Search Smart Spending:

She's ticked and she's not buying it anymore

Posted May 16 2008, 06:33 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

If you want The Frugal Duchess' business, you'd better listen up. In an open letter to consumer-product companies, she says she's fed up with those that mislead, poison, overcharge or downright insult customers.

"Stop filling magazine pages, cyberspace and television airwaves with advertisements designed to make me feel needy, greedy and inadequate," she writes in a guest post at Frugal For Life. For instance: "What's wrong with fine lines around my eyes? I've laughed a lot. I've cried plenty."

She hates what she calls "flavor-of-the-month" clothing. "I hated those tiny bust-hugging, wallet-breaking jackets/sweaters from two or three seasons ago. OMG! Adult women looked as if we had purchased outfits in the children's department," says the Duchess (aka Sharon Harvey Rosenberg).

Stop advertising sales that aren't truly sales. "What's the value of 75% off when a garment has been marked up by 500 to 1,000%?" she asks.

She's no longer buying cosmetics and other personal-care products that contain potentially harmful ingredients. Also, if your product doesn't work, she won't be back. And you can make points with her by getting rid of all the wasteful, unnecessary packaging.

Start using real people in your ads. "I used to weigh about 90 pounds or less, but I've stopped starving myself and I'm not going to buy products from models who make me feel as if I should waste away, skip breakfast or throw up my lunch," she says.

Comments

 

I do not buy anything, what is advertised on TV. Why pay for the advertising?

I wholeheartedly agree with the frugal dutchess!  Voting with your dollars is one of the best ways to initiate change.  I wish more companies would think about more than their bottom line and try to understand the entire impact of their final products.

www.frugalityonedayatatime.blogspot.com

It is ok to be a fat as long as you are moving in the right direction (losing weight.) It is irresponsible to excuse the path to obesity because we don't like marketing, models, etc. And as far as the environment is concerned, studies have shown that our use of fossil fuels has increased several percent over the last 30 years due to the rampant obesity in this country with our cars having to lug around heavier people.

I have come to the sentiment years ago either accept me the way I am or just don't push your way of life on me if you aren't doing any better than I am considering the fact I work in the same place as you...Plus may do just as much as you but not the same job as you are but in very different ways.

Here in the real world if you are a mom and some are and some aren't some go to school and do many things to get educated so they can just half live well people need to start  living abundantly.

Start Tithing!

You should check out the ads in the Harley-Davidson catalogs. They use REAL RIDERS to model their apparel, first names and locations of models are given. Are they all pretty people? No way, but they are some of the truely sexiest ads I've ever seen. They mix up gender, age, ethnenticity and life experience in the models they chose. You find yourself thinking, I' really like to meet that guy/girl sometime, and if you ride, maybe you could! The bottom line is that real people are attracted to real people, and Harley has found that they can sell boatloads of apparel and accessories by using real people, warts and all, to model for them. I'ts no coincidence that they have won some of advertisings top awards along the way!!

Karen:

Thanks for the mention and the link. I'm enjoying this discussion about weight, beauty and marketing.

Best wishes,

Sharon

Being  a man I'm not suppose to read this material but was frustated working on a photo editing program and decided to read something. I'm what is nicely refered to a "Big Man"  5' 8" 275 lbs I wear a 1x shirt and 46-48 pants depending on amount of beer and salt I've consumed. My real complaint is models in "Big Mens" catalogs average 6'2" and 175 lbs.  Now how am I to judge how their clothes will look on me!

Well, if the companies' marketing didn't work, they wouldn't do it. My husband is in marketing, and I'm always learning the little things they do to reel you in. It's helped in some ways to know how I'm being manipulated, but choose not to fall into the trap. On the other hand, some marketed things look too good to pass up! As for the model's before and after pics for weight/wrinkles/whatever, can we say Photoshop? I would be shocked to find a single ad containing people in a magazine that hasn't been touched up. It's so easy, I can do it to my own photos, and those ads are done by professionals!

Hurrah for a good common-sense article! I have often wondered why anyone would buy products from companies whose ads are SO insulting to women.

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):