Search Smart Spending:

Side of beef: Are you getting a good deal?

Posted Dec 09 2008, 12:30 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

We have a chest freezer in the basement (it came with the house when we bought it) and we try to use it in a cost-friendly way. So we're buying half a yearling heifer from a rancher.

But are we really getting a great deal, or is store-bought beef cheaper?

Mark Sisson says getting together with friends to buy a whole or side of beef is now known as "cowpooling." He says it makes sense if you really love beef (ours is grass-fed), have a place to store it, and like to buy locally. But how about the cost?

In a post at Mark Sisson's Daily Apple, he adds that "sometimes it is more expensive to cowpool than it is to purchase meat from your supermarket, especially if you're a whiz at clipping coupons and shopping the sale section."

Our partner blogger J.D. Roth broke down the arguments for and against buying a side of beef at Get Rich Slowly a couple years ago. In 2006, J.D. paid $3.61 a pound for his beef, including cutting and packaging, and compared that with prices at two local stores. "In this case, shopping at the supermarket would be more expensive, but not by much," he wrote. "If you watch for sales, supermarket beef will cost even less."

Want more information? Check out this .pdf file from the Oklahoma Cooperative Extension Service, and Jason Krause's post at Chow.

Comments

 

Unless you like liver,heart,tongue,kidneys,sweet breads,oxtail, and stomach side beef is no deal. The packers all have established market abroad and overseas where they maximize the market on these. They get a premium out of the hide, teeth to dental schools,etc. This brings what we like the primal cut to us at a much much lower price. The most economical way to but beef is in whole cuts sliced free on sale at the retailers or buy the case at a wholesaler and do the work yourself. The only advantage to buying on the hoof is to guarantee the source or the age. We are no longer a local market and overseas they pay over $3.00 for tongues wholesale and we throw it away.

most say fresh but its left to taugh out the cut up from larger companys then sold as fresh yea fresh frozen if you buy a beef it slaughtered hung for up to 4 wks for tenderness the cut and frozen

I have purchased a side of beef the last three years. I know that there are no steroids or other harmful ingredients in it. Also, this year the price went up, but it still worked out to $2.23 per pound, this including butchering to my request and packaging. And yes, it does have a much better taste to it than store bought beef.

check walmart tougne is 7.99 a lb

and ill eat liver and onions any day of the week

Did your store bought beef have a hormone seed planted in the ear?  Many do, including our local six letter wholesale warehouse superstore.  And what about antibiotics?  I only raise organic beef and find it very easy to sell.  People want and deserve to know what they are eating.

i even know of a place that will process your wild game if you come to colorado to hunt elk!

We buy grass fed beef from the farmer and have for years.  My children can taste the difference between our freezer beef and store-bought beef and they won't eat the store-bought.  They say it tastes like chemicals and they're right.  The kind of animal matters, the feed matters, and the butchering matters.  Store beef just can't compare.  And it's significantly more expensive to purchase store beef unless you're just talking ground beef - and since we get ours 94% lean, that isn't any cheaper either.

One caveat to price:  beef prices vary WIDELY around the country.  If you're in Nebraska or Kansas, store beef is MUCH cheaper than in Maine, Massachusetts, Vermont, Nevada, etc.  But the taste still can't compare.

Grass fed organic beef is better for you, it tastes better, and you save money on the gas you don't use to go to the store and buy your meat.  First thing we do when we move to a new state is look up the local grass fed beef coop and start asking questions so we can put in our order.  

Pork is another matter.  It's becoming more difficult to find a good organic pig farmer, at least in my experience.

i I SAY BUYING BEEF FROM THE RANCHER , BUT DON'T THINK YOU ARE GETTING THE BEST DEAL IN PRICE BECAUSE THE MOST OF THE TIME YOU ARE PAYING HOOF PRICE,IF ITS A REASONABLE PRICE IF ITS A LITTLE HIGHER YOU'RE PAYING FOR A LOT OF WASTE (FAT,BONES AND OTHER UNEDITABLE )PARTS SO THEY ARE LOTS OF WASTE EITHER WAY ,STORE BOUGHT BEEF IS GOOD FROM OUR FARMERS IN U.S. .. WHO ARE THEY TO SAY THE FARMERS BEEF ISBETTER YOU CAN GET BAD FEED IN ANY PRUDUCT THAT YOU FEED ANIMALS AND ALSO IN GRASS THATS NOT INSECT FREE FROM CHIMICALS OR OTHER WISE ...I'VE SEEN BEEF CUT AND PACKAGED AND BELIEVE YOU ME THEY ARE LOTS OF WASTE .  YOU ARE STILL FREEZING IT SO THE STORE BOUGHT ON SPECIAL DEALS ARE BETTER TO ME .. AND THE TIME HAS COME THAT THE PACKAGES HAS TO HAVE WHERE THE BEEF COMES FROM .IN THE STORES WE GET LOTS OF OUR BEEF FROM THE WEST COAST AREA .. OF COURSE IF ITS NOT FROZEN ITS GOING TASTE DIFFERENT BUT ONCE FROZEN NOT THAT DIFFERENCES IN STORE BOUGHT OR OUR NEIGHBOR FARMERS . ITS STILL COSTLY ON HOOF OR HANGING SIDES OR QUARTER BEEF ..

Buy pork...raise your own. It only takes 5 months to raise a weiner pig to full market weight, it is very simple and you will be suprised how good it is. By the way pigs are natures best composter they eat everything.  

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):