Search Smart Spending:

Why should love have a price tag?

Posted Jun 27 2008, 11:49 AM by Donna Freedman
Rating:

A jewelry ad I've been hearing on the radio fills me with weary disgust. The announcer suggests that as we grow up, we lose the capacity to delight in simple joys like ice cream. That's why it's important to surprise a woman with jewelry, whether it's to commemorate a specific occasion like the birth of a child or "just a gift to say 'I love you.'"

From ice cream to ice. I suppose that's a logical progression in a society that stresses acquisition as the symbol of true success.

Listen, guys: If the woman in your life has given birth, she'd probably prefer help over gewgaws. Your getting up with the kid or making a major effort at cooking and cleaning would mean a lot more than plunking down a credit card at the jewelry counter.

And as for "just a gift to say 'I love you,'" I've got an idea: Why not say "I love you"?

It don't mean a thing if it ain't got that bling
The ad urged men to "give a gift that will fill her with the wonder and delight of a child." This paints females as infantile and males as clueless -- women for being easily distracted by bright shiny objects, and men for being too doltish to demonstrate affection in any way except through carats or platinum.

I'm disgusted by this simplistic portrayal of relationships. It reminds me of the "How mad is she?" sign I once saw outside a flower shop. Apparently, women can always be appeased with a gift, and men can go on doing whatever it is that made the women mad in the first place.

But this notion isn't a "get out of jail free" card for men. Ultimately it works against them because it doesn't hold women accountable for their actions. Anytime the love of your life gets upset, even for irrational reasons, it's up to you to buy her off rather than call her on her behavior. If she tees off on you because you don't text her five times a day or because you want to spend an evening with your buddies, maybe it's time to rethink the relationship.

Of course, it's easier just to send flowers or buy a necklace.

Spend, spend and spend some more
I'm weary of such stereotypes, and I wish we'd learn to think more clearly about the messages we're receiving.

Want to show her that you love her? Spend money.

Got everything you need? New things are better. Spend money.

Satisfied with your life? No, you're not. The way to be happy is to spend money.

Actions speak louder than cash
How about this instead: Spend time.

Spend time showing her that you love her.

Spend time to care for the things you own, so you won't have to replace them regularly.

Spend time being thankful -- and pay that gratitude forward by spending a little time helping others.

My advice is directed to women, too. Ladies, do you show your sweetheart how much he means to you? Do you care for your possessions in order to get the most value from them? Do you realize what you have and then share your time or money with those who don't have?

And to both sexes: If you love somebody, say so. Say it often, and say it like you mean it. Don't let a credit card slip do the talking.

Comments

 

Yes! This is completely true! I would much rather have my hubby give me a back rub or wash the dishes or clean the litter box than buy me jewelry. With him being in the military, I found that I was buying things for him to make up for the time we couldn't be together- you've inspired me to stop spending out of guilt- and just do something nice for him. Thanks, Donna!

Give me a break.  If I want a back rub, I will go to the spa.  Time is more important than money, blah, blah, blah...that is just what poor people say to make themselves feel better.  

it's always better to be a bit unavailable, married or not.  If your husband thinks that you are  just a little out of his reach, you get both his time and the jewerly

Hmmm....i don't disagree with caring for the things you have, gratitude, hardwork and the all important "I love you".  However, a husband I was seperated from recently passed away; this morning I left for work with a peice of jewelry on he had given me, my son commented immediately "did dad give you that?"  I remember that, with a little smile.  Respect, past love, a happy memory for my son, nothing wrong with that!  Two sides, Two sides to all stories.

No,thats not poor people say. It's what any respectable decent human being would say.

Julie: It's not that I'm against gifts per se. Anyone who knows me knows that I *love* to give gifts. What bothers me is when gifts become mandatory, or a substitute for caring.

Certain gifts I have been given do bring happy memories, and I will never part with those items. They have relatively little monetary value but to me they are priceless.

Thanks for reading Smart Spending.

Best regards,

Donna Freedman

I completely dread the winter because of the barrage of diamond ads on TV, radio and in your face billboards. "He went to Jarrod's!!!" All that tells me is you're a bimbo and your husband probably "went to Jarrod's" for his mistress as well.

I am married, and my husband knows I hate jewelry and flowers.  I would rather have something handcrafted or a potted plant, and would rather buy it myself. I don't need him to buy me stuff to make me happy; the people who do really need to rethink their relationship!

It depends on your values. If you were raised believing that material items equal happiness, you may equate gifts with caring, throughout your life, and put pressure on your mate to provide said gifts. Of course, people's attitudes can change, as they get older. Luckily, we're not cemented to our childhood beliefs, for good!

It all comes down to a personal belief system, so it isn't fair to preach what's right and wrong to people, in this regard. We don't all share the same belief systems, thank goodness. What a boring world we'd have!

Personally, I feel that while the occasional gift is nice and welcomed, a simple "I love you" from my significant other puts a smile on my face that lasts all day long.

This is sooo funny my friend and i was just discussing this topic this am. With as many different people on this earth, I'm sure personal value systems differ just as much. I've read all of the above blogs and concluded that whether or not you have money or not, true love should never have a price tag. Farbeit from me to hate on anyone's financial status...if you have the means, there's nothing wrong with accessing it to treat the one you love, but don't love that one by treats alone. capiche? - Loreelaw

Donna,

Really great post!

If DH ever showed up with jewelry box in hand, I would ask him "what have you done with my husband?"  He knows better than to spend money on jewelry for me (wearing my simple gold wedding band is enough jewelry for me thanks.  I would rather spend the money on something that means more to ME, like traveling).

So many couples get caught up in the "stuff" they give (or are "supposed") to give each other.

That's not to say we don't give gifts to each other, just that we don't need to prove our feelings for each other or our commitment to each other with "stuff".

Once many years ago, I was in a jewelry store and a newly engaged couple was there looking at rings for the woman. The saleslady asked how long the couple had been together. I can't remember the couple's response, but I DO remember the saleslady's response (not verbatim) as something along the lines of "well that [length of time] deserves a nice ring."

Personally (as a man) I believe that I'd rather spend the money on an experience rather than a piece of rock or metal that sits in a jewelry box unless the gift had meaning for something greater, like an egagement or a anniversary milestone.

A painting, poetry and other gifts that truly show how you love for your mate in between. You shouldn't have to sacrifice your livelihood (for both partners) dropping all kinds of money on material things to show you love someone. Just the thought of that idea of equating your love to an expensive gift makes me cringe.

And I'll say what else. Any woman that shallow to equate shiney expensive gifts with love deserves to be cheated on and left behind like the money grubbing whore she is. True love is better than that! I feel sorry for those who don't have it.

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):