Search Smart Spending:

Man buys half-ton pickup with half-ton of spare change

Posted Dec 24 2007, 07:57 PM by Karen Datko
Rating:

We can hear the gears grinding in the minds of personal-finance bloggers everywhere as they process the following information: Paul Brant, 70, of Frankfort, Ind., used about $25,000 in spare quarters and dollar coins he had accumulated over 13 years to help pay for a $26,670 2008 Dodge Ram half-ton pickup last week. Sheriff's deputies provided security as Brant drove the rolls of coins to the dealership. Brant, who works for Chrysler, decided to give his collection of spare pennies, nickels and dimes to his wife, Judy. 

No, dear bloggers, Brant did not deposit his spare change periodically in a high-yield online savings account. He kept it in piggy banks and old cans and jugs. We don't know how he is paying the balance owed on the truck, but we know he could have paid the entire amount and had lots left over if he had deposited or invested the money and let compound interest work for him. (You may even be speculating that Brant could be living comfortably -- in retirement -- if he had different personal-finance habits.)

That apparently isn't Brant's way. He bought himself a truck and his wife a car 13 years ago, again with accumulated spare change. His unusual savings plan was noted by readers of the Journal and Courier of Lafayette, Ind. "If anything, the longer he held this change with 0 interest, he was potentially losing money," a reader names "Zoso" commented.  Reader "lillyalex2003" said maybe Brant's method works best for him. "I think the point should be that this gentlemen knew he wanted a truck and saved for it, whatever the method, and was able to pay for a good portion of it."

Comments

 

Well, I don't agree with his method I am, however; very happy that he had a goal and made it work for him

That equals to 37.00 a day for 2 years. Most people cannot throw 37.00 a day in a jar everyday for 2 years.!!!!!!!

IN 13 YEARS OF SAVING  THAT WORKS OUT TO BE ABOUT $2000 A YEAR IN SAVING QUARTERS  AND DOLLAR PIECES AND HE GAVE THE NICKELS, DIMES AND PENNIES TO HIS WIFE. NICE GIFT!  OF COURSE IN AN INTEREST BEARING ACCOUNT IT WOULD HAVE BEEN TWO OR THREE TIMES THAT AMOUNT DEPENDING ON WHERE HE PUT IT.  IF HE WAS SUCH A GOOD SAVER  HE PROBABLY HAD HIS HOUSE PAYED FOR AND A NICE 401K TO GO WITH IT ANYWAY. IT SOUNDS LIKE HE JUST TOOK THROWING CHANGE INTO A COKE BOTTLE TO ANOTHER LEVEL.

The guy  is a  NUT  case  

Maybe this is how he learned to save or just wanted saving to be fun and was being creative.  Banks are so boring and interest nowadays isn't worth the drive!  Possibly it would of cost him more in depreciation and expense to use his previously purchased vehicle to carry the change to the bank?

Perhaps Mr. Brant was "hiding" his money from himself. How many of us would have SPENT the money on something else before it accumulated to even 1/2 what he spent on the truck, just because we knew how much we had saved?

I had a cousin who had saved nearly $40,000 in small coins and change...I figured that had he invested that over time (about 25 years), he would have had nearly $2.7 million dollars (enough to retire on). He did not do the right thing though.

He could have also "invested" his spare change in several of thousands of high yield investments and then lost some, most, or all of it.  Paul may be a lot smarter than you think.

Good for him I have heard of many of the older generation who do not trust banks or any other institution like that so he knew what he had and when had enough he did what he wantd with it. Kudos to the fine man.

Of course he could've made more if he invested the money in some sort of interest bearing investment.  Nonetheless, my hats off to this guy.  At least he had the money to buy the truck before he did so.  If others had that much money, they'd use it to pay for half a Lexus or a Porsche, refinance their house to pay for the other half of the car and an additional plasma screent TV.  Then, two years from now, cry about hardship in managing their payments- after the Lexus and TV lost its novelty and they are struggling to keep a roof over their heads.

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):