Search Smart Spending:

Unemployment benefits: Who gets left out?

Posted Nov 25 2008, 06:16 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

Unemployment benefits have been extended and that's good news for laid-off workers, right? But did you know that many people who've lost their job aren't eligible to collect?

In fact, former Labor Secretary Robert Reich writes at his blog that "most people who lose their job these days don't qualify for any unemployment benefits at all."

And, we'll add, it's often low-wage and female workers who get left out.

The Center for American Progress Action Fund reports: "Under current law only an average of 37% of unemployed workers actually collect benefits at all, with low-wage, part-time, and female workers particularly harmed by outdated state eligibility rules."

Who can collect is determined state by state, and is often based on laws written in the days when the husband was the breadwinner, and worked one steady job until he retired.

Reich writes at another blog, "Even though those realities have changed, the rules haven't. In most states, you're eligible for unemployment insurance only if you've lost a full-time job that you've had for quite a while. This leaves out just about everyone who's lost one or more part-time jobs. And also excludes any full-time worker who had been at the job less than a year before they got canned."

The Unemployment Insurance Modernization Act, passed by the U.S. House, would address some of these issues.

Whether or not it becomes law, those who lose their jobs should find out immediately if they qualify for benefits. Even if you were part time, you might be eligible in your state. The Associated Press answers a lot of questions about how to apply.

Other information from the Center for American Progress:

  • The average worker who qualifies for this safety net gets $293 a week. The lowest maximum benefit is $230, in Mississippi. Nine states have a maximum payment in excess of $500 a week.
  • In June, 45.5% of mortgage delinquencies reported by Freddie Mac were due to unemployment or lost income.
  • During the current economic downturn, 22.3% of unemployed workers -- 2.26 million people -- have been searching for work for more than six months.

On the other side of the coin, the conservative Heritage Foundation says extending unemployment benefits prolongs the time that people are out of work because they feel less pressure to find a new job.

Comments

 

The article is right, it is a good idea to immediately apply for benefits, even if you're a great worker with great records. There are a lot of highly skilled, honest, ethical people that are without work because of the economic environment, not them. Losers who game the system will continue to get the support they are used to. Hardworking people will be surprised at the lack of hiring and must remember they are suffering injustice because of others' economic indiscretions, and have a credible case to approach God for Him to bring the offending corporate fat cats to justice.

Much can be gained from reading history books on the Great Depression. Then, there was much opposition to working women. Why should some couples enjoy two breadwinners while other families suffer?  Women should get out of the workforce so that employers will be forced to hire men, who can then feed their families.  

Of course, today many people are single, and many working women may be supporting an unemployed husband, and some couples are mired in debt and decided long ago that both would be working for the rest of their pre-retirement years.

I'm taking hope in the fact that because of unemployment perhaps I can have access to the time of educated people who used to be really busy. I'd love to wine and dine a real estate professional and gain some of their knowledge.

Funny how many people can't find a single job when I pass help wanted signs at fast food places, supermarkets, department stores, and the like all the time. It's not that the jobs don't exist it's that people don't want the ones that do for one reason or another. Here's an idea.. Quit expecting the government to bail you out of everything, get off your lazy rear and go do something to get an income. Then you can moan and groan about how much the job sucks while you try to find a better one. I'd much rather not pay a dime into unemployment benefits, social security, or any other gov't "assistance" fund and just be responsible for my own fate.

Blah blah dih blah dirih blah.

We can talk all we want but it's up to the people to stop the greedy corporate culture of paying more to the one who doesn't even need it.

Let's end this now! let's force our politicians to start putting a top to the exagerated salaries that upper management has. They always get raises and bonuses and the people who actually works gets NOTHING at all.

I am really upset.

Can anyone give me some information about overseas citizens? My mom was a stay at home mother until our dad passed away 14 years back. Now she has been working abroad for some time & is aching to retire. She's 59 though she never paid any taxes. Is she eligible to a retirement fund? The bad thing is ; she has NO savings what-so-ever ! What to do ?? PLEASE SOMEONE ENLIGHTEN US....

People! Unemployment is one of the best programs set forth for the American person. If you work it offers a little financial security when you are unemployed. You must work for a specified period of time before you can collect and there are limits.

Less jobs = less people working

Too many people having kids = less jobs for those kids when they get older

Less jobs for those kids when they get older = less people working

Anyone see a trend?

If we don't control the population soon (I hope for a plague, eben if it takes me), noone will be able to afford anything as we will not have enough to cover those who need.

i have been employed for more than a year and the company became very strict in their numbers in production.  I am not in the bottom of the whole company when it come to production but they require you to be on the average level.  Since I have not been getting the average they require, they put me on a final warning and then was told that termination is possible.  If terminated, can I get unemployment because I did not meet their production average?

Thank you for allowing me to post here. I sympathize with everyone who has lost their job during these rough times. It is sad that we are to the point where you have to join the military again to make ends meet. I understand what it is like to be laid off. I was in the same situation back in 2006 when the housing market was at its peak. I was in Tucson, AZ at the time. The job market was scarce due to the rise in foreclosures throughout the city. Many people were getting laid off and a year after I moved from there, AOL closed all of its call centers and many of the call centers there were laying off as well. I am not the type to work in a call center so I worked temp jobs to make ends meet as an admin assistant. I was laid off from two of the temp jobs that I worked and then I was at the point where I had to go back into the military due in part that I wanted to work in IT again and finish my second degree.

I moved to another state in which I was told and noticed that the economy there was doing good and many people had no problem finding a job. After realizing that, I was able to get a job in which I enjoyed until they moved me to another department and I which my dream job dwindled away and now I am doing IT for the military part time. I was able to find another job, but in a different city and I have had my house on the market and it is not able to sell. I have tried to get my house to sell for 8 months, in which I was told that it should not be a problem to sell. I am starting to feel the effects of the economy in this city and it is hard to sell my house. I am too the point where I will rent it out and hopefully someone will want to purchase after renting it for a year or two.

As for those who say the unemployed are leeches, well that is not true, and if a worker has paid into those benefits, then they should understand that the government workers will soon realize what it is like to be laid off as well. Many IT jobs are going to different countries in Asia and South Africa, for corporations to save money and gives the top executives bonuses for a themselves and their families. There are families here that were not born with a silver spoon in their mouth. There are many who are not rich and willing to work to keep their families in good care. What I do not understand is why are the corporations getting bailout money that they do not need while many who loose their jobs are not getting enough unemployment to make ends meet at all?

It will take more than 4 years for the economy to recover, if it recovers at all for the citizens of the US (myself included) to have our textile jobs, where if you look at your clothes, they were made in China or somewhere else in Asia to come back to the US. The manufacture jobs and the auto industry which if it were to callapse, the economy will further resemble the Great Depression of the 1930's.  The IT jobs began their outsourcing long before Sept 11, 2001. It is now starting to bring many of them back to the US but for how long?

I have been in constuction all my working days , that is twenty five years.  I lost my job in Jan. 2007, I drove heavy equipment and had a good paying job. I, for the first time in my life drawed unemployment benfits. I for one had rather work than draw unemployment. There are no jobs to be found in this arear.  How sad it is when we live in the greatest country in the world and people here are unable to find work.

John

This is the new unemployed worker:  laid off due to dirty politics for personal gain - in other words, trying to keep their jobs while telling lies on others - having a mortgage and other personal debt - just like you - now wondering how to 1- get another job while 2- trying to keep what I have.  I live in a modest home, with minimal stuff, just an average person.  

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):