Search Smart Spending:

Kill 'Zill

Posted Oct 08 2007, 05:37 PM by Donna Freedman
Rating:

That’s Zill as in “Bridezilla.” My daughter, Abby, who’s getting married in May, was raging over a newspaper article about the costs a bridesmaid can reasonably expect.

The thing is, some brides are no longer reasonable -- and they expect way too much.

Veteran bridesmaid (eight times!) Arica Colley, profiled in the article, said a recent wedding cost her $1,300. Yep, thirteen hundred dollars.

But here’s the scary part: “Experts” say that bridesmaids should expect to pony up $1,000 to $1,400 for the privilege of wearing the same dress as a bunch of other women.

It isn’t just the dress (average cost: $140), according to a Brides.com editor quoted in the story. Bridesmaids face multiple showers, brunches, spa visits, bachelorette parties and, if they live elsewhere, travel costs.

Oh, and they’re apparently supposed to work on invitations, favors, decorations and anything else the bride-to-be asks. They’re supposed to plan -- and pay for -- all the events noted above.

And they’re supposed to smile while they’re doing it. But that $1,300 experience was so tense that Colley and the bride didn’t speak for half a year.

But it’s my day!

“This is insane,” Abby said. “I can’t imagine asking any of my friends to do this.”

For example:

  • Colley was required to buy new shoes and jewelry. (Abby’s bridesmaids can use whatever they already own. And since they’ll wear the same color but not style of dress, they can shop post-Christmas sales.)
  • Colley had to attend 10 bridal showers for that one bride. (Abby will have one shower. She does not expect gifts from anyone.)
  • Colley lives in Texas. The bachelorette party was in Manhattan. (“An entire weekend of activities paid for the bridesmaids? If you want to go to New York, then pay for it yourself,” my daughter said.”)

Then again, Abby can’t afford to be a Bridezilla. She’s on an extremely limited budget that makes her extremely pragmatic. I’m helping where I can and Abby’s great-grandmother, bless her heart, just sent a contribution.

But this wedding will rely heavily on yard sales, Craigslist, dollar stores, MyPoints, and her abilities to prioritize and compromise. She’s posting tips for other budget-conscious brides on a blog called “Near Mrs.”

Bride on a budget

It’s not that she hasn’t had her share of wedding dreams. She bought a couple of bridal magazines, and dragged me to a trade fair called the “Wedding Expo.” But she’s appalled by the wretched excess noted in the newspaper article.

“I don’t expect my bridesmaids to be wedding planners or to break their budgets just so I can have the perfect day,” Abby said. “Why would they? And why would I ask them to?”

(That’s my girl!)

Seriously: I’m greatly disturbed by the way weddings have turned into floor shows. Aren’t people just as married if they don’t spend the $26,000 that the average wedding allegedly costs?

Ladies, please remember: It’s only one day -- the first day of your marriage. Marriage. That's the part after the wedding. Love, commitment, a lifetime together, all that.

Without a little perspective, Bridezillas and ordinary brides alike may may face “post-wedding blues.” This can happen once the storybook stuff is finished and it’s time for the very real, very hard work of learning to live with this person whose initials are mingled with yours on guest towels no one will ever use.

Or maybe the depression coincides with the arrival of the bills for all the wedding costs -- that is, the ones the bridesmaids didn’t pay.

Comments

 

High time this was stated...a beautiful act of committment has become so commercialized that the meaning has been diluted to as the author states, 'a floor show'.

Perhaps shows like Bridezillas are at least partially accountable for this perception.  There have always been those can well afford these large affairs and have a social/family dynamic where this kind of event is expected.  They are who they are.

As a low-maintenance dame, my first choice would have been a small, simple ceremony but unlikely if you are of Greek descent and part of a huge family.  I was happy my closest friends/relatives could be part of the bridal party.  We were all just starting our careers 26 years ago and money was tight then, too.  It would not have occurred to me to expect more than their agreement to purchase their dress.  

I remember my Dad's (a very experienced chef) counsel:  people always remember good food, good music, and great hospitality--they won't remember the color of the flowers on the table.    We found a place that was very reasonable, had a big dance floor, food that would appeal to most everyone (with a large crowd, often the basics work best).  

Years later, our friends and family still comment on how much fun they had at our wedding.  It is the best compliment you can receive!

