Search Smart Spending:

Food savings: Give powdered milk another try

Posted Jul 25 2008, 10:30 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

We remember powdered milk from our college days, and we don't do it fondly. It was thin in consistency and unappealing in taste. We've never bought it again, despite the cost savings.

We're going to give this versatile product another try, thanks to Canadian blogger "Mr. Cheap" at Quest for Four Pillars and "The Great Powdered Milk Experiment." Besides, other bloggers put the cost of instant milk in the $2- to $3-a-gallon range.

Contrary to the mixing instructions, Mr. Cheap drank some without chilling it first: "gritty" and not good. "Undaunted, I threw it in the fridge overnight. In the morning I opened the door, crossed my fingers and poured myself a glass," he said.

"I took a swig and it tasted just like the milk I usually drink." He's a skim kinda guy.

Melissa at A Penny Closer also recommended chilling it overnight after you add the water. "This gives it time to fully develop and reach the best flavor," she said. "I didn't know this when I first started drinking it and the flavor did improve over time."

Mr. Cheap listed a number of benefits in addition to cost: It's easy to store in the pantry, and handy to cook with.

Plus, it has many uses. Myscha Theriault at our partner blog Wise Bread said you can use it to make your own evaporated milk and sweetened condensed milk. With powdered milk and vinegar, you can make cheese. For additional recipes and variations, check out this post at the Hillbilly Housewife.

Brian Dead at Randomly Firing Neurons also has advice on the subject. "Only use 2 cups per half-gallon, rather than the 2 2/3 cups recommended on the package. It tastes a lot better with less," he said.

Mr. Cheap wrote that you may need some help with the transition. "I'd definitely recommend grabbing a bag of powdered milk and seeing if you can switch over," he said. "If it's tough to stomach, try 'cutting' real milk with powdered milk until you get used to it."

Comments

 

Here in the heart of Texas dairy land, powdered milk, which has to be trucked in from up north, is much more expensive than the real thing, so we don't use it at all. Not to mention that 'real' milk comes from the cow, is heated to kill any bugs, and bottled, whereas powdered milk must be shipped to a processing plant and have all kinds of energy- use processing done to it, THEN shipped to the store. Stick to regular local milk, and leave the powdered stuff for the military.

Powdered milk works great for camping.  Mix it dry with pudding mix in a plastic bag and add water in the woods and you have a great tasting dessert.   do the same thing with cereal on the trail.  I don't have kids yet but that will work in the bottle too I imagine.

I used to use regular 2% or 1% milk on my cereal and in cooking - can't drink much of it alone since I'm a bit lactose intolerant. Always had a small box of powdered in my cupboard in case I ran out of milk and needed some in a hurry, and I didn't taste much difference.

Recently some friends urged me to give soymilk another try, claiming it doesn't taste like raw beans any more. I gave in and tried Silk in regular and chocolate flavors, and they were right. It's more expensive than regular milk but it's fine on cereal, AND my allergies are much better and I can breathe more freely without dairy products in my diet.

By the way - for the singles who can't use up their milk before it spoils - I used to freeze mine when gallons were on sale. I would keep out what I was able to use and freeze the rest in 2-cup containers, leaving a little head space. I thawed it out one container at a time in the fridge, shook it well before using, and I couldn't tell the difference between that and the fresh milk right out of the jug.

We have a few boxes of powdered milk here in our pantry that i have used to bake with, make hot cocoa mix (it's true it makes a great gift) and for emergencies.  My husband and i are now trying it out as part of the experiment to save some money. A gallon of milk here in MD runs around $4 a gallon.  I use it in cereal in the morning, and my husband drinks it in his hot tea and you can hardly tell the difference if you let it sit overnight.

When I had a youngster that loved milk I perpared 2 gallons of powdered milk then mixed it with 1 gallon of whole milk.  He never knew he was drinking the cheap stuff.

Powdered milk is icky and I will not drink it. Thus a box of powdered milk will get wasted in my household. This is money lost. Paying $3.50 for a gallon of real milk (I drink skim) is preferable to paying $3.00 for a product I will not use.

The only thing powdered milk is good for is cooking. Bread-baking recipes use powdered milk well.

Growing up my mother used to mix equal amounts of powdered milk with whole milk chilled.  All those years, my siblings and I had no idea we were drinking powdered milk.

When raising my children I use to mix skim milk with the powdered milk.

I agree with one message poster that the cost cut craze is waaaay out of control.  I think it is infortunate that we are sucking all the fumes in this gas hike recession.  I wiil say, however, that powdered milk isn't that bad.  I know someone who is on a special diet where the consumption of powdered milk is required (do not ask me to explain it!).  I tried some when this person was on it.  Not that bad.  Plus, I think this recession is giving us all time to grow acclimated, and to be appreciative of the great things and opportunities we have in life.  And I don't care if you don't agree with me.  I'm right, and you are not looking hard enough.

I grew up on this stuff. There are tricks to mixing it just right, but the only reason I didn't go back to this sooner is because it cost the same or more to have nonfat dry. Now it is cheaper, and my kids will have to get used to it.

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):