Search Smart Spending:

5 valid reasons to stop using cell phones

Posted Nov 04 2008, 06:55 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

David G. Mitchell knows he's not preaching to the choir when he strongly recommends that most people stop using cell phones. He observes that "I will not use a cell phone and you probably cannot be separated from yours."

Yet, he makes a compelling argument in a pithy post at Saving Advice that provides five reasons to give up cell phones and save money.

Health is one of his concerns.

Research hasn't confirmed a direct link between long-term cell phone use and cancer, possibly because cell phones have been widely used for a relatively short time. But some studies suggest a connection. As a result, the director of the University of Pittsburgh Cancer Institute cautioned employees to limit their use.

Among the things we do know for sure:

Chatting on the phone while driving contributes to vehicle crashes. That's why some states have wised up and banned use of handheld phones behind the wheel.

Cell phones have opportunity costs because they distract you from the task at hand, whether you're meeting a client or, we'll add, out on a date. David writes, "Unless you are a doctor waiting to perform crucial surgery or you have some significant role in national security, chances are you are just not important enough to need to be available all the time."

(He also says, "If you cannot go to a grocery store and decide what to buy when you get to the produce aisle, you should not be grocery shopping.")

Cell phone accessories are expensive, not to mention the cost of texting, Internet access, etc.

We don't need to be constantly accessible. We got along pretty well when all we had were land lines.

An exception, he says, is having a prepaid cell phone in case of true emergencies -- when you're driving in the middle of nowhere or your teens are out and about at night.

"Give up the cell phone and put that money back in your pocket and you will really find that no one had anything to say to you anyway," he writes.

Comments

 

I agree with oklahoma, you people are NOT that important to where you need to be accessible 24/7....we all seemed to survive just fine before cell phones..they are a LUXURY not a necesity!!

Get a grip - The human element is the problem - a dependency upon something that, for the most part, most people can and should do without; that was the author's point.   Our culture has become a bunch of spoiled brats who can't be without their toys, not because they need them, but because they need to be entertained.  If people put as much energy into meeting the needs of others as they did into instant self-gratification (like an unnecessary phone call while driving) our country would be so much better off.    

I resisted getting a cell phone until last year.  I keep it turned off in many cases since I do not like to be interrupted while driving, in Church, or in some other places where it is not convenient.  However, for a true emergency it could be very important -- if coverage was available.  I have a set number of minutes per month, foreign calls are quite reasonable (only use pre-owned minutes plus a small service charge), and it is a luxury which I can live with.  I agree that shopping while on the phone is a bit strange, and some children appear to be quite obcessed with talking on the phone.  

In today's society, everything moves so quickly, depending on your lifestyle, cell phones are just better.  I am opening a new business and spend a lot of time running errands, etc.  I have an unlimited plan which is perfect for me.  There have been numerous occasions when I was very glad I had it with me.

My best friend is housebound at the moment and I always want to be available in case of emergency.  Also, I don't have time to be tied to a land line.  I need to be mobile or I'd never get anything done.  With my cell, I can walk around the house and cook, move laundry around, take out the garbage.....anything.  A land line, even with a cordless phone (usually larger than a cell), is too confining.  

If I need to use a phone, it's in my pocket.  As a woman, I feel safer with my cell phone.  It keeps me from having to find a payphone somewhere in an emergency.  I would not want to get out of my car, day or night, on a highway to go for help.  It's my "security blanket".

i have a pre paid cell phone. id ont see anything wrong with cell phone usage except where it is posted like hospitals and courtrooms  classrooms and other places who ask that you turn your phones off and those who insist on talking while driving and those who take their calls and talk so loudly you cant but help hear them. it seems to me as of late though that the bigger problems with cell phones is all the texting that ppl are doing. texting while driving in a classroom during dinner with dates and movies or while someone is actually face to face with someone and they are texting another. the texting on cell phones and ppls lack of consideration and common decency i think is out of control and often just rude.  i tell everybody i have given my number to that if they text me they will not receive a text reply from me. if you have to text ppl then you really dont have anything important to say, if you did you would actually make the time and make an actual phone call and talk to the other person. or you are just really too cheap to actually use your minutes. if i were a teacher and i saw my students in class with a cell phone on in my class i would automatically give them failing marks for the day and send them out of my class. i would construe their phone usagae as a means of receiving information as a way to cheat academically. if schools did this the kids would not have their phones in  class.

I agree with all the 'pro-cell phone people'.  We have no land lines (saves us $40-50 a month, thank you), we have moved a lot, too, travel with children (excuse me? I am not walking down a highway with 3 kids in tow to find a PAY PHONE!!) and my husband and I use a $4 corded head phone attachment so that the phone is not right next to our heads and so that we are 'hands on the wheel' when we drive.  I'm not even technologically saavy and I can clearly see the benefits.  Plus, my friend in FL and I talk 'free' because we have the same cell service.  The piousness of people with land lines saying cell phone users have a huge ego is really short sighted as is the writer of the article.  Sorry!  Cell phones, like computers, are here to stay...

You can go live like an Amish person if you want, but don't expect the rest of to feel bad if we don't want to.  

To Cell smell,

You are right! People didn't stop for me because I believe that they thought I had a cell phone. At that unfortunate car breakdown, I had no cell! I waited 2 hours before someone came along with a cell for me to use! Then I had to wait even longer for help to arrive. Joe Six Pack has a point.

  Some People at one time in History said; "We don't need horseless carriages.."cars".

Some people at one time said we don't need telephones.....they are bad for our health.  

Some people at one time said computors were bad for our health, and we don't need them anyway....some still say that.

Now;  Some people say we don't need cell phones.....They have become part of alot of people's lives.....

Like anything,  those who use them properly will be fine with cellphones.   Then there always those who will abuse a good thing.

All it takes is Common Sense.

Bottom line, everything is good to use as long as you don't abuse...just like sugar and sunshine..too much can kill you! There are pros and cons but it shouldn't be a I CANT LIVE WITHOUT MY CELLPHONE type of deal! I think a life is too precious to waste if you are in a situation and something dreadful happens because....you didn't have a cellphone

I would argue that as land lines tend to be rather expensive (and offer little service for the cost) it makes more sense, from a fiscal perspective, to abandon land-line service and go completely cellular as did our family in January 2004.

Regardless of the non-fiscal reasons outlined by the author, I can't think of single reason to continue spending money on a land-line.  We, as a family of three, spend only 40% more for having cell phone service than we did for land-line service and that 40% includes a family text messaging plan that I originally had no use for, but have found to be quite useful, especially when trying to contact our daughter.  

Do yourselves a favour:  drop your land-line altogether.

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):