouraged lenders to increase the minimum payments, so that consumers pay down their balances faster.

But a number of consumers who thought they were doing the smart thing -- transferring large balances to cards with locked-in low rates, are finding themselves in a trap. The increased minimum payment is now unaffordable. The price of keeping their payment the same is to give up that promised low rate, so that more of their monthly payment goes to interest each month, not paying down the principal.

Related reading at ConsumerAffairs.com:

Most consumers lack confidence in food safety, survey says

Feds offer DTV reception advice

Wireless carriers agree to $1.5 million cramming settlement

Comments

 

You can complain to the FTC and two law firms have filed class-action suits against chase to stop this practice.

www.gslawny.com/lawyer-attorney-1383679.html

www.girardgibbs.com/chase.asp

www.ftccomplaintassistant.gov

Many of you don't get it.  Most of us consolidated debt (even car debt), at 2.99%, 3.99%, etc.  We  have credit scores in excess of 700 and pay more than our current  minimum.  We didn't abuse our credit--we managed it.  This is about fairness.  Nothing more, nothing less.  Banks and mortgage companies created this mess in part by enabling folks to do what they did.  This isn't an argument for no self control--it is an argument for not penalizing those of us who played by the rules.  I have written the FTC, both Senators and my congressman.  Get off the self-righteousness and see it for what it-----unfair!!

This goes beyond predatory lending and is nothing short of financial terrorism.  I have worked hard for over 20 years to build good credit and pursue my American Dream. Now I am being put in a position of having my credit, my small business, my home and my dreams destroyed by a company my tax dollars bailed out!

I took advantage of a very attractive offer made to me by Chase Credit Card Company.  I borrowed approximately $35,000 locked below 5% interest.  I have made all my payments on time.  Paying the minimum payment with the majority of the money going on principal (because of the low interest rate) I have quickly reduced the loan to $28,000.  Some months after baiting me with this extremely attractive offer Chase has told me they are changing the rules because they would like to have more interest on their money.  

Since I have paid on time, every time, they can’t raise my interest rate to their default rate, so they have decided to up my minimum monthly payment instead, from $560 to $1400.  I guess what Chase is saying to me is “there is more than one way to skin a cat.”  They have decided the easiest way to get more interest out of me is to force me into a default situation.  If I can’t make the minimum payment of $1400 per month, my interest rate will go up substantially and thus providing them with the end result they desire.  

All of my credit cards seem to be changing their terms within the last few months.  Bank of America tried to raise my rate from 7% to 13%, so I opted out of that.  HSBC didn't raise my rate, but did lower my credit line by $2000.  My other chase card raised the rate from 8% to 13.5%, and the one chase card that I have a low apr on is going to be raised from 2% minimum payment to 5%. I agree with Kent, I used credit cards to manage my debt, they made it easier and cheaper to use credit cards than get bank loans.  And now we're getting kind of screwed by them.  For me, it's not about having to pay them more, because I have the money to do that, it's just that I was trying to pay off other debts, like my car loan before I wasted money paying off debts with a low interest rate.

Generally, I chalk up criticism of credit card bank actions to that of whiny children who can't or won't take responsibility.

In this case, however, my general rule does not apply to those who took advantage of the "life of the loan" balance transfer offers. For those individuals, Chase, in my opinion is operating in bad faith, even if it is operating within its contractual rights.

For card holders who use the card for purchases and carry a balance it only seems fair for Chase to apply the new rules to balances created AFTER the new rule takes effect. Any balance created before hand (and in good faith) should continue to have the 2% rule applied.

Not sure if that's possible, but it seems more fair.

I would agree with the last poster. If they make a change in terms, they should apply it to new purchases/transfers not to the ones we established one year ago.

Does anyone know of any relief in sight on this issue? What is the probability of Chase resolving this issue or are we in for a long court battle?

Regardless, ADIOS CHASE FOREVER!! EVERYONE NEEDS TO DISCONTINUE DOING BUSINESS WITH THIS SHADY COMPANY AS SOON AS POSSIBLE!!!!!

Does anyone know the exact attorney to contact with regards to the class action lawsuit that has already been filed regarding this bait and switch tactic by Chase ? Please write to Ed at director@hagancorp.com

I beat them, before they beat me. Blew chase off 7 months ago.No house, no assets.screw it! They raised their ATM fee to $3.00 per transaction! At the bank!!They bought every WAMU in California. I went over my limit by $4.00, My rate went up 6%.HAHAHA SCREW CHASE!If you have nothing, they cant take anything.REVOLT! Blow off Chase.Credit will be hurt for 7 years i am told, but does it matter????

Ed,

It looks like www.girardgibbs.com/chase.asp is about the best firm on the issue that I can find. If anyone knows of additional firms besides the ones listed earlier on this page, please post the info that you know. We need to fight Chase and put them where they belong! I will be able to close my account with them in a relatively short time but many with large families will not be so fortunate. I could possibly see raising the minimum to 3% but NOT 5%. Chase is an EVIL blood sucking SINNING entity!!!

TELL ALL OF YOUR FRIENDS TO STOP DOING BUSINESS WITH CHASE!! THEY DESERVE TO BE RUN OUT OF BUSINESS!!!! I WILL DEFINATELY DO MY PART TO MAKE SURE THEY NEVER GET MY BUSINESS OR MY FRIENDS AND FAMILY'S BUSINESS.

KEEP UP THE FIGHT!!!

Roland, thank you so much for the useful links to the FTC and law firms. Yours is the most worthwhile post here. Thanks again.

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):