Search Smart Spending:

Guarding against the invasion of stuff

Posted Jun 30 2008, 07:50 AM by Karen Datko
Rating:

This post comes from J.D. Roth at partner blog Get Rich Slowly.

Since last August, I've been on a quest to reduce the clutter in my life. Back when I was a spendthrift, I bought a lot of stuff. Stuff comforted me. When I was buying things (even on credit), I felt wealthy.

Stuff doesn't make me feel wealthy anymore -- it makes me feel cramped. With time, stuff simply becomes clutter. Slowly but surely, I'm banishing excess belongings from my household. I still sometimes buy more than I ought to, but mostly I've been guarding the borders of my life against the invasion of stuff.

Here are some of the defenses I've been employing:

I ignore the proverbial Joneses. One of the most dangerous paths to clutter (and to overspending) is the urge to own the same things your friends do. Peer pressure can be powerful. I've come to realize that lifestyles are not a competition. What does it matter what others buy? I'm content with what I have -- more stuff is not going to make me happier. 

If I don't need it, I don't buy it. As I've purged my stuff over the past year, I've been shocked by how many things I bought but never used. I would see something in a store -- a voice recorder, for example -- and convince myself that I needed it. Or I would tell myself, "I might as well buy a jigsaw -- we'll need one in the new house." But I used the jigsaw only once in four years (on the day we moved in). I never used the voice recorder at all. These items are clutter, and were a waste of money. I've learned not to buy something unless I know I'll use it.

I try to value experiences instead of things. Make no mistake -- experiences still cost money. But a trip to England or the entrance fee to a marathon or a nice dinner with friends all share a common characteristic: They don't take up space in my home. I get value for my money, and there's no residual stuff.

I'm trying to practice the one-in, one-out rule. I'll admit upfront that I'm not good at this, but my wife is trying to teach me. I'm attempting to keep a steady state of stuff. If I have, for example, 12 pairs of socks, and then buy another, I must get rid of one pair. Practicing this rule prevents a buildup of stuff.

I focus on quality. It's been difficult for me to realize that sometimes it makes sense to pay more for the things I buy. My instinct is to buy whatever's cheapest. (And sometimes that is the best choice.) But I'm learning to base my purchase decisions on the value an item will give me. Often it makes more sense to have one excellent expensive item than to have several lousy cheap ones. The lousy items just become clutter.

I borrow and lend. Shakespeare might have advised against it, but I've found that with borrowing and lending things among friends, there's less we each need to own. I've loaned out a drill, a rototiller, some golf clubs. I've borrowed books, a video camera, a lamp. By sharing these items, we're each able to have less stuff in our lives.

I've reduced my exposure to advertising. Since I stopped watching television a few years ago, I buy much less stuff. But it's not just television. I used to enjoy reading the ads in magazines. Now I try to ignore them. The less attention I pay to advertising, the less I buy.

I don't want to pretend that I have stuff licked. I don't. I'm still especially susceptible to free and cheap things. In the past year, for example, I've dragged home:

    • A carload of scrap lumber I picked up for free. (Admittedly, this did get used as a border to our garden.)

    • Several pieces of free exercise equipment that have remained unused in our garage.

    • A box of free books -- books that I now realize I will never read.

    Just because something is free or cheap doesn't mean it's a bargain. If I don't need it, I shouldn't bring it home. Despite this weakness in my defenses, the tide of the battle has turned. I'm winning the war against stuff.

    There's nothing wrong with owning stuff that you use and value. But when you accumulate stuff that you never use, that's a problem. Guard your borders. In his excellent "The Joy of Simple Living," Jeff Davidson writes, "By keeping watch over what enters your personal kingdom, you end having to initiate possession-purging exercises." The best way to cope with stuff is to never let it into your house.

    Other articles of interest at Get Rich Slowly:

    Clutter's last stand: The cost of buying things you will not use

    Purge clutter with a de-accumulation bag

    The tyranny of stuff

    Comments

     

    I had to move twice in a one year.  The first time after living in the same apt for 11 years.  It allowed me to get rid of a ton of stuff, when I moved the second time (and hopefully the last), I was moving into a house with no basement and limited attic space, so it forced me to pare down even more.  Even after I moved, I continued to get rid of stuff, through Freecycle and donating to Goodwill.  Now I've adopted the "If I don't need it, don't buy it" mantra.  

    My father in law, who was a very frugal man who turned out to be a "millionaire next door" type !!  always said to my mother-in-law when she was wanting to buy something:   "Do you need it?   Will you use it?   Where will you put it?"   I always ask myself these three questions and usually it helps me decide NOT to purchase the item!!   I am downsizing to a smaller house for the second time ...and I am giving away, selling and tossing lots of things that I thought I could not live without in my past life!!   Wake up call!      Sandy

    "Often it makes more sense to have one excellent expensive item than to have several lousy cheap ones. The lousy items just become clutter."

    If I still needed a good reason as to why I'm gearing up to spend a few hundred dollars on a new hand bag, this is it. I definitely need to pare down my own clutter, but if I spend quite a bit on a bag that I absolutely LOVE, I won't have a ton of the cheaper ones floating around and constantly being replaced.

    Foxie@Dreaming of Ferraris

    I hate the self-righteousness of people who think experiences trump things. I'm an art collector, and I'll take a piece of art over dinner out any time, and it doesn't make me a shallow person.

    I feel sorry for people who value things over people or experience.  They tend to be very lonely.  Mainly because no one wants to be around them.

    Good advice, especially for someone like me.  I love flea markets and I'm a total pack rat.  Granted, I get a lot of stuff there that I use for crafts, and it has a place to live and does get used.  My biggest weakness is books, but since I can't stand to part with them, I try to get rid of other stuff for the one-in one-out rule.

    Another thing is to tell family members exactly what I want for birthday/Christmas.  Otherwise I end up with a box of kitchen crap or knicknacks I have no use for.

    Hi everyone. I have been reading some comments and I rwalize most of those commens look the same things I always tell my wife. She likes to spend money like no one else, she is really unique. She loves clothing, every single 2 weeks when she gets paid first of all she thinks about clothes, shoes, purses. All those items are a lot and there is no more room wherre to put them. Some of she put them in our dasughters closets. If I told you that she has a lot of stuff almost 100 on each category(dresses, shoes, purses..) I have just to believe that. She really has excessively a lot of clothes, shoes, and so on. Since we do not have same bank account every one pf us has their own bank account. Beacuse she does not want me to control her assets.

    Send a Comment

    Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

    (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):