Search Smart Spending:

Deprived? Not us

Posted Jun 06 2008, 12:04 PM by Donna Freedman
Rating:

Emily, a personal-finance blogger at Remodeling This Life, was recently asked something all you frugalists have probably heard before: Don't you ever get tired of living this way? Don't you ever want to stop being deprived?

(Haven't heard these questions? Don't worry. You will.)

Yet Emily thinks her life is pretty good. "I am not deprived of anything that I want or need," she wrote in a blog essay. "Through prioritizing and giving meaning to each and every dollar we spend, we accumulate less, experience more and make room for beauty and passion all around us."

Being frugal requires her to "use restraint and patience, waiting to find the right deal at the right time." As a result she has become "more creative, always trying to think of a way I might be able to do the same thing for less and add uniqueness at the same time."

That doesn't sound like deprivation to me.

'Beauty in the little things'
Emily is a stay-at-home mom of a preschooler and a toddler. Two years ago, she and her husband moved to Florida and bought a 1960s cottage that they've been rehabbing themselves -- on a shoestring, of course. With one income and two kids plus remodeling costs, their simplicity was both voluntary and necessary.

But it's taught her a lot. The most important thing she's learned is "that a simple, small, frugal life is a fabulous life. … I have learned to live in the moment, enjoy the mundane and find beauty in the little things."

Sound familiar? It does to me, too. I'm still working on the "live in the moment" part, since I'm always thinking ahead to the next writing assignment, the next course reading, the next batch of homework, the next research paper. But I've spent years honing those other skills Emily noted: enjoying the mundane, and finding beauty in the little things.

The word "mundane" is often used as a synonym for "boring." I'd like to note that it also means "of or pertaining to the world." That's the real world, as opposed to the imaginary one that advertisers try to sell us. Enjoying the mundane, then, might mean raising kids, fixing up a house with your own hands, shopping carefully, modeling your values.

Seeing the smile of delight on your daughter's face when she plays on the swings. Watching your home take shape. Meeting your needs with available funds instead of going into debt. Living your life with purpose.

How is any of that boring?

Making the switch
Those of you who are new to frugality might, in fact, feel deprived. Maybe you were accustomed to dining out nightly, to shopping most weekends, to leasing a new car every year, to traveling wherever and whenever you pleased.

Strictly speaking, you are deprived -- something that was once a big part of your life is no longer there. Added to this is the shock of learning to live differently. It's more work to cook at home than to pay a restaurant to do it for you, and it takes a new mind-set to entertain yourself without a credit card.

You have to learn to create a spending plan and stick to it. You need to shop with your head and not your heart, such as buying a used auto rather than leasing shiny sports cars. You must learn to save for vacations, or forgo them entirely until you get your finances squared away.

Ask yourself this: How much of my life am I willing to spend paying off consumer debt?

Deciding your own values
Would we be as anxious to keep up with the Joneses if we found out that the Joneses are in debt up to their hairlines and about to declare bankruptcy? Some might. Others might try Emily's tack, which is to "use creative and thrifty ways to bring home the things we need."

"I like to think the values that we all learn from frugality and simplicity are very important ones," she writes. "We are teaching our kids restraint, saving, patience, character, recycling, reusing, creativity."

Living well doesn't have to cost a fortune. To me, a "rich" existence is a mundane one, because the world is full of small moments that add up to a life filled with beauty.

I'd rather eat bread and butter with a dear friend than a steak dinner by myself. The satisfaction of that full meal is merely corporeal. When I share simple food with a friend, my soul gets fed, too.

Comments

 

Great post -loved it!

When I was young, times were tight at times, but my family always practiced a frugal lifestyle.  I remember one year we couldn't go on a group vacation with several other families because of some tight times.  Instead of being upset, my mom pulled us together, said we were going to have a contest to see how much fun we could stir up, and we went out and picked berries for the first part of the summer, worked really hard, and earned some fairly decent money.  After the berry picking was over, mom found every free activity there was to do in the city, and we had a fun-packed summer, and then later with our berry earnings, we managed a really fun week at the beach.  I've been to some more expensive vacation destinations over the years since, but that summer sticks out as one of the best vacations ever.  As you say, the steak dinners are indeed merely corporeal, it's memories like mine that stay with a person a lifetime.

Well said! I have been living this lifestyle since November and it is such a relief.

I have to live this kind of life as the money just isn't there, but I do not enjoy it. I even have two jobs.

i have been living this life from the very beginning.  i enjoy it immensely.  i find it a good challenge. i'm a single mother, not by choice, and if i had been materialistic, i never would have been able to get my four kids through school, own a home, etc.  i do it all by myself with no help from their father.  i find that the more you have the more you want and everything is not necessarily good for you.  the simple things are definitely the best things in life.

Great post and I must say that I love the blog you are referring to -www.remodelingthislife.com - I read it everyday!  I'm glad the simple life is being discussed more!

I love this post!!! Sometimes it's hard to explain why you don't have cable or eat at home... but I love the freedom of looking at things and thinking "I don't need this". I might want it, but I can wait... I get so tired of having so much stuff!

My wife & I were married in 1964. We decided to have two children and she elected to be a stay at home mother so she quit a very promising career. We lived on my paycheck (to paycheck) without any get away vacations. Fun was being together and enjoying each others company. Splurging was popsicles on hot days and maybe a milk shake. We shopped mainly at Thrift Stores or Garage Sales and told our kids the clothes were from Robinson's. Our small TV was black & white without remote. When my oldest son was 12 his teacher asked the class for a show of hands who considered themselves to be in the upper class. My son was the only one who raised his hand.

Those days were simply priceless! I wish them for all of you.

I am so glad you wrote this article! I am one of those people you described--feeling a bit deprived in my new simple and frugal lifestyle. Whenever I am feeling that way, I spend a few minutes reading blogs like yours and get a revived sense that what I am doing is right. Thank you. Today I REALLY needed it!

I love these postings, too and I often get tips that I can use.  I live alone and have very few resources at the age of 72, but I'm trying to enjoy the life I have left.  I very, very seldom eat out, and I think back to the foolish decisions I made when I was working and know that it's my fault that I did not plan better for my retirement so I don't complain.  The people I use to call my friends are not around since I can't do the things they do anymore and my clothes are old and I guess they feel ashamed to be seen with me.  I just pray that after the election, whoever the President is, will remember the American people that are not elite and that are struggling everyday.  

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):