Search Smart Spending:

8 questions NOT to ask in this economy

Posted Dec 03 2008, 10:43 AM by Donna Freedman
Rating:

An old friend recently got a job after being first underemployed and then unemployed. One day at noon her new boss noticed she hadn't left her desk. "Aren't you going to have any lunch?" he asked.

Well, no, she wasn't. There'd been barely enough in the house to make brown-bag lunches for her kids. My friend lied brightly about wanting to work through her lunch hour so she could finish on time for once.

It's bad enough to be on the financial edge. It really stinks to be put on the spot, too.

Some of us don't realize that anybody could be in financial trouble. That well-dressed middle manager might be about to lose her home. That seemingly carefree young co-worker could have two jobs and three roommates and still be sinking under the burden of student loan debt.

The next-door neighbors might be in line at the food bank, and praying that no one they know sees them. Your cousin's job search might be going exactly nowhere and the unemployment benefits aren't enough to keep a guppy in fish flakes.

Simplicity isn't always voluntary
Others aren't in trouble -- yet. But they're concerned about the possibility of layoffs and view the financial turmoil as a wake-up call. That means some belt-tightening while they get their personal finances in order: paying down credit card debt, creating an emergency fund, etc.

Even those making voluntary changes might be in for some ribbing about their new austerity. Here's the thing, though: It's still voluntary. They still have the option of going out for the occasional drink after work.

And those who are deep in the hole and trying desperately to hide it? Here's a scenario: Suppose you know to the penny how much is in your wallet and how far it isn't going to go -- and then a co-worker loudly announces that everyone needs to contribute $10 for a baby shower gift.

That sawbuck could be all you've got for groceries until payday. But who wants to say that out loud?

Watch your mouth
In this economy, here are a few suggestions about what not to ask:

•    How's the job search going? (In circles, but I'm making good time.)
•    I finished my Christmas shopping and I came in under a thousand! What are you buying your kids? (Some groceries. And I was thinking of having the electricity turned back on -- after all, Christmas comes but once a year!)
•    When are you going to buy a new car? (After the repo man snags this one.)
•    Are you going anywhere this winter? (The payday loan place.)
•    When are you going to propose to that girlfriend of yours? (After I win the lottery. Could I borrow a dollar?)
•    The housing market's going down -- why don't you look for a place of your own? (Because my parents' basement is just too homey ever to leave! Besides, the bill collectors will find me wherever I go.)
•    What are you doing this weekend? (Delivering pizzas.)
•    We go to Club Expensivo every Saturday night -- want to join us? (Only if you're ordering a pizza to be delivered to the club.)

Religion, politics -- or money
Perhaps we could start to think before we speak.

Tempted to make snide comments about irresponsible people who walk away from their mortgages? The person next to you might be teetering on the brink of disaster due to, say, a spouse's or child's serious illness. Thanks for making things worse!

Teasing a longtime pal about being too cheap to go out to lunch lately? Gee, wonder why ol' buddy stopped returning your calls.

Dissing "those people" who get food stamps or free school lunches? Several other co-workers agree, loudly. One of them says nothing at all.

You know, you could always talk about the weather.

Comments

 

Do you think it's okay to ask how someone's job search is going, when you want to offer help (such as groceries), but don't know the situation? Is it better to say nothing, in case someone would be offended by your mention of problems? What is a tactful way to approach offering help, when you're not sure if it's needed or wanted?

I delivered pizza when I was in college, it was good money. But now that I work a regular job and am trying to pay off debt, it sucks when they ask you to give $10 for bosses day. Yeah for a boss you don't even like. Or you must buy from my kids fundraiser. I learn to just say no. Yes it ticks people off but I get my bills paid. I have had to rely on free lunch for my son before and given up lunches for a year to afford groceries in the past. When I see coworkers not eatting I offer them part of what I have now. I have been there, it sucks but you really don't want to rub it in anyones face.

To Hannah, perhaps taking the person aside, or inviting them to your house would be best. Say something like, "Things seem to be going better for us than a lot of people, and we're grateful for what we have, but we wanted to share it with you, too."

I've had to swallow my pride repeatedly, being offered help that I didn't ask for, or want, but did need. I had thought I was hiding things better, so it was embarrassing, but since I have kids, I couldn't turn it down. It helps to know that others are in this situation as well. And I have offered help when I've been able, myself.

Also, to Hannah, if they refuse, say something like "This isn't charity. I know that if I am ever in this situation, I can count on you, too!" That does make a person feel better, and in my opinion, more likely to share when things do get better.

You missed one, what's in your wallet?

I just lost my job...first time I've been unemployed since college...but I am very fortunate to be able to survive for a while. Inow  have a better appreciation of my blessings, my spouse, my friends.

Two things amaze me- the generosity of the average person out there, especially many of those who are also hurting themselves - the 3 posts above are great examples of the goodness in people....

The second thing is how it appaers that those most willing to help are those that either have been affected, or feel as though they could be affected, by this downturn; and those we don't hear from are the high level business people & politicians that, in my humble opinion, are mostly responsible for this mess!

Happy Holidays to all!

It is so refreshing to see that people do understand. This article shows me that I am not alone and helps me feel more human in my given situation. I am a single mother of five, working two jobs just to make the basic ends meet and fit EVERY scenario outlined in the uncomfortable questions above. Christmas will surely be a stretch of monumental proportions, yet my children see me give of what's in my wallet to someone in need when we see them on a corner or a storefront. A kind gesture of understanding makes it all seem a little better and I appreciate the sentiment of this article COMPLETELY.

My company keeps a selection of gift cards on hand.  Whenever one of us has a birthday, we get to choose a gift card.  I'm in charge of this.  A woman I work with had a birthday and when she came to choose her gift card decided that she would wait until I ordered more because I didn't have a card for the store where whe wanted to buy new rugs or for her favorite restaurant.  She didn't want a gas card.  I wanted to slap her.  I could really use the free gas right now.

A friend was having trouble.  I gave her grocery money, used (but good) appliances, used (but decent) clothes, I bought her meals to cheer her up, too.  She then asked (actually, hinted) to give her money to buy frivolous items.  I did not give her the amount of cash she was "hinting" she needed, figuring it was time she stood on her own two feet.  She then became verbally abusive and vicious to me & I don't hang out with this person anymore.  This taught me to stop being kind to other people.

Hannah - I had a situation similar to yours - I purchased a gift card to a local grocer and left it in a card marked from your Secret Santa for a friend that I knew was having a tough row.  

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):