Search Smart Spending:

Blogger: No victims in this housing bust

Posted Apr 09 2008, 03:55 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

Seb at Pinching Copper apparently said aloud what other people have been thinking when he wrote "There are no victims in the housing bust."

He's tired of all the media stories about "innocent" people who suddenly find out that they can no longer afford their homes.

"So who do you blame in all this?" Seb wrote. "The bank that approved the loan? The TV show that pumped homeownership? The Realtor who sold the house? In the end, the only person to blame is the one who signed the mortgage document.

"The media can portray these people as victims, but the sad truth is that the vast majority of people who are being foreclosed upon could never afford a home to begin with," Seb said.

We don't think Seb is talking about people who are losing their homes because of devastating health problems or job loss, but rather those who took the bait to buy more house than they should.

Most of the readers who left comments at his site agreed with him. Kevin at No Debt Plan wrote, "It really burns me up when it's 'oh, boo hoo, I bought three times more house than I could afford on a 40-year interest-only mortgage that I can't afford to pay now!'"

Reader TC said some buyers were misled by lenders, but that people need to understand what they're signing. He added, "I hate the whole 'bailout' mentality, but it really isn't in anyone's best interest to have whole neighborhoods sitting and literally rotting -- not the populous, the banks, or America as a whole."

"Mom" at Wide Open Wallet added: "That is what is irritating, watching people get rewarded for their stupidity." Jonathan at Master Your Card said taxpayers are the victims because they're paying for the bailouts.

A couple of bloggers noted that renters become victims when their landlords overextend themselves, and that children are victims when they lose their homes. Ginger at Girls Just Wanna Have Funds said finding a new place to live isn't easy. Landlords are tightening credit requirements for new renters, and homeless shelters are overflowing where she lives. "Yes, I know there are people who screwed themselves, but I still have compassion for them," she said.

Comments

 

I think the lenders are to blame.  The lenders made a vast mistake in underwriting these types of loans.  I do not blame the consumer.  If the lenders had made a fair deal from the start and made sure the loan was within the consumer's budget, none of this would have happened.  For instance, if someone has a lower than average credit score, will someone please stand up and tell me how they think that they are going to benefit (the lender or the consumer) by being charged a higher interest rate than "good credit?"  Your high interest mortgage companies are now reaping what they sowed.  They wanted greed, they got very little in the end,,,unless they really wanted a bunch of homes that they cannot use that have ended up being on the downside of the real estate market.  Good job lenders!    

Just because you qualify for a certain amount of mortgage, doesn't mean you should use the  top amount as your guide to buying a house! It was no surprise to these people how much their payments or potential payments were going to be.  It is also not surprise what their other bills are.  A calculator would have enabled then to determine at comfortable payment. Sure stuff like medical emergencies happens, but that's not the type of case we're talking about! I have a comfortable payment right now ,but dallied with the idea of buying a bigger/nicer home now that my income has gone up.  I "qualified" for an amount that would have resulted in a payment 3x my current payment.  Even though I "qualified" for the obscene amount, I immediately decided that I was not comfortable with the payment as it left me no room for a financial emergency!  JUST SAY NO PEOPLE AND STOP PAYING ATTENTION TO THE JONESES!

I don't currently own a home, but watching what is happening to people who made the wrong choice is awful.  Imagine explaining your situation to your kids.  Sad.  On the other hand, I feel that they should have done more research than they did (who knew that ARM ment 'adjustiable' rate morgage?  What a kicker!  People in these situations (except for their children) do NOT have my sympathy because they should have known better (that's why some of these people have degrees, right?).  I learned from my parents (all of their homes are bought and paid for) and my hubby and I are saving upi for a $50k down (almost there), 30 year Fixed morgage.  I wsh everyone else the best of luck, but they need to get their financial life in order (as it should have been before hand) and then retry.  It's a hard lesson.

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):