Search Smart Spending:

Here's the proof: It's worthwhile to comparison shop

Posted Aug 06 2008, 04:35 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

Which store offers the best deals: the grocery store, the discount store or the dollar store?

Our partner blogger Donna Freedman today explored a similar question, and advised readers that the best prices for foods and sundries often can be found at drugstores and other alternatives to the standard grocery store. And now we've found a Web site that emphasizes her point. The Crazy Dollar Shopper compares prices of various products at three types of stores.

Mark Bykoski at The Crazy Dollar Shopper selects several items a day and compares prices at his local grocery (Publix), discount store (Target) and dollar store (Dollar General).

For instance, one product was Arm & Hammer Fridge-N-Freezer baking soda, with special vents to allow air to circulate through the box. Target was cheapest that day at 74 cents. Publix was next at 89 cents, and Dollar General was third and last at $1 a box.

How about Jell-O chocolate instant pudding and pie filling? (The package says "Calci-YUM!" which we suppose suggests it's good for you.) This time Publix came in last with $1.09 for a 3.9-ounce box. Dollar General was second with 85 cents, and Target was once again the winner, at 77 cents a box.

Attention, students and other frugalists: Here's the comparison on six packages of Nissin Top Ramen noodles -- Publix, $1.09; Target, $1.02; and Dollar General, $1.

Of course, this fledgling site has limited scope (although, if readers chime in, it could broaden). But it makes a good point. If you want the best price for a product, it's best to comparison shop -- and expand the types of stores you pay attention to.

Comments

 

I'm sorry I'm all for saving money but this misses a good point (Donna even made this point). If I have to drive to 3 different stores to save $0.09 isn't it going to cost me more in time and gas? Yes if I had a lot of free time or they were all close by or on the way home from work it might make sense. However there are other economies to consider as well.

Actually it just means you need to do some homework.  If you consolodate trips you're not driving all over town.  In addition, most towns have a Grocery Store, Target and a Dollar Store within a mile of each other.

Plus this site gives you the answer ahead of time.  Check the webstie out...you'll see that Target has been the winner so far.  I guess it comes down to a choice.  Would you rather spend some time doing the homework to make your shopping trips more productive? Or pay a little more by just giong to one store?  You might find that you buy all of your meat at one store, your canned goods at another and paper products at another.  If you buy in bulk when items are on sale, you aren't driving all over town each week.

Another thing I hear a lot is "clipping coupons take so much time for just 25 cents".  Those 25 cents add up.  Why would you want to pass up a few bucks in savings? Seems silly to me.

I sort through the circulars and make lists of what I need with their various price points.  If one item is nine cents cheaper at one store, then obviously it pays to pick it up with the bulk of other purchases. But a lot of times it is worthwhile. This week for example, the grocery store has spend $25 on Kellogs cereal and get $5 back instantly, while Walgreens has spend $10  on Kellogs cereal get $5 toward your next shopping trip. It's pretty much a no brainer that a Walgreens stop is worthwhile. Esp. considering it's next door to another grocery store and thus a combined errand.

Our problem is that we are new "empty nesters" and are still wasting food because we buy to much or decide to go out to dinner which almost seems cheaper that buying groceries. Any tips for us?

I prefer product search because too often I search for products that I need. I am from UK and I like using this one: http://www.octoprice.co.uk

There is more choice than other as for example Kelkoo...

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):