Search Smart Spending:

Why neighborhood mechanics rock

Posted May 23 2008, 11:42 AM by Donna Freedman
Rating:

Recently I used a coupon to get a $17.95 oil change and tire rotation at a local auto-repair chain. Along with the bill came -- surprise! -- a warning that more work was needed. They suggested a tune-up plus a flush of both the coolant and brake fluids because the former was "dirty" and the latter was "dark and dirty." Horrors.

This may have sounded like a scam -- come in for cheap work, pay for additional work -- but I believed them. It's been a long time since those chores were done. I'm not sure how long. According to an MSN Money article, I should have been keeping a service log instead of (usually) tossing receipts into a folder. Oops.

Clearly it was time for some Chevy coddling, especially since my brakes had begun to squeal. Immediately I thought "$500." That's the number that pops into my head whenever a mechanic pops the hood.

So long, economic-stimulus check -- once you get here, I thought. Originally I'd hoped to put that $600 into my Roth IRA. Well, at least it would pay for a chunk of the repair. Maybe.

I wasn't truly anxious, though, because I trust my car-care professional. Everyone should have a mechanic he can trust.

The family doctor, for cars
A guy who goes to the same church I do recommended this mechanic. His place of business reminds me of the auto shop in the town where I grew up: small and cluttered, with car parts on some of the chairs in the tiny waiting area, and not a single naked-lady calendar. It's just him and another employee, a courteous man who encouraged my halting attempts to converse with him in Spanish.

On Wednesday afternoon, the mechanic listened to my description of the problems and suggested I drop the Chevy off the next morning. That's the best part about having a neighborhood place: I can walk back home in three minutes.

A voice-mail message was waiting when I got out of my first class just before lunchtime. "It's going to be almost $500. Call me and let me know what you want me to do about the brakes."

My first reaction: $500? Ha! I was right.

My second reaction: Good grief. Almost $500 for brakes?

Deal with the squeal
As it turned out, he meant almost $500 for everything: coolant and brake fluid flushes, new front brake pads, the turning of two rotors, cleaning and adjusting the rear brakes, a little TLC for the hand brake, and new air and gas filters, spark plugs and wires. (The factory-installed plugs and wires were still in use.) With labor and tax, it came to $492.99.

Lest some of you write in to say how much less you paid for the same service, remember that this is a decent-sized city with higher overhead than your cousin's garage in Anytown, USA. Mechanic prices vary. So do car part prices.

The fact is, I trust the workmanship -- and $492.99 every so often beats the heck out of 48 monthly car payments. My hope is to drive this seven-year-old vehicle for at least another seven years, preferably longer. My sister kept a car for 16 years; my dad ran a Volkswagen hard for more than two decades, putting two new engines into the valiant little bug. According to an MSN Money article, "Almost any car can be nursed to 200,000 miles without endangering your life, and even a new engine is cheaper than all but the cheapest used cars."

That is, if you can find a mechanic you trust. Another MSN Money article has some search tips, and suggests that you look for a mechanic before you need one. Picture yourself standing in the highway median next to your moribund vehicle -- when the tow truck arrives, where will you tell the driver to take you?

That may seem like fairly obvious advice. Then again, you probably know somebody who never got around to choosing a doctor or dentist -- but who, on the day he woke up with a fever or a toothache, sure wished he had.

I still wish I could put the whole rebate check into the Roth. But at least I'm stimulating the local economy.

Comments

 

$500??? you got out cheap for all that work! Congratulations!  Wish I could trust some of the local guys around here.

I too did have for the longest time a mechanic I could trust. I would bring him what supplies were needed for what I wanted done, ie: oil, filters, coolant and so on and he charged me for the labor. If I needed more, we worked it out. He too just had himself and one other person and his little station was crowded with parts and his softball trophies and pics. of his kids.Alas the spell was broken by the cursed CVS drugstore chain that just had to have his property and paid him a cool $1 million even for it. He retired and has since passed on. He did have some wonderful times I am glad to say after he retired and got to enjoy his first granchild for a few years. He was a great mechanic and a very good man. Both are not easy to find these days it seems sometimes...

I completely agree with your philosophy on this one. I have a 1995 Geo Prizm that's been so baby-ed, it's ridiculous. It has over 140k miles on it and some unfortunate little dents on the driver's side but otherwise runs smooth as butter on the original engine and transmission. If my very trusted mechanic (with a garage that sounds suspiciously like yours, except mine is 1000 southeast of Seattle and has a few more employees) tells me that I need to put $500 in repairs on it, I don't even blink. That's nothing compared to what five or more years of car payments at $350+ a month would mean to my wallet.

That's funny, because I just read an article today in Reader's Digest stating to be wary of mechanics who tell you that you need a coolant flush, as this generally only needs to be done after about 100,000 miles or so.

Donna

I couldn't agree more.  I have been going to the same mechanic since I started driving 8 years ago.  My granparents used his father and now my parents and I use him.  I know that I can trust him and he won't rip me off.  He's the kind of man that when there was horrible rattling sound coming from the back of my car returned it to me 2 hours later and didn't charge me a things because he had only removed a heat shield.

I'm moving out of the area and that terrifies me because I'm so used to having a mechanic that I can trust and I've always taken it for granted that I'd be able to go to him.

I may pay a little more in parts, because he only uses the best, when I go to him, but I know I save money in the long run.

I went to one of those coupon-giving chain places for an oil change a while ago. Their recommendations? The coolant and brake fluid flush, as well as power steering fluid. I have a Saturn Ion, which has an all-electric power steering motor. No fluid!

I had the mechanic who signed off on it come out into the parking lot and show me the power steering fluid reservoir, and sheepishly he admitted that it didn't have one.  I have a great mechanic, but the one time I go to a chain.... yeesh.

Way to go Laura! I hate to admit it but I would have fallen for that one.

I did call my dealership on trying to get me to pay for a radiator. They said it had been in a wreck. Problem was they said that they had replaced it after a wreck and my car had not been damaged since their repair.

A dealership is no guarantee of quality.

I moved into a place with a local mechanic 1/2 block away. When my car wouldn't start one day, I walked down there - he drove his car up to my garage, jump started the car, replaced the battery, and gave me a good lecture on the merits of AAA - all for under $100. Too bad it was near the end of life of the car.

I think I wasted a lot of money at the chain gas stations over the years. Seemed like every repair cost a ton of money, and there was always the "we found something else" phone call. Yeah, sc cdf - I definitely would have fallen for that one too, in fact I probably DID at some point. But I'm going to the local guy from now on.

I TRUST MY MECHANIC TOO,NOT.TOLD ME I NEEDED MUFFLER BEARING AND I FEEL FOR IT,COST ME 123.00 BUCKS. WELL HE IS OUT OF BUSINESS NOW.

Ditto to sc cdf. A dealership is no guarantee of quality. I had a Ford dealership leave the oil cap off of my car after they made repairs to I believe the timing belt but I could be wrong. I picked the car up in the morning and by the time I got to work, 15 miles away but mostly highway there, my car was smoking and fizzling. When I called them about it, they wanted me to DRIVE my car back. Right. I made them come and get it on their dime with a tow truck and give me a rental car in the mean time. Next time my car broke, I took it to the dealership across town but under the same people, and they were great. No problems, fixed it for cheap, etc. You never can tell. I have a new car (fixing it would have been more than the car was worth) now so I'll stick with the dealer (now a Toyota) until the warranty runs out then I'll find someone better and cheaper to help me keep driving it until the wheels fall off. :)

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):