Search Smart Spending:

Use 'reverse credit' to stick to your budget

Posted May 12 2008, 08:18 AM by Karen Datko
Rating:

This post comes from J.D. Roth at partner blog Get Rich Slowly.

Ralph sent me an e-mail recently describing a clever budget trick he picked up from a friend:

My wife and I had dinner last night with a couple of young women we know. We talked a little about personal finance. One of the girls has an interesting idea on forced savings. She calls it "reverse credit."

"When I want to buy something expensive, I go to the store and buy a $20 gift card," she said. "I save these up. When I'm ready, I take all the cards and go get my new thing."

I think this forced savings plan is brilliant, and told her so.

I've actually been doing something similar.

Because I want to expand my wardrobe, I've been asking for gift cards for my birthday and Christmas. Over the past two years, I've accumulated $305 in reverse credit at Lands' End, and once I lose a little more weight, I plan to place a large order. By using reverse credit, I'll be able to adhere to a strict clothing budget.

You can use reverse credit to save for more than just large items. You might use it to budget for your morning coffee, for example. If you want to limit your spending at Starbucks, put a fixed amount -- $20 maybe -- on a card at the beginning of the month. When that card is drained, you know you've spent your coffee budget. At the start of next month, put another $20 on the card.

You may recognize reverse credit as another form of envelope budgeting. With the envelope system, you budget by physically placing cash in envelopes designated for specific purposes. You might have a clothing envelope, for example, or a coffee envelope. When you've spent all the money in any given envelope, you're done spending in that category until the next payday.

Reverse credit isn't for everyone. For one, gift cards have notable drawbacks. If these worry you, another way to do this is to open a separate checking account, deposit a specific amount each month, and then use the associated debit card as described above. If you already have control of your spending, this may seem excessive. But if you're trying to teach yourself to budget, this could be an effective way to do it.

Other articles of interest at Get Rich Slowly:

"The pros and cons of gift cards"

"Building your first budget"

"Budgeting for nonbudgeters"

Comments

 

I think the idea given at the end of the article (to open a checking account to move money in to save for a specific purchase) is a MUCH better idea then to buy up gift cards until you are ready for a big purchase.

Why would you give someone else your money to earn interest on when you can be earning that interest?  Why tie up your money in gift cards- what if something happens when you are $500 into a $1000 purcahse, and you need that $500 for something else? It's tied up and you can't use it for something else.  What if you change your mind? (Isn't that a big point of not rushing out and buying things right away? You might change your mind.) The money is already gone.

$20 on a starbucks card might be a good idea- its a small amount, and when its gone you are done for the month. (Really? $20 A MONTH on starbucks? Wow, I'm glad I don't drink coffee- thats $240 a year).  But letting Lands End hold onto over $300 for you- thats enough to be making headway into earning interest if placed in a savings/checking account.

Or you could just discipline yourself instead of these time-consuming tricks.  

This reminds me of the "lay-away" days......I myself buy $200.00 in gas cards at the beginning of the month and, if I have an extra, one of the kids gets a nice surprise....

I agree with Jessica, why buy $20 gift cards when you can put that $20 dollars into an interest earning account?  The day after my pay day, I have money automatically transferred from my checking to my 2 savings account (one is a high interest ING account).  Gift cards can expire, they can get lost or they can lose their value over time.  Though the Starbucks card is a good idea, but $20.00 is only 10 venti coffees, even less if you drink the frou frou drinks

I like to budget for certain items using a VISA Gift Card you can get from you local bank. Then set it aside for a specific purpose. But in case an emergency you can still use the money just about anywhere.

Seems like SmartyPig would be a good tool for people like this to use.

I use a similar approach.  When my family asks what I want for my birthday or Christmas, I told them I wanted a gift card for a specific store.  After two birthdays and two Christmases, I had enough gift cards to buy the flat panel T.V. I had my eyes on.  Now, I have them getting me gift cards for another store so that I can replace some small kitchen applicances.

It's a waste of funds to purchase a gift card.  It doesn't earn interest, it doesn't help build credit or a banking relationship. What if you decide you want something from a different store?

Open up a savings account (or a checking account at a bank that pays interest--one of our local banks is paying 2% interest on no-cost checking accounts with a minimum balance of $1000).  Once you reach a certain goal, then spend it.

I think I like the idea of opening up a savings or checking account, which I've already done. I got a link which I used to open up a savings account; for doing this I will receive $20. I linked a checking account to it and set up automatic transfers of $10 a month. It may be 2% interest yield, but it gives back more than a gift card certainly would.

Another method, if your bank or credit union offers this, is to get a reloadable Visa card. It's a one time thing, you can use the card at Starbucks, Land's End, etc. Just make sure there's no expiration date and you lose whatever value is on your card.

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):