Search Smart Spending:

Unemployment benefits: Who gets left out?

Posted Nov 25 2008, 06:16 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

Unemployment benefits have been extended and that's good news for laid-off workers, right? But did you know that many people who've lost their job aren't eligible to collect?

In fact, former Labor Secretary Robert Reich writes at his blog that "most people who lose their job these days don't qualify for any unemployment benefits at all."

And, we'll add, it's often low-wage and female workers who get left out.

The Center for American Progress Action Fund reports: "Under current law only an average of 37% of unemployed workers actually collect benefits at all, with low-wage, part-time, and female workers particularly harmed by outdated state eligibility rules."

Who can collect is determined state by state, and is often based on laws written in the days when the husband was the breadwinner, and worked one steady job until he retired.

Reich writes at another blog, "Even though those realities have changed, the rules haven't. In most states, you're eligible for unemployment insurance only if you've lost a full-time job that you've had for quite a while. This leaves out just about everyone who's lost one or more part-time jobs. And also excludes any full-time worker who had been at the job less than a year before they got canned."

The Unemployment Insurance Modernization Act, passed by the U.S. House, would address some of these issues.

Whether or not it becomes law, those who lose their jobs should find out immediately if they qualify for benefits. Even if you were part time, you might be eligible in your state. The Associated Press answers a lot of questions about how to apply.

Other information from the Center for American Progress:

  • The average worker who qualifies for this safety net gets $293 a week. The lowest maximum benefit is $230, in Mississippi. Nine states have a maximum payment in excess of $500 a week.
  • In June, 45.5% of mortgage delinquencies reported by Freddie Mac were due to unemployment or lost income.
  • During the current economic downturn, 22.3% of unemployed workers -- 2.26 million people -- have been searching for work for more than six months.

On the other side of the coin, the conservative Heritage Foundation says extending unemployment benefits prolongs the time that people are out of work because they feel less pressure to find a new job.

Comments

 

As an unemployed person receiving umemployment benefits, I resent the  conservative Heritage Foundation's scrutiny of the extension of unemployment benefits.  Who cares if we feel less pressure to find a new job, we have endured so much already, facing forceclosure of our homes, struggling to afford basic needs for our families. Give me a break, so it takes me "2-3" weeks longer to find a job. The search for a job can become so dim and disappointing at times.  The benefits are no more then 500 per week at most, compared to the billion dollar bailouts of greedy corporations who won't blink at spending on lavish vacations, arriving in Washington D.C. in separate private jets (which also takes a toll on  the environmen) I don't think our little benefits that we received and are significant enough to make a stink about.  

I think cookie is living in a dream world. The government is there to take money out of my pocket and and give it someone else. How fair is that?  I have no job and live on a pension. No money for me just taxes.

For one thing it doesn't take the pressure off of finding a job so where the Heritage Foundation gets that idea I would like to know.  Looking for 3 and more jobs a week is no picnic.  Another, unless you are the one unemployed and looking for work, which I doubt any of them are, then I say they don't know what they are talking about.  Everybody can sit around and bounce ideas and statistics off each other all day long but unless you are actually the one out there having to do this then it is my opinion that they do not know what they speak of.  Course it doesn't look like they are taking in the whole picture of all that's happening around us either.  It's pretty sad when a think tank corporation has to pick on people who are out of work through no fault of their own and on top of it. losing homes, cars, belongings, and hope because of the economy.

I'm generally anti-welfare and entitlements but I think it's important to have a small unemployment safety net.  People who become unemployeed through no fault of there own are very different than the social leaches who game and live off the system.   I feel like most states have decent enough benefits for those recently unemployed.  New york offers a max of 405/week.  This would allow me to live bare bones and not have to dip into my savings.  Keep in mind I'm just a single Gen-Yer with very few expenses.    

I'm generally anti-welfare and entitlements but I think it's important to have a small unemployment safety net.  People who become unemployeed through no fault of there own are very different than the social leaches who game and live off the system.   I feel like most states have decent enough benefits for those recently unemployed.  New york offers a max of 405/week.  This would allow me to live bare bones and not have to dip into my savings.  Keep in mind I'm just a single Gen-Yer with very few expenses.    

Arizona has a max of $240.00 why would anyone want to stay home on that??  I cant feed my family and keep a roof over our head with that. I love hearing from people that I am over qualified.. I just want a job!!!

Don  I think you are the one living in a dream world.

I have worked hard over the past 12 years and have paid my taxes - unemployment taxes as well - you're the one living off the system whereas I have paid a percentage of my paycheck for years towards the unemployment system AS WELL AS my employer who is also obligated to pay a portion towards the unemployment system.

As an architect who is unlikely to see a job in my profession come my way anytime soon I am now applying for jobs that I am way overqualified just so I can get back to work - try looking for work that even pays near what I made is impossible I am now desparately applying for jobs that will just barely pay my bills. It's tough out there!

The blogs are interesting, but nothing is going to happen until the un-employed start marching on Washington. This is a problem the Government could have put a halt to. Both sides knew about it, supposedly tried to raise a flag.  Our government has failed it's people. We need to demand that they bail us out!

Don't attack each other, put the blame where it belongs in Washington. There are blood sucking corporations out there still trying get every last drop. The fact that the average Joe will be dead doesn't concern them at all. There are not enough jobs, and most companies are still laying off. We need to wake up fast, and demand more help to survive what's coming. Remember how we use to say the only ones that could get credit were the people that don't need it. We're back to that, and now the only ones that can get a Bailout is the ones who can buy it in Washington.

get a job and quit living off of me

john....

who is living off you?  Everyone receiving unemployment has paid into their own unemployment insurance.  I have worked over25 years...I have surely paid for my own unemployment insurance and some. Its sad how people make  statements before getting the facts.  I sure hope you never hit a bump in the road or never need help for any reason.  

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):