Search Smart Spending:

When friends don't pay you back

Posted Oct 23 2008, 03:44 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

When you lend money to a friend and he doesn't pay you back, what do you do? Enlisting the aid of the Soprano crew is not an option, so do you sulk, get mad, get even, or pester the person until he cracks?

Fitz at Ready To Be Rich has some potential solutions, but first, let's examine whether you should lend money to friends at all.

Our approach is to give rather than lend if a friend needs help. That eliminates the possibility of hard feelings. We learned a sour lesson many years ago when we unwisely stretched our resources to lend a friend several hundred dollars, and later learned that when she came into some cash, she bought a new couch and didn't pay us back.

(In fact, not being repaid can really eat at you. Fitz writes: "Each month that the loan remains unpaid, you lose more hope of getting your money back. Consequently, feelings of anger and resentment toward your friend begin to consume you.")

Our partner blogger, Donna Freedman, is more comfortable with lending to friends, even though, she recently wrote, "some people to whom I've lent money in the past wound up repaying only part of it. Sometimes, life just happens that way."

If you make the loan

An article at MSN Money suggests you have a frank conversation with your friend about his or her financial situation before you decide to make a loan. You'll then have an idea of whether you'd be throwing good money after bad.

If you commit, Donna and Fitz say, you should lend no more than you can afford to lose. Get the terms in writing, another MSN Money article advises.

From there, Fitz offers suggestions on how to proceed. Among them:

    • Remind your friend about the loan several days before repayment is due. E-mail works well.

    • If that deadline is missed, set a second date no more than three weeks in the future. Again, remind the friend.

    • If that date is missed, have a talk to agree on an alternate payment arrangement.

    "Sincerely ask him the reason why he's having a hard time meeting the payment deadline," Fitz says. "Don't be emotional during this talk." Your options include accepting smaller payments over time or an item your friend owns that has a value equal to the amount you're owed. Or, you can have your friend do some kind of work for you. Or you can forgive the loan and try to forget.

    Comments

     

    How about some specific advice on what you can do to get payment on the loans that were given.  Enough with the "don't loan money" responses.  That wasn't the title of the article.  How to hire an attorney, small claims court, how to get a judgement against somebody etc.

    Never lend money to anyone without  accepting the fact that you may never get it back. I have learned this lesson the hard way and will never loan money again.

    If the money is in a savings account (bank or credit union), why not do a formal loan? Borrow against the savings, and have the financial institution do a loan contract with set pmt amt,  due dates, interest. Keep close tabs on the friend making the payments. You can set it up so the bank takes the pmt out of your savings, automatically to ward off any 'hit' to your credit, if he is late, or misses a pmt. If he pays it off perfectly, it's a win/win. Your credit score goes up and your friend's credit with you goes up. Why risk having your & your friend's personal info. getting out for strangers to nose into?

    A friend had transferred from the department I'm in to another.  While working late one night, I received a call from her on my cell phone just as I was exiting the parking garage.  She was stranded at a gas station and said that she could not find her wallet and someone must have stolen it.  I told her not to worry and I was on my way.  As I inserted my credit card into the machine so that she could fill up her auto to get home, she said how much she appreciated what I was doing and she would pay me back tomorrow.  I told her not to worry about that right now and let's focus on getting you home.  The charge was $60.00.  It's been since June 2007 and she has not paid me back.  Each time it comes up she changes the subject or a relative is sick.  She was to pay me back on Friday and when I e-mailed her for a time to meet downstairs she writes back that her niece is in the hospital.  My male friend said that he would e-mail her and ask where my money is.   As I told her in the e-mail, each time I see her I think about her owing me money and I just don't want to think about it anymore and she could either pay me back in full or arrange a payment plan.  

    i would never expect to some one telling me that let me barow $5 dollers. sothen they say i will pay you back towmarow and you give them the money and they never bring the money back. and you keep whiating and whiating and you never get your money back.

    mony and friend should not be in a balance if you friend is honest you can lend money for him but should write a bill signed in acknowlegement of debt

    Your advice is good, however what if you lend money to a son, or daughter, and they loose their job, and can't pay you back. Can you deduct the money from your income taxes?

    i loan money to guy i do not know if i will get it back

    NEVER in life will I ever loan friends money...one friend has owed me $2400 for over three years and another $5400 for the past 6 months..... They are both playing games and every time I speak with them all I get is...something game up yada yada..I will pay this day and that day....promises promises....   I am angry that I even helped either one of them. I have asked to set up a payment plan but still have not received the money..... there will not be a next time I don't care if they are dead or dying....DON'T LOAN FRIENDS OR FAMILY MONEY UNLESS YOU CAN AFFORD TO TAKE THE LOSS! JUST SAY NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!

    I lent (out of good will, via written checks, I had a good  job at the time, before I got laid off) a close friend $16,000 over the course of a year to help them out (with rent, food, etc., I also helped them sift through job ads to try to find a job) back in 2006 when they were unemployed.  At that time, I said don't worry about paying me back, but the person said they would pay me back.  They now have a good job and I'm  just coming out of unemployment with a short contract job I found and I also still have my school loan of about $16,000 to pay off.  The tables have turned, and I asked if my friend would get the ball rolling on paying me back, but I am met with excuses, or no replies, etc.  They have also moved to another state upon landing a new job.  I will never be lending out money like this again.  Is there anything legal I can do to try to recover the money or will it be hard to argue whether this was a gift or loan?

    Send a Comment

    Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

    (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):