Search Smart Spending:

Sneaking candy into the theater: Frugal or cheap?

Posted Jun 18 2008, 05:39 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

It's once again time to take a break from the heavier issues of the day, and "Frugal Dad" gave us the respite we were looking for. Ponder this one: Is sneaking your own candy into the movie theater frugal or cheap?

This is an academic exercise for us because we don't really care for movie theater candy. (We've got our eye on the popcorn with extra butter.) But it's a real-life decision for Frugal Dad, and you might be surprised at the decision he reached.

Frugal Dad originally floated this question in a forum at our partner blog Wise Bread. He described how he'd gone to the $1-a-box aisle at a discount store to stock up before going to see the film. His wife called him cheap.

"Normally, I would thank her for the compliment, but this time her comment had me thinking," Frugal Dad said.

Readers had varying opinions, both at Wise Bread and at Frugal Dad's site, and some are very entertaining. Of course, frugalists suggested he rent the DVD and watch the movie at home.

We tend to agree with Elliott of 21st Century Dad, who said, "It's a cheapskate move for sure. It's like bringing your own food to a restaurant."

Frugal Dad decided that it's not only cheap but possibly illegal to sneak your own candy inside. We are capitalists, after all, he said, and the theater owner has the right to make money from candy sales.

If you want to save money, don't eat the candy. If you can afford it, go ahead and live large. "In the grand scheme of things, a box or two of movie candy or a large tub of popcorn is really not going to make or break us," he said.

Comments

 

Who pays to go to the movies????  With the cost of movies these days, it is a frugal decision to rent and watch at home.  If you get used to it, you don't miss the movies at all.  You can sleep through a rented DVD several times and still watch it.

I remember doing just that in college. Except we could carry in supper in our bookbags. Recently I got a huge purse. I had a friend say I like your theatre purse. I didn't catch on. I've heard of totes, shoppers, hobo's and clutches but never a theatre purse, so I bit and ask what it was. She said a purse large enough to carry a bottle of water and a a box of candy!

The problem with snacks at the movies is that they're marked up astronomically and what if I don't want the junk they're selling? It's not like they offer much variety and if they want that much for popcorn shouldn't it be at least popped recently? In NY one chain gets their popcorn in large plastic bags and the "butter" is just yellow gunk.

So no, I will still take my snacks in and the cinema can take my money for the ticket or I can just put the movie on my Netflix list in which case the theatre gets NONE of my money.

Thanks for the link!  We do have a Netflix subscription, so these movie visits are few and far between.  It's usually for our semi-annual date night when we can line up a babysitter or a Grandma to watch the kids.  I've loosened up a bit and decided no more than we go we can afford to splurge a bit and just buy popcorn or a box of candy at the theater (but we still share).

I watch Netflix mostly, but when I do go to a movie (which is rare) I don't buy candy. $3 - $4  for a box of $1 candy is ridiculous, but I do get popcorn.  Gots to have movie popcorn.  

What's next? Having to spit your gum out before you enter in case they want to sell you some?

Half the fun of eating bootleg candy is trying not toget caught sneaking it in. Remember high school and sneaking a pint of rum in to add to your coke?

Maybe they should spend more of an effort cleaning the sticky floors and filthy seats than enforcing the 'no contraband' candy law.

My friends and I have been taking snacks into the movies forever.  The cost of adult and children's tickets are ridiculous.  I have no problem watching movies at home, but try telling a 5 year old to wait for something to come out on DVD when the commercial is on 100 times a day.  I would pay a fair price for candy and/or popcorn, but the prices aren't fair especially when the same size boxes are sold at the $.99 store or the grocery store for a 1/3 of what the theatre charges.  I usually buy candy and water outside and one tub of popcorn inside.....once though I wanted potato chips for the movie and I took them inside of my theatre bag. Sorry for those offended.

From what I understand, the ticket price that the theaters charge goes almost completely to the movie makers, so the theaters have to make their money by charging highwayman prices for snacks.

I admit to bringing most of my food in, not because I am cheap (I used to buy at the theater) but because the high movie prices now eat up my entire entertainment budget.

Perhaps if the theaters charged a reasonable price the whole question would be moot.

I say yes to bringing your own snacks.  With 5 kids going to the movies can put a dent in the pocket book and they all want something different so we stop by the store and everyone pick the candy they want.  We get drinks and popcorn at the movies if needed.  But I've also found if I take the kids right after lunch or dinner no candy is  need for the show.

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):