Search Smart Spending:

Man buys half-ton pickup with half-ton of spare change

Posted Dec 24 2007, 07:57 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

We can hear the gears grinding in the minds of personal-finance bloggers everywhere as they process the following information: Paul Brant, 70, of Frankfort, Ind., used about $25,000 in spare quarters and dollar coins he had accumulated over 13 years to help pay for a $26,670 2008 Dodge Ram half-ton pickup last week. Sheriff's deputies provided security as Brant drove the rolls of coins to the dealership. Brant, who works for Chrysler, decided to give his collection of spare pennies, nickels and dimes to his wife, Judy. 

No, dear bloggers, Brant did not deposit his spare change periodically in a high-yield online savings account. He kept it in piggy banks and old cans and jugs. We don't know how he is paying the balance owed on the truck, but we know he could have paid the entire amount and had lots left over if he had deposited or invested the money and let compound interest work for him. (You may even be speculating that Brant could be living comfortably -- in retirement -- if he had different personal-finance habits.)

That apparently isn't Brant's way. He bought himself a truck and his wife a car 13 years ago, again with accumulated spare change. His unusual savings plan was noted by readers of the Journal and Courier of Lafayette, Ind. "If anything, the longer he held this change with 0 interest, he was potentially losing money," a reader names "Zoso" commented.  Reader "lillyalex2003" said maybe Brant's method works best for him. "I think the point should be that this gentlemen knew he wanted a truck and saved for it, whatever the method, and was able to pay for a good portion of it."

Comments

 

Wow! Thats amazing!!!

His money would have been safe even if his house burnt down, since it was all coins.

My father in law did the same thing when we got married in 1989 he rolled out several  5 gallon water jugs and paid for the wedding that way. He also puts his change aside for his six grand children and on thier birthday days and Christmas gives them the change to put in their jugs.

What he did may not have been the best, but the point is that he DID save it (and good for him on saving $25k and not spending it!) and whatever method works for him should be applauded in this time of spend spend and spend some more.  Everyone has ways that are "better" to save....to each his own.....I have listened to others on savings and lost money, have listened to others and made money and had good and bad investment counselors.  It all comes down to saving period.  Did he lose potential money?  possibly.....but he also SAVED interest payments and was able to keep saving (How many of us take the time to roll coins or take them to the bank?  It actually is a smart method for him and I use that with my children and we go to the bank once a year with it...in accounts they can't touch until 18!).

Come on!  I saved my change in a 5 gallon jar which took me 10 years to fill.  Saved a whopping $2,500, including the $400 in silver dollars.  4745 days divided by $25,000 equales $5.26 a day.  Nobody accumulates this much change in a day.  

I agree about the earning interest and he might be lossing money. But, that is logical thinking and human is not logical/rational. If he has put money in the saving account, after a while, when you see balance in your account, lest say $10,000 you are tempted to go and buy something you dont need. That is how american financial system works. If you are strong enough, rational enough and decisive enough to keep money and dont touch until you have enough money to buy for what you are saving, then putting money in savings account is good for this kind of small savings. otherwise I agree with what Brant did.

Way to go Mr. Brant.  A penny saved is a penny earned!  Enjoy ur new truck.

I would like to know how long it took to load all those rolls of change to go to the dealership.

Now that you've told his name and where he lives he won't be able to keep his change at home anymore.

I think most people would love the extra money but really don't know where to start.  Maybe fear of being taken by their bank or whatever.  It is easier to save one way when that is what you know or how your parents taught you.    How does one get something started with the the compound interest?  Tell us how to go about it and maybe people might change their lives.

He would have to average 21 quarters a day for 13 years to save $25K.  I guess its possible to save that much from spare change, but I doubt it.  Thats a 100,000 quarters.  I think he has a form of compulsive hoarding and worked hard at getting that many coins.    

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):