Search Smart Spending:

When friends don't pay you back

Posted Oct 23 2008, 03:44 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

When you lend money to a friend and he doesn't pay you back, what do you do? Enlisting the aid of the Soprano crew is not an option, so do you sulk, get mad, get even, or pester the person until he cracks?

Fitz at Ready To Be Rich has some potential solutions, but first, let's examine whether you should lend money to friends at all.

Our approach is to give rather than lend if a friend needs help. That eliminates the possibility of hard feelings. We learned a sour lesson many years ago when we unwisely stretched our resources to lend a friend several hundred dollars, and later learned that when she came into some cash, she bought a new couch and didn't pay us back.

(In fact, not being repaid can really eat at you. Fitz writes: "Each month that the loan remains unpaid, you lose more hope of getting your money back. Consequently, feelings of anger and resentment toward your friend begin to consume you.")

Our partner blogger, Donna Freedman, is more comfortable with lending to friends, even though, she recently wrote, "some people to whom I've lent money in the past wound up repaying only part of it. Sometimes, life just happens that way."

If you make the loan

An article at MSN Money suggests you have a frank conversation with your friend about his or her financial situation before you decide to make a loan. You'll then have an idea of whether you'd be throwing good money after bad.

If you commit, Donna and Fitz say, you should lend no more than you can afford to lose. Get the terms in writing, another MSN Money article advises.

From there, Fitz offers suggestions on how to proceed. Among them:

    • Remind your friend about the loan several days before repayment is due. E-mail works well.

    • If that deadline is missed, set a second date no more than three weeks in the future. Again, remind the friend.

    • If that date is missed, have a talk to agree on an alternate payment arrangement.

    "Sincerely ask him the reason why he's having a hard time meeting the payment deadline," Fitz says. "Don't be emotional during this talk." Your options include accepting smaller payments over time or an item your friend owns that has a value equal to the amount you're owed. Or, you can have your friend do some kind of work for you. Or you can forgive the loan and try to forget.

    Comments

     

    I had a friend who needed a car and I offered buy it for her.  She found the car and even though it was a bit higher than the suggested amount, I paid for the car.  She said she would pay me back.  I knew that would be extremely difficult so I told her, no she did not need to replay me.  However, I told her that one day someone will come to her for help and I expect her to do like wise.  

    It's been my experience to have loaned good friends money and ending up with an ex-good friend...also the people who need money the most, are the ones who would never ask...strange how that works. Just hand over the cash and don't count on getting it back. Or back away s-l-o-w-l-y, then run!!!

    So far I’ve read a lot of comments from people who have generously extended themselves to “friends” who never repay.  Where are all the comments from all these people who have borrowed money and never paid any back?  I hope they’re all squirming at their PC’s.  And for all of you who claim that they lent money and not expect payback, let me ask you:  Would you borrow money from a friend and then feel free to just forget about it?  If not, then why is it okay for you to let other people get away with such rotten behavior?  

    A Friend loaned me over $4,000 to pay off a car I had just purchased to save me from a 26% nterrest rate. We set up a payment plan, but after two months I paid him back and he would not accept interrest. I did not want to lose such a good friend!

    So, I guess it's how much someone values friendship as to how the thing will turn out.

    If you borrow someone $20 and you never see them again....

                It was probably worth it....

    Loaning money and providing a roof over thier head rent free should only be on short term and keep loans small. watch everything closely and follow gut feeling, eye contact and the truth very important. You aren't getting solid eye contact and the stories don't add up cut your loss and your deadbeat friend NOW, before it gets deeper (in your pocket). I am too honest and an easy touch too often it's later and more expensive than I planed even if I lose. I found small, cheap spy video cameras a solid buy. Catch your deadbeat "Friend" helping himself and going through your belongings a big violation of trust and honesty a perfect excuse to verbaly berate that lowlife as you show them the door while cutting your loss. Wish I could follow my own advice before there was a large tab, never to recoup. Many so called friends are just setting you up and have no mores. Catch them on film, toss'em out and strong-arm them, empty thier pockets everytime you see them. until paid off with interest. Remember they were not your friend, they were playing you. Lowest form of human filth to lie to befriend so as to steal from another. Let it go, cut the loss, or show no mercy and draw blud, bang heads. A good pay back if the offender is a drinker and drives. Stake out thier watering hole and cell 911 about a drunk on the road. Easy to make thier life misserable, court, jail, high insurance, license revoke etc. Now if they have a lot of gold fillings in thier mouth, brass-knuckles....enough.

    ..lets face it, friends that beg for money are no friends, they are leeches and bloodsuckers.....anyone that lends them cash is a fool, let them beg somewhere else...you do not need these kinds of parasites. Unless you are hard up and insecure for friends...these are not friends.

    This is an interesting problem.  We had friends come to us, because they didn't have the money to pay they're 1st months rent.  They had gone to family members who wouldn't come up with the money, either.  They had been through two bankruptcies, and had to move out of their home, because the bank was taking the property.  There are folks who have zero clue on how to handle money.  So, what did we do?  We gave them the money, and even though they said they would pay it all back, we considered it as a gift, for our own mental wellbeing.  It kinda works, but sometimes I like the idea of breaking something in their home, but there isn't anything there of the same value as the "gift".

    My momma always said ;) Don't loan money if you can't live without it. And that has been a good rule of thumb for me to live by. Also... if I have seen the person throwing their money around, before asking for the loan... I calmly respond that I don't have the money to spare... b/c it is the truth... I don't have money to spare to be thrown around carelessly!! :)

    My thoughts are, if you cannot afford to give the money, then don't loan it.

    Send a Comment

    Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

    (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):