Search Smart Spending:

6 reasons why I love cash

Posted Aug 18 2008, 03:29 AM by Donna Freedman
Rating:

Last month my colleague Karen Datko linked to a post from personal finance blogger "Broke Grad Student." The short essay, "6 reasons why I hate cash," seemed at least partly tongue in cheek, especially since a couple of days later he followed up with reasons to love money. Yet the underlying sentiment -- plastic rules, cash stinks -- seemed genuine.

Broke Grad Student wrote his piece after making an ATM run to buy food at his workplace cafe. "Having to make the trip to get the cash (annoyed) me," he wrote. Good grief -- hasn't this man ever thought about getting cash back with a purchase from the supermarket or drugstore? Or, for that matter, about packing his own lunch?

The blogger further groused that cash is "easy to lose." Just about everybody misplaces moola, he claimed, and afterward "you can't call an 800 number and have them cancel your $20 bills."

Yeah, and if you lose your credit or debit card and don't have any cash on you, good luck with that cab ride.

We've got coins that go jingle, jangle, jingle
Maybe he was kidding. Maybe not. But here are my six reasons why cash is cool:

1. It reminds you how much you’re allowed to spend. On a cash-only system you know that once your walking-around money is gone, it's time to go home. Plastic makes it easy to announce, "Next round's on me, and let's get some food too!" You might not do that if you had to take actual money out of your wallet to pay.

2. Cash reminds you how much you earn. Suppose you get paid $10 an hour. (Hi there, all you stunned college graduates!) You want to buy a shirt on sale for $20. Hold a double sawbuck in your hand: It represents two hours of stocking auto parts/answering phones/selling bagels. Is it worth two hours of your life just to get another garment? Maybe, if it's a really cute shirt. Probably not, though.

3. "Change sucks," the PF blogger wrote. Sometimes it does. But coins can also be a painless way of saving if you throw all you have into a jar every night. Someday, you might be able to buy a truck with your stash. Most of us, though, will just be happy to bank some extra dollars -- that is, if we can find a bank that will accept the coins.

More reasons to love that lucre
4. Tossing all your dollar bills into a jar is a faster way to set aside some dough. It's helped some Smart Spending message board readers to save upward of $500 so far this year. A Boston-area woman who saves all $5 bills ended up with more than $12,000 in three years.

5. Paper money "folds, wrinkles and tears," Broke Grad Student griped, making it hard to fit into a vending machine. So why not use those horrible coins instead? (Or skip vending machines.)  Furthermore, a wrinkly bill is still legal tender whereas a cracked credit card or one with a damaged magnetic strip spells trouble. You can still use it for online shopping, but a restaurant or store is likely to want an intact card.

6. Finally, the blogger noted that cash is "hard to split" -- when everybody pulls out a twenty at dinner, it takes time to "figure out what combination of change we need to get so everybody gets enough money back." How'd he get to be a grad student without being able to do simple mathematics? The fact is, using cash for dinner out is a great way to stay on budget because, once again, it involves the actual concept of money spent: With tax and tip, I just spent two hours' worth of salary on a burger, fries and beer. If you use plastic, it's easy just to sign and forget.

You wanna play, you gotta pay
Look, I've got nothing against plastic. Instead of going to an ATM for my own walking-around money, I get cash back with debit card purchases. Frankly, ATMs make me nervous; I wonder if I'm going to get robbed.

The rest of the time, I use a credit card in order to get frequent flier miles. In fact, I just cashed a bunch in last month for a really frugal trip to see family and friends. Rewards and cash-back programs can be great if you play your cards right, so to speak. Broke Grad Student gets money back each year. He also pays his bills in full each month.

Not everyone has that kind of self-control, which is why I'm concerned when people eschew cash entirely. Swiping a credit or debit card can give the delightful feeling of just having obtained what we want without actually having paid for it.

That is, until the monthly statements arrive and we realize just how much we actually did pay. Plus interest. Ka-ching!

Comments

 

Do you want to prevent I.D. Theft?  Use cash to pay tabs.  That way the barmaid, waiter, cabbie or anybody else who uses the job to obtain identities will be frustrated by the fact that on a dollar bill: 1) There is no card number. 2) There is no expiration date.  3) There is no security code.  4) There is no name of a card issuer.  5)  There is no first name, last name or middle initial of the payor.  Fantastic!

