Search Smart Spending:

Blu-ray vs. HD DVD: What does it all mean?

Posted Feb 25 2008, 08:38 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

You've probably heard that Sony's Blu-ray has won the high-definition DVD format battle with Toshiba's HD DVD. Other than alphabet soup, what does that mean to the average consumer? Do we all have to run out and buy new DVD players and DVDs?

Not yet, says Patrick at Cash Money Life. Unless you're determined to be an early adopter of technology, the regular equipment and DVDs you have right now will work just fine while the price for Blu-ray technology inevitably drops.

That's great news for geeks and nongeeks alike.

Patrick observes that many people delayed buying high-definition DVD players and DVDs until the format battle was won. (We're old enough to remember the last great war, between Betamax and VHS.) Now, he says, consumers can be confident that Blu-ray won't become obsolete.

But hold off on buying until the price falls, he says. (We know he's right because we remember when the first calculators were very expensive.) "Continual improvements and cheaper technology will drive prices down, and eventually you will be able to purchase that new technology at a reasonable price -- or decide that you just don't need it after all," he writes.

Patrick adds that upgrading to high-def won't enhance your viewing pleasure unless you have a large-screen HDTV. And once you get a Blu-ray player, he says, your old-fashioned DVDs will work in them just fine. 

Comments

 

I have never been much of an early adopter for technology items. I prefer to wait until the price comes down and the bugs are worked out. Then, I decide if I really even want it after all. Thank you for highlighting my article. :)

I just started upgrading my huge VHS collection to regular DVD's!  :-O  No way I'm upgrading anytime soon.

I just enjoying the dvd formats and here comes a new one, i'll wait and see and for now the prices of this blu raything  is still high and i'll wait until it become reasonable.  

I'll wait till I can get a laptop with Blu-ray and HDMI in it. Then I can do everything on my 60" plasma.

Regarding waiting until bugs have been worked out of the new technology, I've already heard that some advances have been made or will be made with the Blu-Ray players.  I heard that it takes up to 60 seconds for a disc to load, but some brands have already started to make improvements to load times.  That has been the only negative I have heard about the HD DVD formats.

Are you kidding.  Are we forgetting the most basic laws of how supply and demand work.  Obviously there is more demand now that Blu-ray is the only option for high def DVD viewing.  There is no reason for them to do anything with price at least until after the next Christmas season.  This is not early adopting.  This technolgy was first shown in 2000 and on shelves in 2003.  People either will want it now or not and it won't matter if it's 500 or 450 or 400 or even 375, the saame people will buy it.  Now give it another year and then drop it so that the people who are just now upgrading to DVD (sounds like they are still out there) can adopt.  I don't know what that same person will do with his TV in Feb.

Is there anyone out there who has reliable information on when Blu-Ray Recordable DVD Players will be available to the U.S.A. market?

I am waiting to buy Blu Ray until I can record Hi Def programs from TV.

I would be very interested if anyone has this information.

Thanks

DVD's will become a thing of the past like VHS. Most people will buy on demand like the new Netflix box and Dish Network. Save your pennies. A lot of systems already have free movies to rent.

FYI blu-ray is only a real benefit if you ALSO have an HDTV.  If you have a standard definition TV, dont waste your money.

Get an HDTV FIRST, then consider moving up to BluRay.  You can also purchase DVD players that will up-convert your regular DVD's to HD.  Although, the picture won't be AS good as HDTV + BluRay.  You'll likely have blurring and other issues.  But it will be pretty good.

That said, we have a 52" HDTV, a playstation 3 that plays BluRay and WHOA NELLIE!  The first movies we watched were Pirates of the Caribbean 2 & 3.  And let me tell you it was like having Johnny Depp in my living room!!  You can't beat the picture quality.  Its AMAZING.

But realize that having HD will be more than just converting to BluRay.  It requires many upgrades.

I LOVE my Blu-Ray.  Got it on sale and with a rebate! Can't beat that.  Some of the movies are a little pricey.

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):