Search Smart Spending:

How we're failing Home Ec 101

Posted Nov 29 2008, 01:53 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

Spurred on by the faltering economy, more people are trying to spend wisely and save money. But are we getting results?

Blogger Kay Bell at Don't Mess With Taxes points to a New York Times story called "Failing home economics" that questions many people's methods.

In the NYT story, for instance, shopper Richard Winkler called himself "grocery wise, cable foolish." "You know, walking three blocks to save 10 cents on Triscuits," he said, while "my phone bill still has charges like $4.99 per month for technical stunts I can't even pronounce, much less access."

Other examples from the story:

    • Basing spending decisions on saving time rather than saving money.

    • Buying big-ticket items at Wal-Mart rather than another retailer because shopping at a discount store makes you feel better about yourself. (The lesson here, folks, is that if you're watching your spending, you don't buy a huge flat-screen TV.)

    • Taking bulk buying to extremes. Are you really saving if you've bought six cases of prunes?

    • Making purchases we think will save us money without doing the research first.

    Kay says she tries to shop wisely by looking for sales and going to the grocery store with a list. "We try to stick to just those items, but now and then, like the woman in today's article, the convenience factor kicks in," she writes. "And, again like the woman in the article, failure to do so costs us."

    Comments

     

    I think we're all guilty of this. Let me give you my own personal example...

    My car insurance has be nearly $50 more expensive each month because I haven't turned in a couple of docs. that I need for lower insurance. So while the months pass on and on not taking care of that, I fret over my wife going a few dollars over the limit on our grocery bill.

    Go figure...

    http://www.financialnut.com

    I think that a lot of people "step over the dollars to pick up the dimes."  But I do think that you have to consider your time as part of the cost.  Should I bake my own bread or drive out of my way to a discount bakery store?  Should I just buy what I need at the local grocery store and not spend a lot of time on that issue?  The answer will vary depending on the individual and how he/she chooses to spend his/her time.  For example, some think baking their own bread is a good investment of their time, others may take a once monthly trip to the discount bakery store to stock up and freeze their bread.  Others may not have that kind of time and stop at the store on the way home from work to grab a loaf of bread.  How a person budgets his/her time is as important as how a person budgets his/her money.

    I don't think we're failing.  We're not all getting As, certainly, however Bs, Cs, or even Ds still indicate a certain amount of effort.  

    And this is an extremely subjective matter.  I may think you're failing if you buy fresh vegetables rather than frozen, because frozen are cheaper and have more nutrients left, but you may think you're behaving sensibly because the fresh vegetables are local whereas you think I'm being foolish for buying in bulk at Costco and bringing it home by car rather than shopping frequently at a local discount store and taking the groceries home by bus and foot.  

    To each her own.  As long as we're making an effort, I think that counts towards passing home economics.  

    Saving time isn't always worth the cost of those extra dollars, though.  Don't get me wrong, I can barely tell which end of the screwdriver to use, so of course if something goes wrong with the plumbing, I'm not going to try to fix it myself (barring the most obvious of obvious wrongs, of course).  But things like making my own lunch (and adding plenty of snacks!) saves me at least $3 a day--I usually stick to soup and yogurt if I do buy lunch--and takes me 10 minutes.

    I wholeheartedly agree:  just because it comes from a discount store doesn't mean it's any cheaper.  I especially watch coffee prices (it's not available in bulk in either of the two supermarkets that are within a reasonable biking distance), and it always amuses me to see the more expensive supermarket carry cheaper coffee.  

    giving people an "A for effort" is the reason they do not understand basic home budgeting in the first place! Because the education system gave them brownie points for trying, that was just enough to let them squeak by and even get diplomas/degrees...

    I had a professor in college who responded to a classmate's inquiry as to whether we would get "participation" points and he said "No, isn't that why you are here and paying $45k a year?! Everybody should try, but that does not mean everybody should be successful"  I loved that guy...

    If a person really needs to buy something, then odds are high that an item will be much cheaper to purchase online rather than going to a store like Wal-Mart.  Many people who have decided to buy a big screen TV should go to an online retailer like http://www.TVstore.biz rather than Wal-Mart or a specialty TV store.  You will save more money and the bonus is that you donĀ“t have to leave your home to buy it, so you save gas.

    Why not be good at budgeting your time AND your money?

    I make several trips to several stores but not in the same day.  On Saturday, I needed to go to a store that had something on sale.   While there,  I looked in the flyer for the other two stores in the shoppign complex and got some other things  I eventually needed that were on sale.  Now, I know I need toothpaste but it's not on sale this week and I'm not driving out of my way to get it.  But next week, I'll go to the place it's on sale and try to group my shopping to the same place.  I do have the luxury of going to several different groups of stores because I live in a metropolitan area.  It's the best way to make the most of your time AND your money!

    "If a person really needs to buy something, then odds are high that an item will be much cheaper to purchase online rather than going to a store like Wal-Mart"

    However, the cost of shipping might eat up the difference! So, the answer as always is, it depends.

    My wife and I started what we called the no spend year this year.  We started the year off paying off all debt.  We promised to only use cash.  For the year our total discrencenary expesnses have totalled just over $800, which were mostly clothes.  My Ipod and satelite radio were stolen from my car and my laptop took its last breath.  I didn't run out to replace those things like I would have in past years.  I must say we feel great.  And we realize just how much money we have spent in the past on things that we didn't need.  Our savings accounts sure do thank us.  Try it for your family....at times it will be hard to say no, but at the end of the year you will feel great and have some extra money in your savings....not to mention you won't go further into debt with the credit cards.....I have learned to live without credit cards and it is life changing.

    simple dont buy crap you dont need...

    Send a Comment

    Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

    (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):