Search Smart Spending:

Man buys half-ton pickup with half-ton of spare change

Posted Dec 24 2007, 07:57 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

We can hear the gears grinding in the minds of personal-finance bloggers everywhere as they process the following information: Paul Brant, 70, of Frankfort, Ind., used about $25,000 in spare quarters and dollar coins he had accumulated over 13 years to help pay for a $26,670 2008 Dodge Ram half-ton pickup last week. Sheriff's deputies provided security as Brant drove the rolls of coins to the dealership. Brant, who works for Chrysler, decided to give his collection of spare pennies, nickels and dimes to his wife, Judy. 

No, dear bloggers, Brant did not deposit his spare change periodically in a high-yield online savings account. He kept it in piggy banks and old cans and jugs. We don't know how he is paying the balance owed on the truck, but we know he could have paid the entire amount and had lots left over if he had deposited or invested the money and let compound interest work for him. (You may even be speculating that Brant could be living comfortably -- in retirement -- if he had different personal-finance habits.)

That apparently isn't Brant's way. He bought himself a truck and his wife a car 13 years ago, again with accumulated spare change. His unusual savings plan was noted by readers of the Journal and Courier of Lafayette, Ind. "If anything, the longer he held this change with 0 interest, he was potentially losing money," a reader names "Zoso" commented.  Reader "lillyalex2003" said maybe Brant's method works best for him. "I think the point should be that this gentlemen knew he wanted a truck and saved for it, whatever the method, and was able to pay for a good portion of it."

Comments

 

why put it in an interest bearing account? Then the government will tax the interest and you don't get anything anyway!  The tiny weeny littel bit of interest isn't worth the hassle. Now if it were like credit  cards and the way they steal from people...

if your savings made interest like the money the credit cards steal from you....

If I can keep a few nickels out of the hands of the thieves that run our government I will.  I hate paying taxes so they can give it away for war mongering.  Be different if the governmnet helped people here but they send it overseas.  

WAY TO GO MR BRANT!!!

i agree with the reader mentioned in the article, lillyalex2003... granted the man did lose money in the long run in not putting it into a savings, but it's his way. maybe if he had put it in a savings account he would have seen how much money he had and spent it from time to time. the phrase "out of site out of mind" then eventually you count it and realize you have a lot saved. i think he should have at least gone to the bank and cashed it in for bills at least rather than used the change itself to buy the truck.

see spare change does add up,a penny saved is a penny earned.....

Sure, he could have better invested same and exponentially expanded his nest-egg as he added to it over the years, but that's missing the point.  This guy basically paid cash for a new vehicle, which is far smarter them what perhaps 97.5 of other car buyers do.  I do however need to advise Mr. Brant that he would have been wiser to have bougjht a newly used 1/2 ton Dodge with very low miles, that way perhaps he'd of gotten it for $3-4 grand less and he could have used the savings to fill the tank fot a few years (orless if gas keeps climbing at current rates).

-Mark Baker

Bottom line, he paid cash for the vehicle and did not get taken advantage of with a high interest car loan.

Great job. I have 3 gallons of change will take to the bank when I get my 5gallon bucket full

I think the point should be that this is the thinking of a sparcely toothed  moron from gobersville, and very typical of most colts fans.I f you really wanted impress on him the importants of compound interest,you should have told him he could have had it paid for w/ a gun rack and  the 38 inch. wheels.

What you have to remember is that this gentleman is old enough to remember the crash of '29, like my parents, or at least heard a great deal about it, like I have.  Their feeling is that banks are not safe and investing is gambling!  I'm afraid that I'm with Mr. Brant.  Like so many folks in this day and age, they want what they want and they want it yesterday and seem to have no notion of earning things by hard work - whether it is as a programmer or manual labor!  Did I mention that I'm 60?  I'm happy to have the roof over my head paid off, my car, paid off and a job where I am able to earn enough to pay off my, in comparison to others, a rather small loan - which - if I have planned well enough will be paid off on the day I retire from my place of employment.  Oh yes - I'm single and have earned everything myself!

Goes to Show Eveyone that No Matter how little you save you can still get there

who can trust the banks!? save at home

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):