Search Smart Spending:

Is recycling aluminum worth it?

Posted Jan 21 2009, 11:27 AM by Donna Freedman
Rating:

Prices for recycled materials like cans and cardboard tanked along with the global and U.S. economy, according to an article in The Seattle Times. That explains why I got only $2 for 10 pounds of aluminum cans at my neighborhood recycling plant last weekend.

Only a couple of months ago they were paying 40 cents a pound (about 28 cans). If I lived in one of 11 states with can/bottle deposit laws, I’d have made at least $12.60.

For a $2 payoff, was it worth the effort to recycle? There are a couple of different ways to answer that question.

From a strictly ecological standpoint, sure. We can keep reusing the aluminum rather than dump cans in a landfill. Of course, if I were worried about the environment I could have just put them in the recycle bin outside the apartment building. But I wondered how much they were worth.

Reduce, reuse, cash in?
Costwise, was it worth it? That depends on whether we’re talking cash or time. It didn’t cost me anything to drive to the recycling plant because I was on my way to another errand. The place is less than a mile away, so I could make it a destination walk anytime I have a couple of bags of cans.

Partner blogger Trent Hamm at The Simple Dollar figures he earns the equivalent of $48 an hour to recycle aluminum -- you get a nickel a can in Iowa. I wish. Here in the land of No Deposit, it took me maybe 10 minutes total to take the cans out of my apartment, drive to the place, get paid and leave. You could look at that as earning $12 an hour.

If you’re out of a job, snowflaking a debt or simply determined to find additional sources of income, here are a few tips on how to get more cans:

•    Collect them at your workplace.
•    Carry a bag when you take walks. It’s a little disturbing how many cans get tossed on the roads and even on hiking trails.
•    Make friends with a bar owner who sells lots of canned beer -- that is, if you can stand the stench of the dregs.
•    Ask neighbors and/or relatives, nicely, if they’ll save their cans for you.
•    Get permission to put collection containers in places where people gather, such as bowling alleys or social halls. Check them often, though, lest others with the same idea empty the bins for you.

For an occasional $2 payday, a lot of people might not think it’s worth their time. But for those living on the margins through chance or choice, even a few dollars is better than nothing. I’m thinking of the guys who rummage in the recycle bins outside my window; I doubt that they’re doing it because they got tired of being day traders.

As times get tighter, I think we may see more working-class and middle-class folks hauling cans to recycling centers for a little extra cash. However, it’s worth noting that unless you’re picking up cans along roadsides, you might “earn” more money by reducing or cutting soda (and beer) from your diet.

Related reading:

8 natural ways to make water more flavorful

In praise of iced tea

Have all the Dr Pepper you want, kids – if you're paying for it

Comments

 

I agree most with Donna's last sentence.  You might “earn” more money by reducing or cutting soda (and beer) from your diet. You may do your health a favor too.

spillingbuckets.blogspot.com/.../mapmyrun.html

Where we live recycling is handled as part of trash collection.  The reason for this is simple every ton of waste diverted from the land fill site extends he sites useful life span.  The recycling program although not profitable, does pay for it self by reducing total costs for waste disposal.  In our area they figure that the recycling efforts have reduced total waste disposal costs by 30% by removing over 60% of the solid waste (glass, plastic, paper and metals) from our landfill site.

So unless you want to pay much higher waste costs then keep it up.  You should really push for a municipally run program they divert more then the private by and sell programs, because they look at total cost reduction not what they can make.

You have to do everything to avoid creating cost increase pressure on uncontrollable costs like garbage.

You know the real surprise here is that I would normally be saying that governments should be kept out of things. But in waste disposal and recycling programs, the best programs I have ever seen to date are all run by local governments.

www.budgetingsense.com

We're a state with a soda can deposit. At work, cans used to get tossed with the trash because everyone was too lazy/busy/distracted to bring them home. What we do now is have a big recycling bin for the cans - when it's full we get the deposit money and donate it to whichever of the local charities is next on our rotating list. As to the pull tabs (which really aren't pull tabs anymore, but I'm old enough to recall the original ones, so there you go) they're collected separately and a member of the local Shriner's chapter picks them up for recycling then funding their work. Of course you're right that soda's an unnecessary expense but, while some of the folks here still indulge, they've found a way to reduce waste and help the local community.

"But for those living on the margins through chance or choice, even a few dollars is better than nothing."

With all of my heart, thank you for continuing to inspire. And for writing articles that represent the many. When I tired of the frugal fight, I stop by for a quick pick me up. Your frugal philosophy has inspired many and saved even more. Keep up the good work!

Full disclosure: I drink Diet Coke. I average about one can a day -- always bought on sale, of course. I'm not criticizing people for buying soda or beer.

Generally I put the cans in the recycle bin; lately, the youth group at my church has been collecting cans to earn money for Habitat for Humanity. I'll likely go back to doing that.

Incidentally, that $2 went into Spider-Man's head -- a coin bank that my daughter and son-in-law keep on the kitchen counter for spare change. Allegedly it's to help snowflake their debt, but they also fish bus fare out of it as needed.

Thanks for reading Smart Spending.

Best regards,

Donna Freedman

What you don't realize is that in states that have return laws you aren't "making" any money since you have already paid the surcharge when you purchase the cans at the store

If you bought the soda in a state with a deposit law, you would just get back what you paid.  You wouldn't really "make" anything...

My father in law used to pick up cans and bottle when he was jogging. He made about $2,000.00 per year doing this and saved tons of reusable waste from ending up in the landfill.

In Iowa you only get a nickel a can for returns because you have to pay that in the first place. So unless you are finding other people's cans, you aren't getting money- just hassle.  Instead of being able to put my cans out curbside with all the other recycling the city picks up, I have to take them back to the store and return them one by one to break even, otherwise a 12 pack costs 60 cents more than you planned.

I've been saving can ,cooper wire,aluminum scraps etc,I take this mess in once a year if the collection gets to big.It's been a profitable way of making some extra cash for hardly any effort put into collecting these items,it also frees up some of our landfills at the same time.

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):