Search Smart Spending:

Unemployment benefits: Who gets left out?

Posted Nov 25 2008, 06:16 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

Unemployment benefits have been extended and that's good news for laid-off workers, right? But did you know that many people who've lost their job aren't eligible to collect?

In fact, former Labor Secretary Robert Reich writes at his blog that "most people who lose their job these days don't qualify for any unemployment benefits at all."

And, we'll add, it's often low-wage and female workers who get left out.

The Center for American Progress Action Fund reports: "Under current law only an average of 37% of unemployed workers actually collect benefits at all, with low-wage, part-time, and female workers particularly harmed by outdated state eligibility rules."

Who can collect is determined state by state, and is often based on laws written in the days when the husband was the breadwinner, and worked one steady job until he retired.

Reich writes at another blog, "Even though those realities have changed, the rules haven't. In most states, you're eligible for unemployment insurance only if you've lost a full-time job that you've had for quite a while. This leaves out just about everyone who's lost one or more part-time jobs. And also excludes any full-time worker who had been at the job less than a year before they got canned."

The Unemployment Insurance Modernization Act, passed by the U.S. House, would address some of these issues.

Whether or not it becomes law, those who lose their jobs should find out immediately if they qualify for benefits. Even if you were part time, you might be eligible in your state. The Associated Press answers a lot of questions about how to apply.

Other information from the Center for American Progress:

  • The average worker who qualifies for this safety net gets $293 a week. The lowest maximum benefit is $230, in Mississippi. Nine states have a maximum payment in excess of $500 a week.
  • In June, 45.5% of mortgage delinquencies reported by Freddie Mac were due to unemployment or lost income.
  • During the current economic downturn, 22.3% of unemployed workers -- 2.26 million people -- have been searching for work for more than six months.

On the other side of the coin, the conservative Heritage Foundation says extending unemployment benefits prolongs the time that people are out of work because they feel less pressure to find a new job.

Comments

 

i have one thing to say   about all the whining. I lost my job didn't qaulify for benifits because i waited to long to applied. so i went to aday labor place to work. this was great i had a income coming in and the flexblty to look for a better job. then the economy wnt bust because of two types of idiots. the banks who made stupid loans to people who clearly did not qualify for those loans. and then there the idioits who took those loans for house they could not afford trying to impress their neigbors. Im a highschool graduate and know that 30% of your income is all you should spend on your home. thats the maxium you should spend.  not the minium so when their is hard times you cut back and you can survive.

This can only get worse as all the unemployed run out of savings and unemployment benefits. When we can't spend more jobs will be lost. I live in a county where unemployment is 10% and climbin so enjoy your job while you have it ,you could be looking at this from the unemployed side  before this ends if it ever does.

When it comes to social conciousness and government help for people in need, the United States ranks very low on the list of  'civilized' countries in the world that have a social safety net.  Our country is one of the most stingy of all the western democracies.

To all the bashers out there complaining about how "their" tax money is paying for the unemployed my message is simple. Quit bitching and look at the big picture. Most unemployed people are lifers who spent long careers and paid much more into the unemployment system than they will ever take out. You had better stand by your fellow americans and quit complaining about someone taking a few dollars to try to make it to the next job. Keep the following in mind. Your job is probably next to go to China so the corporate executives can buy the second yacht they so desperately need.

I sympathize with those of you have been laid off - I was laid off in the early 90s and it took me 5 months to find a job - it was pretty crappy and less money. We do pay into our unemployment benefits with our employers contributing also so you have a right to collect while looking anybody who say otherwise is a facist pig or probably a government worker of some type who has know idea what its like to work in the private sector. My question is - if the private sector is losing jobs and becoming lean - when will our fat, bloated, over compensated government - State & Fed follow suit? Those people are the true leeches - living off of taxpayer's money!Again this is an example off how the Politicians promote taxes for one thing and take the money and put it elsewhere - Can anyone say Social Security?

Mike in ILL....right you are about pigs in high places and people being ready to be next on UE line...I've been in the same manufacturing job for 24+ yrs,working on avg. 50-55 hrs wkly..times are plenty slow now and hopefullyI can keep a job if China will allow it to stay in U.S.I have planned ahead by paying off my home and autos and kept a savings,so I'm not a burden to anyone (at least yet)..To those who say to get a job or that these people are taking from you,I say you are full of it,and I'd love to meet you in a dark alley or phone booth...Keep the faith folks,maybe we can get thru this as a nation.

I saw a posting a couple pages back from someone who claimed that we don't have any money deducted from our paychecks for unemployment. Maybe where you live that is the case, but I have a line on my pay stub for UNEM. This is the amount deducted from every one of my paychecks to help fund the unemployment system.  As far as unemployment compensation is concerned, no one should ever feel guilty about taking it. You've paid into it your whole working career, contrary to that one poster who probably has an employer who is cheating the system some how.

Just would like to mention, the unemployment statistics do not include many people that are not eligible for unemployment as we are subcontractors.

Of course I understand we did not pay into the unemployment system and certainly do not expect anything, just want to bring attention to the fact, that there are thousands of people unemployed whom are not reflected in the figures,

The unemployment rate in TN is higher than the national average.  I'm now drawing unemployment after paying into the system for over 30 years...I don't feel I'm living off anybody.  The maximum is 275 and that's not enough to keep you from having to live under a bridge.  While welfare isn't taxed, unemployment is and the government ends up with a percentage of this money back anyway.  The Federal government needs to bail out it's citizens instead of big corporations but they'd rather sh** and sit in it than put any amount of our own money into our hands.  Freddie Mac has reported that almost half of mortgage delinquencies are from job loss, they receive money from the government while we still lose our homes...that doesn't make much sense.  While I more than understand the resentment of people living off our tax dollars, I think welfare has become more of a drain that unemployment.

I was working a fulltime job and a parttime job to make ends meat while my wife was/is

going back to school. I was laid off from my fulltime job and my part time job counted twards my unemployment benefits. I had to decide to quit my parttime job to get my benefits. If i worked 15-20 hrs a week those wages counted tward my unemployment and my check was smaller so at that job I was working for nothing. Penalize the ones trying to help themselves

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):