I read the comments and wonder how any bride could expect her parents to pay for her wedding?  I was married in April of 1969 and according to the norm, the brides' family paid for the wedding. BUT, my parents had three other children still at home to care for and I planned and paid for my own wedding.  Of course, the prices in 1969 are not the prices now, but I had the wedding of my dreams and my choices for $700.00 or less.  I am still married to the groom and have 2 daughters which grew up with the idea that if I could have a nice wedding and pay for it that they could also.

So far one daughter has done so and even with more people attending managed to keep her total cost to less than $3000.00.  She spent over $500.00 on her dress and had to rent a place for the reception, but had a lovely wedding as her pictures prove.

My contributions were making the bridesmaids dresses and some spirits for the receiption. She was very happy with her wedding and proud that she paid for what she wanted on her own.  ( I was also!)  Now only one daughter to go and she swears that she is just getting married by a judge and will use her money for a honeymoon trip to New Zealand.  She isn't engaged yet so that may change but she still knows that she will make the decisions and handle the expenses with encouragement from her parents...not an open checkbook.

Abby is a thoughtful friend and her husband is lucky to have such a practical lady!

Houses and wealth are inherited from parents, but a prudent wife is from the LORD.

Proverbs 19:14

This post is obviously late, but...

The best advice I received when my husband proposed was..

Put more energy into planning your marriage than your wedding and everything will work out in both endevors.

We had 308 people attend our wedding and the final total, including location, food, bar, DJ, Photographer, cake, flowers, dresses (Mine & M.O.H) Tuxes (Hubby's & Best Man), hair & makeup.. you name it...  $3750.  And it ROCKED!

Hee!  Cheapass (and I use that term endearingly) weddings are the best!  Eight years later I'm very proud of our less than $1000 wedding.  But Abby remembers ;0)

I checked out your daughter's blog and I must say (no offense) that that is one horribly designed website.  The information is useful and practical but the website is absolutely horrible.  I suggest that she redesign the site.  Thanks for the helpful info!

Instead of renting tuxedos, every man in the wedding party wore a dark suit.  Those who didn't own one could purchase one for about the price of renting a tux.  We bought neckties and matching pocket square to dress up the suits at solidcolornecktie.com and paid $6/each for ties and hankies that looked like satin.  The men looked phenomenal and each walked away from the ordeal with something he could use for the rest of his life, attending other weddings, funerals, etc

Interesting article & feedback!  My husband & I had a whirlwind romance & married within 6 months of meeting each other (4 month engagement).  Our wedding & reception cost about 4K and was paid off before we said "I Do".  We had a very low-budget honeymoon - thanks to the generous loan of a Kentucky "cabin" :)  We have been married almost 11 years & thoughout that time there have been plenty of opportunities to second-guess our "lack of budget" or rush to the altar. But when it comes down to it, we are married & still love each other.  And since my father-in-law was a wedding photographer, we have beautiful pictures to remind us that, despite society's high standard for the perfect wedding, we too had a lovely day that reflects who we are.  Which, isn't that the most important thing about a wedding?!

I agree! You don't have to spend a ton.  My husband and I decided to get married in my parents' living room, my dad is a minister so he officiated the ceremony, I bought a gorgeous vintage 1930's dress on eBay for $150, and we only had 15 guests.  We decided to keep it to immediate family only, as we felt our only other option was to invite everyone and expect 300-400 people.  My sister made our wedding cake, we hired a photographer, and we paid a total of $2500 for the whole wedding.  I should say my parents paid that amount.  They gave us the remaining $2500 that they would have been willing to spend, and that along with the money my husband's parents gave us for the honeymoon let us have an amazing 2 weeks in NYC!  We spent more on our honeymoon than wedding, came home debt free and sent the leftover money to pay down debt.  We are SO happy that we did it this way.  

My fiance and I are not having a huge wedding and we couldn't be happier!  We opted for a wedding chapel in Helen, GA, we can have ten guests, no attendants, they provide the pastor, the champagne toast, traditional vows and music, our cake and use of the facility for an hour.  All that's left is me getting my dress and flowers.  We're getting out on the cheap and because we decided to do this, his aunt and uncle(who would have paid for our reception) bought us a honeymoon in Bermuda!  I didn't expect a bachelorette party, but my best friend(and Honorary Maid of Honor) volunteered to throw me one anyway.  She's in a medical masters program so I know she won't be spending a lot, but it will still be a blast!

Send a Comment

Comments must be directly related to the blog entry. Comments with offensive language will be deleted. Your e-mail address won't be displayed.

(please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):