Search Smart Spending:

Just say no to Christmas gifts

Posted Nov 24 2008, 02:20 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

As part of his popular Save $1,000 in 30 Days Challenge, blogger Ramit Sethi is on to what might be his biggest and best money-saving idea. Tip No. 18 of the challenge is "No Christmas gifts this year."

"This year, Americans are planning to spend over $400 on Christmas gifts," he writes. "Instead of buying things we can't afford, here's a way to do something more meaningful."

For a lot of people who haven't taken steps to brace themselves for the coming economic reality, the first question should be: "Where can I sign up?"

According to an American Research Group survey cited by Ramit, Americans plan to spend an average of $431 on holiday gifts this year, about half of last year's average. But many people shouldn't be doing even that.

(Ramit quotes New York Times columnist Thomas Friedman, who wrote that he gets the urge to tell young diners at restaurants, "You should be saving your money. You should be home eating tuna fish. This financial crisis is so far from over. We are just at the end of the beginning.")

But how can you explain your new no-gifts status to friends and loved ones? Ramit is well aware of how touchy this can be. "Can you even imagine calling your parents, or your girlfriend, or talking to your son about how you can't afford to buy something this year?" he writes. "Of course not."

Ramit, who blogs at I Will Teach You To Be Rich, makes it easier. You can send e-cards via his new Web site to people on your list that suggest alternatives to buying gifts -- fun or worthwhile activities you can do together, like cooking a meal, learning a new skill or volunteering for a charity. You can fill in your own suggestion and select the appearance of your card.

Some of his readers were enthusiastic. Others balked, but agreed to be more mindful of spending. "There is no way I am going to not give gifts to my children," reader Cymbidium said.

Comments

 

We are having a Secret Santa Christmas this year.  With times tight for everyone, this seemed ideal.  We drew names and now you only have one person to buy for.  There is only one child in the family, a teenager, but she was more than willing to participate in this new way of celebrating, so she was included in the name drawing.  We are all grown adults who have everything we could possibly want or need, so this will be fun.  Plus, what a great way to get to know new members of the family (spouses, boy/girfriends).  We put no spending restrictions in our plan since you were only shopping for one person.  Everyone in the family is on board with it and very excited!

Gift giving is largely a symbolic activity that reinforces the relationship between people, and there is no reason that can't be done extremely inexpensively.  We just blogged about this at Thrive, but the short version is: a good gift is the one that says something about your relationship to a person, and reminds them that you know about them because you care about them.  For under $10, you can easily find dozens of gifts that demonstrate that you know a person's interests and personality and that reflect on your bond.

No gifts is relatively less satisfying, as it doesn't entirely capitalize on that relationship, nor does sending a digital "I spammed this to 200 people this holiday season" card.  Ramit was headed in the right direction, but part of a gift is the effort behind it and a digital "let's do this together" that you don't actually do is unlikely to deliver on that symbolic, and psychological, process.

http://www.justthrive.com

This holiday season I'm planning to hit up great sales and get good deals on nice gifts for family and friends.  (ie: Bought my mom a Vera Bradley bag for $36, on sale from $60)  It's spending less, but still getting your loved ones something nice and thoughtful.  

However, I'm all in favor of homemade gifts such as themed baskets, baking bread or cookies, or knitting a hat or scarf to give.  It really is the thought that counts.

www.becomingthemarshmallow.com

christmas is out of control. why not just get together for dinner? parents can give their own children gifts before the come over, and everybody just enjoys each other"s company after that.i'll bet most poeple would be relieved knowing they dont have to spend extra money they don't have.think about it.my family has been doing this for years and nobody fee ls less loved. have you ever recieved/given a "hated" gift? very uncomfy.life doesn't always hve to be about material gain. by the way, merry christmas!

I'm buying very few presents this year -- almost none except the gifts for the children whose names I picked off the church's angel tree.  The shirts for one child and jacket for another will mean a lot more to the recipients than more stuff will mean for my family.

I will buy small things for the children in the family, probably page-a-day calendars because they love them and because those can be enjoyed all year.  Other than that, nothing except homemade goodies.

Years ago when I was in college and no way could I afford to do extravagent gifts I learned how to make ChexMix and dipped chocolate pretzels--especially using the holiday-shaped pretzels.  For each gift I'd make up a gallon zip bag of ChexMix and maybe a quart zip bag of pretzels.  Everyone loved them and no one thought I was cheap--at least not to my face :)  Now it is an EXPECTED gift.... :) And now that my mother spends a good part of Dec with me we make the ChexMix and pretzels together and she sends them to HER friends as well...plus it's a neat family tradition.

Not to be a Scrooge--but I looked at the Angel Tree put up at our church this weekend and it was outrageous the EXPENSIVE things kids wanted!!  Wiis and Playstations, and Digital Cameras and cell phones and MP3 players and $50-$100 gift cards!!  I heard the same thing from other folks checking it out.  About the cheapest thing I saw was one girl wanting a Tinkerbelle DVD.  I am VERY reluctant to give gift cards for places like WalMart as I wonder if the parents get them instead of the kids.  I think I'll pass on the Angel Tree this year...

The past several years have been up and down.  This year even more down.  My kids have become accustomed to what I call a tax refund Christmas; sometimes with a real Christmas tree and sometimes the little fake one.  The kids get one gift at Christmas, and a few more at tax refund time.  This year I think I will will have to pull out the little fake tree, omit the one gift at Christmas, and keep the tax refund Christmas very small.

If we all start eating tuna out of a can we will only accelerate the recession. Even people

in the media like the individual suggesting we all eat tuna out of a can will lose their jobs.

Imagine that (it isn't hard to do, imagine all the media eating tuna fish out of a can, you may say I'm a dreamer but I'm not the only one)

Last year, I shopped very early for all the friends & family.  It of course was very rewarding to find great gifts for those I loved but I felt like we all (me, my husband, and our family & friends) were very fortunate and lucky to be able to afford what we need and want for the most part.  It just didn't feel right that we're all going out spending all this money on each other when really the holiday is about being with friends & family & helping those in need (not just fulfilling people's unnecessary wishes).  The most rewarding experience was choosing a homeless family to buy gifts for.  I bought necessary items for a baby girl.  At that point, I began thinking that's what we should all be doing.  And now with everything that's going on with the economy this year, if people have anything to spare, we should spend that money on people who need it.  I agree we shouldn't spoil any kids' Christmas'...if I have young kids to shop for, they are the priority.  But for the grown-ups, I think we can pass on the unnecessary spending.  Now the fun part, seeing who's up for this!

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):