Search Smart Spending:

You decide: What is a baby sitter worth?

Posted Sep 11 2008, 03:06 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

Now that the youngest of their four kids is 3 (and the oldest is 10), Nickel at Five Cent Nickel and his wife are rediscovering their social life. They're paying a teenager they know $10 an hour to baby-sit. 

He thinks that's a bit higher than the going rate where he lives, and he asked his readers for their thoughts. This post is particularly valuable because so many people chimed in.

Many of his readers agreed that he's paying a fair price, but apparently a lot depends on where you live.

When David of My Two Dollars lived in Los Angeles, his wife was paid $15 an hour for the first child, and $5 an hour for each additional kid. Where he now resides -- in Taos, N.M. -- the rate is $12 an hour. His friends in San Francisco pay $15 to $20 an hour.

Reader "saltinesgirl" says she pays $15 an hour for an adult baby sitter in Seattle. "This is someone that can drive, knows CPR and isn't on the phone/computer the entire time," she writes.

In Boston, Geoff writes, the rate for an adult baby sitter is $15 to $20 an hour. Outside Minneapolis, Danielle says, "my friends pay $6 an hour for teen baby sitters, and they pay the highest rate of anyone I know for their one child." Readers in Ohio, West Virginia and North Carolina also reported hourly rates of less than $10.

Some readers were clearly more entrepreneurial than others. Blaine Moore said that when he used to baby-sit more than a decade ago, he charged $15 to $18 an hour. Actually, he set a total price for the evening, but it worked out to that. He added that "most of the people didn't do the math to figure out how much they were paying ...."

Deepali at Paradigm Shifted thought some of those who left comments are cheap, and offered some observations about the job, "not to mention the sick kids, the messy kids, the not-quite-potty-trained kids, the crying kids, the bratty spoiled kids. And these really are your kids," she said. "... You have to pay a fair rate for dealing with all of this."

Baby-sitting isn't our thing, so we agree with what Mr. ToughMoneyLove had to say: "You couldn't afford to pay me enough to watch four kids under 10."

Comments

 

In the past five years i've made around $10 per hour in new york for any number of children. Most of the people rounded up to the nearest increment of $20 when paying me for the night. if the children are behaved and there are good snacks on hand, then it's worth it, but if i'm put through a lot of trouble, it definitely is not.

I remember almost fifteen years ago, in California, I went to my local park & rec department and took a babysitter certification course, learned infant CPR, etc., and went to work making....$2 an hour.  And I was so excited.  Talk about inflation!

livesimpleinvegas.blogspot.com

I'm in KY and about a year ago I made $10.00/hr watching 4 children , all under the age of $10.00. I thought that was a fair price. I had to cook dinner, bathe the kids, and get them to bed. Most of it was fun though, I enjoyed satisfying my maternal instincts without having to be a full time parent.

Here in Utah, we pay teens about $10 an hour to watch our one, very well behaved son. When we get a sitter. Often we either trade off sitting with my brother and his wife, who lives in town, or we go on "lunch dates" while our son is at school. However, I have heard that the $10 we pay for one is rather high. Most sitters charge between $2 and $2.50 per child per hour (we are in Utah, after all) in our neighborhood, I hear.

There is no way snotty-nosed teenagers should make above minimum wage for babysitting.  It shows how much they feel entitled these days.  Good thing I don't have kids - I'd get sick paying more than $5/hr. for some kid to babysit.

I would also not be afraid to keep up relationships with babysitters who you started employing in high school.  If your kids aren't brats then it should be no problem and may, eventually, be cheaper.  I sat for one family with 3 wonderful kids all through college.  I was perfectly happy to make less money taking the late night sitting jobs (parents home quite late, usually after 1 a.m. because of travel or cocktails) when I was home from school.  They weren't my primary source of income (I always had a day job) so the extra money was all gravy.  I was also old enough to be thrilled to get paid anything for sitting around watching TV while making sure no one broke it or the house didn't catch on fire.

Cynical-while the rate of babysitting wages may be disputed, these are your "children" you are talking about.  While a cheap babysitter might be around to make sure the kids don't burn down the house, they might be to busy watching TV or talking on the phone to watch them jump off the fence and break an arm.  

Miranda is quite right. I am also from utah, and am now 18, but since i was 16 any babysitting job that i did recieve never payed me more than 1.00 to 1.50 an hour. haha, they were lucky that i loved their kids. Or, maybe the people I babysat for were just cheep.

the worst thing to ask from your babysitter is to entertain your children for you while you are gone.  if i was i hired clown then my rate would be alot higher.  Watching over your children is just that, watching them.  I am not saying bedtime stories, games and crafts are not somthing to expect out of your babysitter, but i am pretty sure a parent wont spend that much attention to their kids in one night that seems to be asked from some parents.  

I remember when I used to baby sit. I think I only got 3-4 per hr. And I was grateful that I got that much. If it was not for the fact I need a higher paying job to pay my bills (since I am 27 and have a house payment and stuff)  I would still baby sit for that much. I think it would be another story if some of that money went to the kids (food, entertainment, ect.) but it doesn't. Kids, and teens need to be taught responsibility. Letting them baby sit for $5.00 or more per hr. is not responsible on there part, it is just plain greedy.

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):