Search Smart Spending:

When friends don't pay you back

Posted Oct 23 2008, 03:44 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

When you lend money to a friend and he doesn't pay you back, what do you do? Enlisting the aid of the Soprano crew is not an option, so do you sulk, get mad, get even, or pester the person until he cracks?

Fitz at Ready To Be Rich has some potential solutions, but first, let's examine whether you should lend money to friends at all.

Our approach is to give rather than lend if a friend needs help. That eliminates the possibility of hard feelings. We learned a sour lesson many years ago when we unwisely stretched our resources to lend a friend several hundred dollars, and later learned that when she came into some cash, she bought a new couch and didn't pay us back.

(In fact, not being repaid can really eat at you. Fitz writes: "Each month that the loan remains unpaid, you lose more hope of getting your money back. Consequently, feelings of anger and resentment toward your friend begin to consume you.")

Our partner blogger, Donna Freedman, is more comfortable with lending to friends, even though, she recently wrote, "some people to whom I've lent money in the past wound up repaying only part of it. Sometimes, life just happens that way."

If you make the loan

An article at MSN Money suggests you have a frank conversation with your friend about his or her financial situation before you decide to make a loan. You'll then have an idea of whether you'd be throwing good money after bad.

If you commit, Donna and Fitz say, you should lend no more than you can afford to lose. Get the terms in writing, another MSN Money article advises.

From there, Fitz offers suggestions on how to proceed. Among them:

    • Remind your friend about the loan several days before repayment is due. E-mail works well.

    • If that deadline is missed, set a second date no more than three weeks in the future. Again, remind the friend.

    • If that date is missed, have a talk to agree on an alternate payment arrangement.

    "Sincerely ask him the reason why he's having a hard time meeting the payment deadline," Fitz says. "Don't be emotional during this talk." Your options include accepting smaller payments over time or an item your friend owns that has a value equal to the amount you're owed. Or, you can have your friend do some kind of work for you. Or you can forgive the loan and try to forget.

    Comments

     

    why should we feel uncomfortable reminding the person that they owe you money! It was probably kind of difficult in the first place for that person to ask you for money. Just keep on keeping on till you get it and hope you learned a lesson.

    I commented on Fitz's original post, that I think an option would be to lend him/her money through a lending partner such as Prosper/lending club.  This would allow 2 things, it would allow him or her to get a better rate (people may outbid you!) and secondly prosper goes after him/her NOT YOU!  

    My Journey to Millions

    www.MyJourneytoMillions.com

    I have both given and lent to friends.  The difference is what the friend needs the money for.  It also depends on the friends ability to repay and the amount in question.  I think the amount should never be more than you can walk away from.  I had loaned a friend some money and he never got around to repaying it.  Recently he asked for a loan and I told him he didn't have good credit because he never paid back the last loan.  He said he thought he had repaid it but that just shows the priority he gave repaying the loan.  When my grandson borrows money I tell him repayment affects his credit rating.  In general I just don't remind friends of what they owe unless they ask for another loan.  I want to believe they would repay me if they could.  I know that's not necessarily true but it helps me think of them as friends.

    I never lend out more than I can afford. I will only lend money to good friends. People that have been good to me before. I look at it as a gift, and consider myself lucky if they pay it back. If you do not expect to get it back you will not think of the loan everytime you see your friend. I will tell tell you one thing. Don't ever ask me again.

    I believe that money and friendship should remain separate, to avoid losing both!  That being said I did help a friend out when his beloved cat was very very sick and he had no money for a vet.  I gave him a couple hundred dollars and his cat got better.  He never paid me back but to be honest, I rarely ever think about it.  I believe in karma and I hope one of these days, should I ever (gods forbid) be in a similar situation that I will have a generous person close by.  But just knowing that I possibly saved that cat's life and saved my friend from a ton of grief is "payment" enough.  

    According to the comedian Rita Rudner, if you get stiffed on a loan you should go to that friend's house and break something of approximately the same value.

    Thanks for mentioning my post here. I'm glad that you found it informative. :D

    I don't lend money I wouldn't give to somebody, that way my emotions are detached and our friendship is not based upon bill collecting.  This means that sometimes I just say sorry, I can't do it if it will affect me or my family due to the amount or timing.  I also tell them up front that I am not their bill collector and they will have to keep track of what is owed.  Once the money is in their hands I feel good I helped and forget about the rest.  I have always been repaid, but if I don't get it back sometime, it will be just fine.  

    Sometimes, lending money to a friend(?) is the best way to free yourself of a friend...

    I extended a balance of a Rhino "quad type vehicle"to a long time "friend".I had loaned this person over 15k total over the years we have known each other and always got paid back.He started taking fat burning pills and turned into an idiot .He spread rumors that I was pressuring to repay.The fact is I had bought a washer dryer at Home Depot on the no interest program and needed the balance when agreed or I was going to have to pay the outrageous interest due.He refused until after the fact and I ended up losing over 2k helping a friend.Never again will I lend money.Give ?Yes .Loan .Not on your life

    Send a Comment

    Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

    (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):