Search Smart Spending:

They tried eating on $25 a week

Posted Oct 06 2008, 06:59 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

The $25 Challenge is over in Illinois, and we're sure the participants are thrilled about that. They agreed to spend no more than $25 on food for a week -- that's about $3.50 a day -- and blog about what they learned during the experience.

It was a real eye-opener for most. When you have so little money for food, you realize that "there is food all around you, all the time, but you can't eat it," wrote Frank Finnegan, who was planning yet another dinner of ham and beans. He added, "Forget nutrition. When shopping, the only thing that matters is price."

He makes a number of good points. It is difficult -- but not impossible -- to buy fresh vegetables and fruit when you're working with a tiny food budget. And you'd better make sure you can stomach repetition in your diet. You quickly learn that when you're buying and cooking in bulk to stretch limited dollars, food becomes a means to get necessary calories rather than a delicious treat.

Unlike some others in the challenge, Chris Strupp didn't take advantage of free food when it was available. It's a choice he likely regrets. On Day Four he wrote, "I have lost a lot of concentration and patience due to the challenge. I have become extremely agitated for no decent reason."

The food budget for the challenge wasn't selected randomly. The $25 a week is about what the average food stamp recipient is expected to survive on in Illinois. Many who took the challenge wrote eloquently about the deprivation they felt.

A poster named Becky accepted the challenge on behalf of her family of four and found that $100 was doable, but just barely. In a post called "We are out of milk," she said, "As the week has progressed, I feel an overwhelming sense of failure and guilt for not providing for my family. I cannot help but to think of the families who face this every week."

The challenge was organized by the Illinois Food Bank Association, which notes at its Web site, "Illinois has experienced an unprecedented rise in the number of working families who are turning to food banks and pantries to make ends meet."

Comments

 

there's free food everywhere. if you had too many kids, and can't feed them... that's on you. churches give away free food... if you're struggling, go find god, he's got free food and community.

and, if that's not enough, there's ramen, pb&j, apples, and water. protein, carbs, sugars, and hydration. that's all you need, and how much is that per person...

1 loaf of bread= approx. $1.50

1 jar of peanut butter= bout 2.00

1 jar of some good cheap jelly= 1.50

15 or so packs of ramen= 2.00

1 bag of apples= 3.00

That's ten dollars. That can hold a cat down for a week, and they'd be bored with the taste, but it would work. stop bitching, the economy is about to get way worse... we're a bunch of whiny babies on the internet that somebody had to pay for...

Free food is in abundance. I can eat free every day... if you've got a family you can't feed, then that's on you not knowing your resources.

Churches give out free food. Free food, faith, community and sense of belonging... there you go. Not hungry or hopeless anymore.

You can live for ten dollars a week if you don't even want to be a so-called charity case. If you need food, go get it. It's vital to live.

a loaf of bread= 1.50

peanut butter= 2.00

some cheap jelly= 1.50

bag of apples= 3.00

10 things of ramen= 2.00

Boom. Ten dollars and you sho as hell aren't hungry. If you're that hungry, don't use the spice packet in the ramen and make some soup later...

We're on the internet... we can't be too righteous, somebody's paying for our time online ;]

HEY PEOPLE, you were never supposed to rely 100% on taxpayer funded food stamps for your survival. (Bunch of idiots!)

I couldn't go vegetarian.  If we weren't supposed to eat animals why are they made of meat?

How about getting a job to supplement your food budget.  

I know, I know, I'm working to feed my family AND yours, so kick back and turn Oprah while eating the dollar menu meals.

I started reading through the blogs of the participants and couldn't get over how whiny they sound. The only reason $25/person/week sounds awful is because these people apparently live off considerably more. They are representatives and higher positions making six figures, these people are used to the best of the best I'm sure. Many Americans live on $25 a week, without government assistance. There's a reason they are changing the program name to Supplemental Nutritional Assistance Program, because it's meant to be a supplemental program, not a primary source of food. I was a welfare child and I know what it's like and I can honestly say I think the program is flawed. My parents bought the best cuts of steak and shrimp and fed us Hamburger Helper, then by the end of the month we were completely out of food and eating whatever we could scrounge out of the cabinet. Also, they never held down a job. Most of the time only one of them would have a part time job if one at all. You know what they did with the money that they did earn? Drugs, yes, that's right drugs. They got assistance for food, utilities, and housing, and then bought drugs with anything they did earn. Everyone they were associated with did the exact same thing. I was surrounded by people who earned little money so they got assistance from everywhere imaginable and then did stupid things with their money. You think food stamps are helping the kids, but they aren't. Kids aren't the top of the priority list for these people. I agree with a previous poster that says the food stamp program should be more like the WIC program. That would definitely help curb the the number of people abusing the system. I wish there were a way to help the truly needy without having to by default help those who misuse the system. The lady that shared her story about how her husband of 10 years walked out on her and their kids and while working and getting an education received assistance is the perfect example of how this program worked properly. It helped her family through a rough spot and now she is back on her feet. That's how it's supposed to work. There are so many resources for those with small incomes, but they aren't used properly and that is sad. My brother makes $30,000 a year, by the time you factor in their food stamps ($500/month), their income tax rebate ($7,000/year), but exclude the other assistance they receive like utility help they are making like $43,000 a year. My husband is an engineer making $57,000 a year and we net $42,000 a year after taxes. Imagine that. I wonder if there is a reason my husband and I have to put ourselves through school for at least 4 years, graduate with debt with the hope that we'll make something of that education, and then see our incomes redistributed so that someone with bad financial planning (really bad, we've seen their "monthly budget") can make more than us?  

