Search Smart Spending:

Children’s gifts: Don’t spend a lot on what they don’t want

Posted Dec 07 2007, 09:40 AM by Karen Datko
Rating:

This post comes from Trent Hamm at partner blog The Simple Dollar.

Over my son’s life, he’s received numerous gifts from me and my wife, his grandparents, and his aunts and uncles. We have many toys he doesn't regularly play with, so we’ve given a few away and have some in storage so we can rotate them monthly, giving him the enjoyment of having “new” toys to play with.

His second birthday is approaching, and we’ve been thinking about what sorts of gifts are appropriate for him. What would he enjoy at this age? The surprising answer is that almost everything he indicates an interest in is very inexpensive.

This would likely be his gift list if he were writing his own:

    • Hot Wheels cars. These are his favorite at the moment. It’s easy to get a 10-pack at a department store for $6 or $7, and it will likely be one of his favorite gifts.

    • Paper to draw on. He loves busting out the washable markers and drawing on any paper we allow him to, and he sometimes draws on himself. I am looking for a blank roll of newsprint. A new set of washable markers also may be part of the present.

    • Used children’s books. He loves books. He sits on the floor and goes through them himself and insists that we read to him a lot. Why not get him five or 10 used children’s books (many of which look barely used) instead of one new one, especially considering that he quickly adds wear and tear to them?

    • A large rubber ball. Whenever we see one in a department store, he points, says “ball,” and stares at it in an almost trancelike state.

    • Apple juice. Every time I’ve asked him what he wants for his birthday, "apple juice" has been his response. Guess what beverage will be served at his birthday party.

    My philosophy is this: Get him things that he actually wants. Later on, when his tastes become more expensive -- "I want an Xbox 720" -- gifts might change. But for now, if the child’s tastes are frugal, support that frugality.

    Both sets of grandparents are giving him larger gifts that are sensible, and that’s fine. But for Christmas I’m going to encourage everyone to get him simple things -- and if they insist on giving him more, I'll suggest they contribute to his college fund. That way, he’ll enjoy the gifts he receives, and their contributions will have about 17 years to grow and really help him in college. Even better, it will prevent him -- somewhat -- from seeing Christmas as a giant materialistic gift-grabbing occasion.

    What’s the take-home message here? If you have the opportunity to give a gift to a child,  make it a frugal one that the child actually will enjoy. If you feel obligated to spend more, put some money along with it and earmark it for a college fund. That way, the child will have something to enjoy now and something that will be a benefit later on.

    Other articles of interest at The Simple Dollar:

    The art of the thank-you note

    Why Johnny can read

    10 books that changed my life

    Comments

     

    I watched my grandaughter open about 30 presents last christmas all brought by Santa. She got tired of opening them. She has been given so much that when you meet her the first questions she asks is do you have a present for me. Also she needs to know the meaning of the word NO. She will scream if she is denied anything.It is not fun to have everything.

    Kz3rgB  <a href="liobrkbybebx.com/.../a>, [url=http://xhmeyeugbxcc.com/]xhmeyeugbxcc[/url], [link=http://ptrqrcsfaawo.com/]ptrqrcsfaawo[/link], http://maqjntjkvdil.com/

    The Newspaper in our town has newsprint for sale on rolls for a small fee. At 2 yrs.  My kids loved a 9 piece plastic train set that went in a small case that they could carry around.  My guys liked larger toy  trucks, & bulldozers  that they could play with in the dirt.  Also they liked a set of containers that they could pour water in the swimming pool or bath. We had some soap that you could draw with in the bathtub.  They liked that.  My husband got a bunch of cardboard boxes and we built a fort with different rooms.  They loved that--just boxes.  They loved a rubber swimming pool in the back yard.  We paired it with a sturdy plastic yardsale slide.  They loved to slide down the slide and splash in the little pool.  Also they liked to roll their rubber balls down the slide. The expensive toy they loved was the wooden train set with magnets.     You can find wonderful toys, clothes and books at yardsales for a young child. Kids like crafts too-gluing things and easy stiching with yard and a big plastic needle. You can ask the seller what their children actually played with.  Those duplos are good.  Other kids are fun to play with.  Keep them away from video games/TV/computers as long as possible.  Little kids need hands on.  Avoid computer, TV, video games as long as possible.  When you are forced, monitor everything from the beginning and set time limits.   Kids like to play with their parents and other kids.  Get on the floor & get out some Fisher Price barn & Little People.  They learn language when you play with them and talk which is helpful in reading and school.

