Search Smart Spending:

Man buys half-ton pickup with half-ton of spare change

Posted Dec 24 2007, 07:57 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

We can hear the gears grinding in the minds of personal-finance bloggers everywhere as they process the following information: Paul Brant, 70, of Frankfort, Ind., used about $25,000 in spare quarters and dollar coins he had accumulated over 13 years to help pay for a $26,670 2008 Dodge Ram half-ton pickup last week. Sheriff's deputies provided security as Brant drove the rolls of coins to the dealership. Brant, who works for Chrysler, decided to give his collection of spare pennies, nickels and dimes to his wife, Judy. 

No, dear bloggers, Brant did not deposit his spare change periodically in a high-yield online savings account. He kept it in piggy banks and old cans and jugs. We don't know how he is paying the balance owed on the truck, but we know he could have paid the entire amount and had lots left over if he had deposited or invested the money and let compound interest work for him. (You may even be speculating that Brant could be living comfortably -- in retirement -- if he had different personal-finance habits.)

That apparently isn't Brant's way. He bought himself a truck and his wife a car 13 years ago, again with accumulated spare change. His unusual savings plan was noted by readers of the Journal and Courier of Lafayette, Ind. "If anything, the longer he held this change with 0 interest, he was potentially losing money," a reader names "Zoso" commented.  Reader "lillyalex2003" said maybe Brant's method works best for him. "I think the point should be that this gentlemen knew he wanted a truck and saved for it, whatever the method, and was able to pay for a good portion of it."

Comments

 

Everyone is so  worried about the money he could have earned in mutal funds or savings, well at least he saving considering the average American saves -2.2 percent of their income. I'm willing to bet that Mr.Brant is probably doing well, if he has the ability to save up 25k in change.

I say good job Brant! I have a brother-in-law who buys all sorts of things with spare change that he would not normally go out and buy for himself otherwise.

i'd like to see a picture of the stacks of coins.

The man had a plan & he stuck to it!  Bravo to him!  Most of us start a project & never finish it - quit within a few weeks.  But 13 years?!  And how many of us put that 'loose change' in the bank & spend it for other things, still having to take out a loan for that car?  Having that much money in one's home takes self-discipline, planning & great accounting skills!  I say God bless him & we all should learn from his example!

Das ist godt in se gebben sie bitter!

Funny, but foolish.  Stupid, self destructive, self defeating  behavior.  If he'd banked his change once a week and turned it into a CD every six months, he'd have a lot more money.  Man's a jerk, a professional loser.  So he got a truck.  He could have gotten the truck, AND HAD A NICE CHUNK OF MONEY LEFT OVER, OR BOUGHT THE TRUCK AFTER SIX YEARS INSTEAD OF THIRTEEN.  Actually, he's part of the reason the American economy isn't better than it is, he's too dumb to put money in bank so it could be lent to someone who would open  or expand a business.  Depositing the change weekly would have made money for him, for the bank, and helped a business person earn more money.  LOSER!  deRuiter

I think many years ago when the gov. decided to make people claim their interest made on savings accounts these old timers said no way are they taking back some of their own money. a lot of these people decided to salt their money at home where the gov. couldn't touch any of it.They just weren't educated to see the whole picture of what they were doing.The word investing to make more money just wasn't even thought about.

This is motivating especially in today's society when we normally buy first and pay later!  Good job.

That is exactly the way I do it. Best method for me. I've bought a 3 bedroom house full of furniture and a new boat that exact way. Works for me.

the insanity of the "compounding intrest" group is astounding. Rather than obsessing over small amounts of change (did any of the pecuniary savants calculate the time it takes to invest $10 twice a week?)  the man seems like he was busy working and being nice to his wife. And, did any of them EVER mention *gasp* stock market LOSS?

The guy is also doing a great job avoiding interest payments on a new vehicle, how many "investors" can say that.....

AND, if i may twist the blade, the venerable purchaser didn't empower as many crooked  CEOs on his purchasing journey....no wonder so many are gesticulating madly, they and their way of life were cut out of the loop....

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):