I started reading through the blogs of the participants and couldn't get over how whiny they sound. The only reason $25/person/week sounds awful is because these people apparently live off considerably more. They are representatives and higher positions making six figures, these people are used to the best of the best I'm sure. Many Americans live on $25 a week, without government assistance. There's a reason they are changing the program name to Supplemental Nutritional Assistance Program, because it's meant to be a supplemental program, not a primary source of food. I was a welfare child and I know what it's like and I can honestly say I think the program is flawed. My parents bought the best cuts of steak and shrimp and fed us Hamburger Helper, then by the end of the month we were completely out of food and eating whatever we could scrounge out of the cabinet. Also, they never held down a job. Most of the time only one of them would have a part time job if one at all. You know what they did with the money that they did earn? Drugs, yes, that's right drugs. They got assistance for food, utilities, and housing, and then bought drugs with anything they did earn. Everyone they were associated with did the exact same thing. I was surrounded by people who earned little money so they got assistance from everywhere imaginable and then did stupid things with their money. You think food stamps are helping the kids, but they aren't. Kids aren't the top of the priority list for these people. I agree with a previous poster that says the food stamp program should be more like the WIC program. That would definitely help curb the the number of people abusing the system. I wish there were a way to help the truly needy without having to by default help those who misuse the system. The lady that shared her story about how her husband of 10 years walked out on her and their kids and while working and getting an education received assistance is the perfect example of how this program worked properly. It helped her family through a rough spot and now she is back on her feet. That's how it's supposed to work. There are so many resources for those with small incomes, but they aren't used properly and that is sad. My brother makes $30,000 a year, by the time you factor in their food stamps ($500/month), their income tax rebate ($7,000/year), but exclude the other assistance they receive like utility help they are making like $43,000 a year. My husband is an engineer making $57,000 a year and we net $42,000 a year after taxes. Imagine that. I wonder if there is a reason my husband and I have to put ourselves through school for at least 4 years, graduate with debt with the hope that we'll make something of that education, and then see our incomes redistributed so that someone with bad financial planning (really bad, we've seen their "monthly budget") can make more than us?  

I'm so glad so many of you can sit on your high horse and preach to people how to eat on less. But I can bet you most of the people that have to live on $25/week are not reading this article. So your only preaching to the choir. It honestly depends on what part of the country you live in. Food is so expensive where I live I would have to shop at the Farmer's Market year round. And that is only open during the Summer. Most people that live on Food Stamps are poor and pissed off about it. They have to live like that it is not a choice. Yeah, go get a second job you say. Sometimes it is not that easy for some people, especially if they are uneducated. When you have to live on a certain amount of money for food and you see the people around you eating what and when they want you get pissed off. A person in that situation can turn to self-destructive behavior, which can mean not eating healthy or wanting to spend the time to cook. I believe with the hand out of Food Stamps or any program like this (especially in Urban areas) there needs to be a program to help people learn how to cook for themselves and their families properly. There needs to be a program on healthy living, in which, can hopefully lead to more self-esteem. And this can then lead to having the strength to get that second job to have more money to supplement the food stamps.

Oh, God forbid people actually have to go out and earn a living to pay for food! We can't have that...no, it's better for you to spend what little money you make on your cell phone, your cable bill, your HD TV payments, your cigarettes, and your booze.  We'll make all those damned rich people, the guys that actually took risks and put effort into their lives...they should be the ones to pay for your food! Oh, and if they don't want to do that, well, we'll just elect Obama because then he can use the force of government to FORCE them to pay for your food.  This sounds like the true American dream to me: "Why work hard when others will pay your way for you?"

Oh, God forbid people actually have to go out and earn a living to pay for food! We can't have that...no, it's better for you to spend what little money you make on your cell phone, your cable bill, your HD TV payments, your cigarettes, and your booze.  We'll make all those damned rich people, the guys that actually took risks and put effort into their lives...they should be the ones to pay for your food! Oh, and if they don't want to do that, well, we'll just elect Obama because then he can use the force of government to FORCE them to pay for your food.  This sounds like the true American dream to me: "Why work hard when others will pay your way for you?"

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):