Cash is also great for bargain finds:  garage sales, thrift stores, sidewalk sales, church bazzars, etc.  Sometimes, no tax.  Big savings.

Those are great reasons to love cahs, but it still remains as my main and only reason I Do Not Carry Cash... Cash can get lost!!!!!!  You loose your purse or wallet or worst case senerio, you get robbed and poof, it's gone, no replacing, no nothing.  You use your debit/check card or credit card and remain disciplined in paying it off or tracking your purchases and instent security.  Now if that thug from around the corner takes your purse or you leave your wallet at a store and within hours you can cancel cards/accounts and guest what, you're not out for than the cost of a new purse or wallet verses loosing cold hard cash.  Even if that thug starts making charges, most of the time, you aren't out that money and can claim fraud.  So in the end Donna Freedman, would you like a metal for your response to the Reasons to hate cash, cause good for you and the few old fashion americans that don't have control of their finances or self control with the credit cards, but the rest of America is going to play it safe and not loosing their money other than b y their own decisions (bad or good).

My husband is more spend on anything than I am. I pay the bills and balance our checkbook every month. When we go out to eat, we always pay with cash. When we go shopping, we always use the joint debit card.  That said, we do have two credit cards that we use for going out of town to book a room, and buy gas on occasion. But we still carry cash to pay for everything else. I  have a jar that my husband puts his spare change in everynight. When it gets full I cash it in. The most we ever had was $115.00 but that went toward our vacation. We also have a Christmas club account that money is taken out of our checking and deposited every month so that we wont be strapped at Christmas. When you don't see it, you don't spend it. I have a budget that we stick to and we both have a ROTH  IRA that we contribute to.  We decided to not trade either vehicle and pay them off and the boat before thinking of getting into debt for five years again.  We are not perfect, rich or out of debt but we are trying to be better stewards of our money. I just Tank GOD we both have a good job that we love. Times are tuff.

My husband and I live on a mostly cash-only basis; I do have a debit card, but it's only for occasional online purchases and nothing else.  You don't overspend when you know exactly where you stand (or at least you shouldn't).

And I'd like to make a suggestion.  Some of our bills are paid online (insurance) and I buy a gift card from our bank and use it to pay.  I buy just enough to pay the bill and maybe have a dollar or two to get a Napster download.  Then if someone does hack the insurer's system, they get a card that's absolutely worthless.

My husband recently lost his job and went back to school...We decided to keep out money each week for gas, groceries, etc.....When the money is gone it is gone...

The funny thing is, is that holding the cash in our hands makes us less apt to spend then we were when we "used our card" for anything we wanted.  We have cut our grocery bill in half, quit going out to eat, and have found that it hasn't killed us, but has helped us to begin saving...

It's funny how one can live better with less money...We have done it, you should try.

I use my debit card which is tied to frequent flier miles. To me it's like writing a check.  The money has to be there.  But we teach our kids with cash only.  We also save change and then allow them to cash it in for bills.  A portion goes to savings and another portion they can spend.  For getting your children financially savvy there is nothing like cash.  <creditmomblog.com>

Glad to see others doing what I've been doing for years (and I thought I was a throwback to the dinosaur era!). This is the way our parents - if you are a boomer - got by during the lean years. We are at those lean years again, and it's getting leaner day by day. I have credit cards, but seldom use them and ALWAYS pay them off. Used to be I could get by with $100 cash each week for gas, food, and mini splurges. Now that gas is up around $4 I need $150 a week. But if you are a smart shopper you can stretch that cash and live reasonably well. Dollar stores (99 Cent Only is a Godsend) provide many grocery  items, and thrift stores have provided GAP and Burberry shirts for a buck or two apiece, not to mention five hundred dollar vacuum cleaner for $64 and $700 air purifiers for $20. I can stretch a penny so far you could use it for copper wire. Cash rules because everyone will accept it, and you know exactly what your budget is. It worked for Mom and Dad (thanks folks, I miss ya). It will work for us!

G

I think this is all hogwash. Self control is what you need.  Use your credit cards always , get flyer miles , insurance,  and build your credit scores. Oh just make sure you pay your cards off every month interest free and let your money( Cash) work that month in the bank.

i think this is good advice

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):