    While your idea about used books isn't a bad one, I ended up getting a boat load of them for $10 a a garage sale - obviously a great deal.  But...they drove me crazy because they would all be pulled out of the bookshelf and all over the floor, and not being the worlds greatest housekeeper it was just always a mess.  So we have donated some books and have since gotten a library membership.  The library isn't what it used to be!  You can also get some music and videos now.  The kids enjoy the trip to the library, and my husband and I get a book to read as well.  It's soooo cheap to join, and you have a constant rotation of thousands of books to choose from.

    You guys are very frugal and sensible, but you are forgetting that grandparents are so madly in love with their grandkids that they just can't help it! It might come as a surprise to you, but your parents probably complained that their parents bought you a lot of useless junk! Can't you let them spoil the grandkids? That's what grandparents are for- and you had better hope you live long enough- and have enough money- to spoil your own grandkids one day.

    woah i totally agree

    My grandchildren's ages are 5 years old and 16 months old, respectively.  At this time I'm considering buying some Disneyworld stocks for them to have in the future.

    How do I go about doing this?  Where do I go?  Can someone recommend a way to do this to a novice.

    My grandchildren's ages are 5 years old and 16 months old, respectively.  At this time I'm considering buying some Disneyworld stocks for them to have in the future.

    How do I go about doing this?  Where do I go?  Can someone recommend a way to do this to a novice.

    For Teenagers who ask for expensive items you can't afford: Chances are they can't either but if you offer to pay half if they pay the other half, you'll find they will begin to ask for more reasonable items.

    Before Christmas or birthdays my kids and my daycare kids were allowed to start a wish list as long as they wanted....some were 6 or 8 feet long! We would take them to the local toy store and write down everything they could possibly wish for. Then come home and write it out to hang on the wall. They could add to it daily. Once there friends and family could "see" what they wanted. We mothers could direct people to the acceptable items. Once Christmas or the birthday was over each kid could mark off all that they did receive. This taught them to be careful of what you wish for and that you can't have everything you want either. The wish list got considerably shorter once they had learned the lesson.

    As for parties, my "kids" are 21 and 16 now but the most memorable parties they had, that are also remembered by friends, included toilet paper, chocolate milk, and flavoured ice cream! The toilet paper was to play Mummy Wrap in pairs and then when that was exhausted they had "snowball" fights and buried each other in it. It was always the last hour or so of any party and yes every parent who saw it for the first time thought I was crazy.

    I never served pop but instead made a jug of chocolate milk, always a hit with the kids. I used frozen/fresh fruits to make vanilla ice cream into a variety of flavours and colours which was not only delicious but healthy too. My 21 year old's friends still say they had the most fun at our parties.

    As for gifts, my older one decided he didn't really need a party after he turned 10 but would instead organize group of friends to go skating or swimming or bowling and not mention it was anywhere near his birthday.

    My younger one loved the parties, still does but she has asked her friends to instead bring a gift for her to add to her collection for the kids she sponsors at Christmas. She shops all year long with her own money to buy gifts for the kids she sponsors so it really helps her collection to grow with her fall birthday donations.

    Both my kids have learned the value of the dollar by first "working" at home for their allowance. One month they worked piece work.....no work no pay! Another month they worked hourly...again no work no pay. Yet another month they worked Salary with assigned tasks they alone were responsible for. Then they started a large paper route that they shared for 8 years, and the younger one still does 11 years after starting. They always got paid for the actual amount of work they did. They have both purchased the big ticket items they've wanted over the years and take good care of what they have.

    Send a Comment

    Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

    (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):